5 ms·
Again, I'm not really trying to defend Google one way or the other. At the end of the day it seemed like Gebru published a paper that was quite critical of how
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
Again, I'm not really trying to defend Google one way or the other. At the end of the day it seemed like Gebru published a paper that was quite critical of how Google intends to make a sizable portion of their revenue, and anyone should understand that when you do that in a large company, it's going to get extra scrutiny. And it could very well be that the whole purpose of Google's "ethical AI" team in the first place is to just provide a "veneer of morality" over what are some fairly unnerving practices and consequences of AI. But regardless, the honorable thing then for anyone on that team is to simply resign, say that "I don't agree with Google's values", and find someplace else to do your work (it's not like these people couldn't get highly paid jobs elsewhere). Instead they're throwing tantrums.
- panpanna 6y agoSo basically Gebru was fired for turning Googles fake ethics group into a real ethics group?
- cbozeman 6y agoWell, its like HR. The Ethics group is there to shield the company, not the customer. Apparently she didn't understand that.
- googlethrow3134 6y agoShe wasn’t fired for trying to publish the paper. She threatened to resign if her demands were met, so Google pre-empted it by accepting her resignation. The narrative around her being “fired” is completely false and is a lie that needs to be stopped in its track.
- baron_harkonnen 6y agoSo do you honestly believe that if Gebru were to interview at another company and they performed a background check asking why her last position was terminated if she put "voluntary" it would come back with no problems? Do you likewise honestly think that if she applied for unemployment services in the US should we be denied because of willful termination from her last job? Everyone I know who has been fired, when it's reported to the company, the phrasing is always "Person X and the company have come to a mutual agreement", but in my experience it's never really mutual. I've known many coworkers that threaten to quit over issues, but it still depends on them making that choice formally. Otherwise they are fired.
- thu2111 6y agoHer paper didn't make any reasonable points about real ethics, it was mostly wafer thin pseudo-intellectual moralising of the form "but what about the trees!" without any attempt at rigorous cost/benefit analysis. At its core ethics is about balances and tradeoffs: something creates some problems for one person, but creates some benefits for another person, is it moral? Is it right? As a consequence her paper made a lot of points that came across as absurd like railing against models due to the electricity cost of training them, even though those costs are small relative to completely ordinary things everyone takes for granted, like driving to work and back.
- free_rms 6y agoIt's fascinating how nobody can say how this paper was such an ethical stab in the heart for Google, it's all about process. The paper's out there! You can read it!
- Nullabillity 6y agoThe "honorable thing to do" would be to let them window-shop until they find someone willing to rubberstamp whatever they want?
- pron 6y agoWouldn't the honourable thing be to first try to change how Google behaves and only if unsuccessful resign? Why is the assumption that employees shouldn't even try to influence the direction of their company? Why is doing so considered a tantrum?
- microtherion 6y ago> first try to change how Google behaves By, say, attempting to publish papers and have internal discussions about it?
- pron 6y agoI don't have all the facts here and neither, I believe, do you, and we don't know what recourses have been tried. My point is just that I find strange the view that the company is entitled to do anything as long as it's legal while employees aren't, and are expected to either leave or stay and shut up.
- microtherion 6y agoI think we're entirely in agreement on this. I would say that in all jobs, it's more honorable to first try to change the company rather than quit silently, but if your job description encompasses "ethics" or "compliance", it's pretty much a dereliction of duty to quit without even trying to change policies one finds wrong.
- throwaway316943 6y agoThere is a huge difference between skillfully navigating the internal politics and procedures of a company vs issuing demands based on flimsy evidence/feelings and threatening to take your toys and go home if you don’t get your way (and then throwing a social media tantrum when they call your bluff and accept your resignation).
- pron 6y agoSure, and maybe they misjudged their power and overplayed their hand, but why is it that the law is the only guidance for management while employees are held up to a higher standard? If management can do anything as long as it's legal, so can the workers.
- woah 6y agoGoogle claims to be a place where academics can do research. Censoring a critical paper goes against that. I’m not a fan of Timnit, but in this case she is right to make a stink. It’s not like her job was to write ad copy.
- xvedejas 6y agoIs "having standards for what Google pursues for publications" really censorship? I think we'd need additional evidence to say so. If this isn't the first paper Google has stopped when an internal anonymous reviewer gives the red light, it sounds like they're just following their own process for quality control. Maybe the debate should be whether it is the best process for quality control.
- dannyw 6y agoMaybe we live in completely different worldviews, but an academic on an Ethical AI team’s primary obligation should be academic honest and integrity. If the truth damages the company, then that is the company’s fault, not the academic’s fault.