3 ms·
Your arguments about pirates stealing food from the mouths of the workers are valid and can be accepted as long as you define as pirates those who sell or distr
by adrian_b 6y ago
Your arguments about pirates stealing food from the mouths of the workers are valid and can be accepted as long as you define as pirates those who sell or distribute copies of something for which they do not own the copyright.
Nevertheless, the American copyright laws and all the similar laws that were introduced in other countries, as a result of US bribing or blackmailing, are profoundly flawed and it is completely beyond my understanding how such laws could have been voted by so-called rational beings.
Neither the act of making copies or any device that can be used to make copies have anything to do with piracy or copyright infringement. All the laws that say otherwise are wrong and they have no rational basis.
Only the act of transferring copies to a third party can rationally be incriminated.
It is absurd to define copyright infringement as making copies and to consider this as a crime.
Making copies of any information that you own is a fundamental right, not a crime. If you cannot make copies, then you certainly do not own it. The support of any information will sooner or later self-destruct, so, if the information had not already been copied, you will lose your property.
Some people are happy to just rent information for a limited time, but I find that unacceptable. I am not even interested in viewing a rented movie, instead of buying it. I do not want to forget anything, unless I decide to do that, so if the owner does not want to sell it, i.e. in a form that can be copied, then I do not pay money for it in another form.
If the information owner claims that he is selling it, not renting it, but the product is copy-protected, that should be considered as fraud. If the law says otherwise, the law is wrong.