3 ms·
> Perhaps the existing, "floats on water Navy" feels abandoned and unregarded because their only remaining function is to be a cover story? I wouldn't say "cov
by derefr 6y ago
> Perhaps the existing, "floats on water Navy" feels abandoned and unregarded because their only remaining function is to be a cover story?
I wouldn't say "cover story." The boats — especially the subs — are still pretty crucial to a lot the Navy's functions. Laying/tapping undersea cables, for example; or shipping and escorting classified cargo and workers to set up bases and outposts
Think of it like: an Army Engineering Corps is just a bunch of skilled labor that can march around. A Naval Engineering Corps, meanwhile, is a bunch of skilled labor and a handy, defended floating base full of heavy equipment and building material.
The Navy hasn't been about "gun boats" in the sense of "boats that themselves project power" for a while; but the Navy's boats do still need to be "gun boats" in the sense of being fortresses that can defend themselves from a nation-state trying to claim the big pools of mobile resources they house.
- ak217 6y agoWhat a strange take. SSBNs remain the ultimate weapon and most naval warfare is geared toward either neutralizing enemy SSBNs or missile attack (a Burke can carry 5+ times more armament than a B-52 and stay on station for months). The Navy has a logistics arm and a spec ops arm, just like the other branches do, but their core capability revolves around SSBNs.
- derefr 6y agoSure, but that’s like saying the Secret Service’s main job is to protect the President against assassination. Sure, they do that — and if their budget were heavily constrained, that’s the one thing they wouldn’t be able to de-prioritize doing — but with their budget as large as it is, they don’t spend most of their time or resources doing that. And, just the same, the Navy doesn’t spend most of its time, budget, or manpower on “naval warfare”! What naval warfare the Navy does accomplish, can almost be seen as a secondary concern to the larger purpose the US government puts the Navy to: serving as a logistics and spec ops arm through which the non-military departments of the Executive can accomplish military goals. Who runs and mans the Hawaii Cryptologic Center? The Navy. Guantanamo Bay? Technically a Naval base. All our spy satellites? Naval. That kind of thing, when you add it all up, costs more money, and has more military members working on it, than all the actual direct war-fighting the Navy gets up to.