3 ms·
I would guess that the vast majority of free software is written and paid for by corporations.
by chrisseaton 6y ago
I would guess that the vast majority of free software is written and paid for by corporations.
- pornel 6y agoIt is, but when you have ability to modify or fork a project, it is an insurance against corporations adding anti-features.
- chrisseaton 6y agoBut the corporations gave you that ability to modify or fork their code in the first place.
- abetusk 6y agoIs it? I would really like a reference for that claim. Maybe you're confusing the free time that developers have because of their corporate jobs to create FOSS, but this is not the same as directly writing and paying for FOSS by corporations. This gets complicated because are you talking about volume of code created or are you weighing code by its use? Anyway, you might be right, I don't know, but my assumption is that FOSS is mostly developed in spite of lack of corporate resources, not because of it.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Maybe you're confusing the free time that developers have because of their corporate jobs to create FOSS, but this is not the same as directly writing and paying for FOSS by corporations. Massive companies everywhere have thousands and thousands of people collectively working all day on free software as their main job. You’re probably using a free software browser from a corporation right now?
- xenocyon 6y ago> You’re probably using a free software browser from a corporation right now? Free (as in 'free beer') is not the same as FOSS.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Free (as in 'free beer') is not the same as FOSS. Who said it was? Chrome, Safari, Firefox are all primarily FOSS - they have some proprietary trademark and minor components, but the actual browser core in each is FOSS.
- crpatino 6y agoI'd have to disagree... https://policies.google.com/terms https://policies.google.com/terms https://www.apple.com/legal/internet-services/terms/site.html https://www.apple.com/legal/internet-services/terms/site.htm... Maybe there's some code that at one point was FOSS in those products, but the products themselves are nor Free. IMHO a code base that has been forked from a FOSS project cannot be considered FOSS itself even if they keep retrofitting changes back to the original, because you cannot know what is there in the proprietary part. This is specially true if you distribute the derivative product only in binary form.
- chrisseaton 6y agoYou're hell-banned, by the way. But you're also wrong. The trademarked Chrome distribution is built from the free Chromium, where main-line development is done. They don't dump changes over the wall like you're suggesting. That's the same for WebKit and Firefox.
- crpatino 6y agoReally, hell banned? Go figure. I assume you at least can still read me. BSD and MIT licenses are Open Source but not Free, they are more concerned with providing a claim of ownership to the author than with the freedom of the user. LGPL is a backdoor to let Free Software interact with non Free Software, which is a good thing too. If your product uses Free Libraries, no big deal, the more the merrier. But you cannot claim it is also Free y proxy.
- chrisseaton 6y ago
- abetusk 6y agoI'm using Firefox, so, yes, I'm using software directly funded by a corporation. My point wasn't that big corporations don't fund FOSS, it's that I would think the vast majority of FOSS, measured in either lines of code or in '(lines of code) x (processing cycles used)' is done via non corporate backed contributions. We also have to be careful about what we define as a 'corporation'. You're clearly putting non-profits under that category and that may be fair, I don't know, but for non-profit corporations that have a large portion of their income in the form of donations or have been created with the specific charter of promoting, developing or maintaining FOSS, it seems pretty disingenuous to lump them into the same 'corporate' category. It gets further complicated if you consider colleges and universities as corporations. Here are some links that may help move the discussion, though they don't answer the question head on (as far as I can tell): * https://www.quora.com/Has-anyone-ever-tried-to-estimate-the-market-value-of-top-open-source-software https://www.quora.com/Has-anyone-ever-tried-to-estimate-the-... * https://www.linux.com/news/study-open-source-worth-387-billion-savings/ https://www.linux.com/news/study-open-source-worth-387-billi... * https://octoverse.github.com/2016/ https://octoverse.github.com/2016/ * https://thenewstack.io/week-numbers-data-lots https://thenewstack.io/week-numbers-data-lots * https://www.techrepublic.com/article/who-contributes-most-to-open-source-the-answers-will-definitely-surprise-you/ https://www.techrepublic.com/article/who-contributes-most-to... * https://redmonk.com/dberkholz/2013/04/22/the-size-of-open-source-communities-and-its-impact-upon-activity-licensing-and-hosting/ https://redmonk.com/dberkholz/2013/04/22/the-size-of-open-so... * https://www.techrepublic.com/article/for-50-percent-of-developers-open-source-is-a-9-to-5-job/ https://www.techrepublic.com/article/for-50-percent-of-devel... Some estimates put the Linux kernel at around $300B+. The above links measure contributions from various companies, of which Microsoft (who now owns GitHub) and Mozilla make the top 10. There needs to be some work done to figure out the actual answer the question ("do corporations fund/create the majority of FOSS?"), including figuring out what aspects of the question are actually valid, like whether it's code used or code created, what counts as a 'corporation' etc. Like I said, I don't actually know but this is something that I had a bias towards believing that FOSS excelled in spite of corporate backing instead of because of it. I'll say it again: citation needed.
- 533474 6y agoNo citations, the linux kernel succeeded because of GPLv2. A rather better term would be FLOSS [1] [1]: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/floss-and-foss.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/floss-and-foss.en.html
- colejohnson66 6y agoThere are quite a few FOSS projects that have developers who are paid to work on them. The biggest is Linux. But to claim that the vast majority are? I’d say that’s wrong.
- jabl 6y agoSure, but you somehow have to weight the size and/or importance of the project as well. If you count in all the not-updated-in-the-past-5-years 50-line projects on github, yes you might find that hobbyist coders are behind the largest number of FOSS projects, but that's a rather silly conclusion.
- max_ 6y agoThey mean "free" as in freedom not free beer.
- chrisseaton 6y agoNo that’s what I mean as well. Corporations wrote tons of free as in freedom software. You’re probably using a corporate free software browser right now? The idea that free software is a niche done by amateurs is wrong. Most people who work on Linux are paid to do so. Same for Chrome, same for Java, same for LLVM, etc etc all the way up the stack. Free software won, and we have the corporations who funded it to thank.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- colejohnson66 6y agoLinux was started by someone because they could, not because they were paid. Sure, if a project (like Linux) gets big enough, corporations will throw money at developers who work on it, but by and large, FOSS is done by unpaid people. If the majority were paid, GIMP would be on par with Photoshop, Inkscape with Illustrator, etc. But they’re not on par because they don’t have corporations throwing millions of dollars at them like Adobe does.
- chrisseaton 6y agoHave you ever been somewhere like FOSDEM? Next time walk around and ask people if this is their full time job. In most of the rooms I’m in, it’s everyone’s corporate full time job and they’re there on corporate expense accounts. It’s just not the case that most projects are just random hobbies these days, and it’s bad for the movement to keep pretending it is. It’s grown up and corporations invested - that’s a good thing!
- colejohnson66 6y agoNo. I haven’t been to FOSDEM and I’d bet the majority of FOSS developers haven’t. And that’s the point. Just because you experience a lot of people getting paid to do it doesn’t mean “the vast majority” are. I guess we’re just arguing past each other. I agree it’s good to recognize money in the industry (many have an aversion to it because of EEE fears), and I also agree that the majority of successful projects are done by paid people. I guess that’s the disconnect: I’m looking at all projects, not just the successful ones.
- worik 6y agoThat is the original idea IIRC. The companies that make the hardware should fund the software.
- jangid 6y agoPerhaps, I am in a minority then.