4 ms·
Somehow the rest of the internet was sold to the idea of "EU is forcing you to put cookie banners, these are nothing but annoyance" rhetoric. Whoever pulled th
by mrtksn 6y ago
Somehow the rest of the internet was sold to the idea of "EU is forcing you to put cookie banners, these are nothing but annoyance" rhetoric. Whoever pulled that off, bravo!
In reality, the idea was to make people aware that they are being tracked across the web and and give them options and somehow everyone pretended that "No tracking, no banners" is not an option.
I am so glad that GitHub is coming forward and point out the elephant in the room: You don't need cookie banners or tracking consent forms if there's nothing to consent.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoI am pretty sure that they are still tracking you - but Microsoft can easily afford to do tracking in-house...
- mrtksn 6y agoWhat do you mean by in house tracking?
- BlueTemplar 6y agoAcross Microsoft services like Github, Office365, Bing, LinkedIn, Windows...
- mrtksn 6y agoyes but what does it mean tracking? having an account? keeping a tab of last time you used it?
- BlueTemplar 6y agoSome identifier tied to a time and "place" (service)?
- mrtksn 6y agoTo do what exactly?
- vrperson 6y agoLearn at what moment your defenses are down so that they can sell you stuff, presumably. Isn't that the general assumption about tracking? Or sell your data to interested parties. Maybe if you liked certain GitHub repos, you are more likely to vote Democrat or whatever.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoI'm not sure that the GDPR really cares what is being done with that information? It cares more about who that information is being shared with, and about your consent.
- rlpb 6y agoDoing "tracking in-house" does not exempt you from GDPR requirements. The requirement is exactly the same: explicit and freely given consent is required to collect extra private information not specifically necessary to provide the service requested.
- chubs 6y agoIn this case, is github uncompliant now? They say they're not doing third-party tracking but the blog post seems to hint that they're doing their own tracking.
- rlpb 6y agoThat depends on what personal data they're collecting and for what purpose, in the case that a person hasn't explicitly opted-in by giving consent freely. I don't think it's possible for us to figure those details out exhaustively merely by observation from the outside.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoYes, and it's not like the EU is going to send surprise inspections to go dig into Microsoft's code and databases to check whether they are violating this or not?
- fwip 6y agoSure, but it's also likely that Microsoft's lawyers allowed the Github team to do this if they didn't think that Github was still in compliance.
- rlpb 6y agoThey don't send surprise inspections to your house to check if you're engaging in criminal activity, either. My point is that you're moving the goalposts. Law enforcement generally always requires a complaint that justifies an investigation, and people and organisations get away with breaking the law all the time. However that has nothing to do with whether or not GitHub put their website behind a "consent" wall, or whether or not they're doing in-house as opposed to contracted-out analytics.
- closeparen 6y ago>We use Usage Information and Device Information to better understand how our Users use GitHub and to improve our Website and Service. https://docs.github.com/en/free-pro-team@latest/github/site-policy/github-privacy-statement#githubs-global-privacy-practices https://docs.github.com/en/free-pro-team@latest/github/site-...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- d0gbread 6y agoI think you mean "you don't need cookie banners if you have your own identifier" which they certainly do and affords them the luxury of this blog post.
- kzrdude 6y agoAnd add to that, they have paying customers.
- mrtksn 6y agoThat's the idea. You visit GitHub and github knows about it, not Facebook, not your local advertisement agency, not the data brokers. Also, these identifiers are not forged in the fire of Mordor, you can have your identifier too.
- harha 6y agoMeanwhile more and more websites are adding “legitimate interest” controls to ads and analytics, as a way to keep them activated. It’s so absurd from a user perspective, they even have separate controls for normal and legitimate interest ads. I wouldn’t be surprised if the sales teams at Google, criteo etc told them to do so off the record. Every time I see the banner I think is it really necessary to visit the website? So I’m also quite happy about this move by GitHub.
- tonymet 6y agothey are an annoyance because they are redundant, out of band, and pass the burden onto individuals who have no authority. They are like CA Prop 65 lead warnings: useless spam that everyone ignores.
- jimmaswell 6y ago>"EU is forcing you to put cookie banners, these are nothing but annoyance" rhetoric I came to the conclusion myself. I personally see no real need for laws like GDPR and see humanity dealing with cookie banners every day and lost ability for websites to be profitable as pure negatives.