6 ms·
Wow, Google's ethical AI group sounds like the most toxic group of individuals I've ever heard of. I'm going to sidestep the debate about whether Gebru was "fi
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
Wow, Google's ethical AI group sounds like the most toxic group of individuals I've ever heard of.
I'm going to sidestep the debate about whether Gebru was "fired" or she "resigned", because that debate primarily centers on how one defines the words. But clearly she did do this: She sent a letter that made a bunch of (IMO) outrageous demands, outrageous because it essentially attacked other people at the company, and said that if her demands were not met, that she would leave. In this case, the ethical AI group is doing the same thing: demanding a manager not have a role with them, demanding (again IMO) unwarranted apologies from other people, and worse, demanding the rehiring of someone has shown that she has no respect for others in her workplace.
A bunch of overpaid toxic babies from my opinion. I don't care who you are, going around demanding "my way or the highway" in a large company just makes you an asshole. If they don't like what happened they should simply resign with integrity and move on.
- woah 6y agoGoogle tried to prevent her from publishing a paper, which is outside of their normal practice, then dissembled about what happened (pretending internal reviewers are anonymous, for example)
- holidayacct 6y agoWhat was the topic of the paper?
- uh_uh 6y agoDidn't they push back on the publication because the paper was lacking in certain regards? IIRC it failed to take into account relevant recent papers, for example. Which probably could have been fixed if they didn't submit as late as they did.
- GVIrish 6y agoThe paper was submitted on time, other papers at Google were submitted for review after they were released. By Jeff Dean's own admission the paper was approved for release. The demand for retraction was initially given while refusing to state what the reason(s) for the demand were. Only after the meeting where they demanded she retract the paper did they belatedly agree to read her the feedback that they stated as the reason. They wouldn't even let her read it first hand. Ultimately it seems like Google could have plainly stated their issues with the paper from the start, and that said issues were not so serious that they merited a demand for retraction. There are a number of things that just don't add up. Even if you take it at face value that Gebru's ultimatum demands were unreasonable, there are several problems with how the situation got to that point in the first place.
- uh_uh 6y agoExcerpt from Jeff Dean's email: > Timnit co-authored a paper with four fellow Googlers as well as some external collaborators that needed to go through our review process (as is the case with all externally submitted papers). We’ve approved dozens of papers that Timnit and/or the other Googlers have authored and then published, but as you know, papers often require changes during the internal review process (or are even deemed unsuitable for submission). Unfortunately, this particular paper was only shared with a day’s notice before its deadline — we require two weeks for this sort of review — and then instead of awaiting reviewer feedback, it was approved for submission and submitted. > A cross functional team then reviewed the paper as part of our regular process and the authors were informed that it didn’t meet our bar for publication and were given feedback about why. It ignored too much relevant research — for example, it talked about the environmental impact of large models, but disregarded subsequent research showing much greater efficiencies. Similarly, it raised concerns about bias in language models, but didn’t take into account recent research to mitigate these issues. We acknowledge that the authors were extremely disappointed with the decision that Megan and I ultimately made, especially as they’d already submitted the paper. I'm curious: why is ignoring too much relevant research not a good reason to demand retraction? Isn't this one of the most common embarrassing mistakes that inexperienced researchers tend to make? I can fully understand if Google does not want to associate itself with work that might be viewed by the wider research community as shoddy.
- tomdell 6y agoThat claim by Jeff Dean has been more or less debunked. The real reason that Google demanded the paper not be published is that it is critical of models underlying the company’s fundamental business - the whole message from Jeff Dean is very misleading and states a bunch of other, unrelated things as the “real reason”.
- zaroth 6y agoIt would be very helpful to point to sources for the claim that Jeff Dean's explanation is debunked, rather than just claiming it has been. The timing of the submission for review, and the deadline for submission to publication seems like a simple factual statement that should be easily demonstrated as true or false.
- woah 6y agoAccording to current and former Google employees on various machine learning forums, Google does not do an academic review on their employee’s papers. That is the job of the journal reviewers. Google usually just checks whether any proprietary IP has accidentally made it in. For them to claim anything different is comically dishonest.
- Nimitz14 6y agoNot true, see christian's tweet. It's also obvious that a paper like this one will receive more scrutiny than a technical one.
- red_admiral 6y agoI'm not sure what did or did happen in this case, but I've reviewed enough papers and seen enough of my own reviewed that I know "failed to take into account relevant recent papers" is one of many ways a reviewer who wants to shoot a paper down for BS reasons can use. To be clear, reading that reason in a negative review can mean at least two things, and I'm not judging which of the two happened here: 1. The paper did fail to take into account the results in some highly relevant and widely cited papers. (I've rejected papers claiming new results myself before now with "this problem was in fact already solved by X, published in Y".) 2. The paper was fine, but it didn't cite every paper published recently on the topic ever, and someone used that to shoot it down for whatever BS reason. Matt Might calls these reviewers snipers: http://matt.might.net/articles/peer-fortress/ http://matt.might.net/articles/peer-fortress/
- InsomniacL 6y agoEven if the internal reviews aren't anonymous, if you send your manager a letter demanding something or you're leaving, they're probably not going to give you it regardless.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoAgain, I'm not really trying to defend Google one way or the other. At the end of the day it seemed like Gebru published a paper that was quite critical of how Google intends to make a sizable portion of their revenue, and anyone should understand that when you do that in a large company, it's going to get extra scrutiny. And it could very well be that the whole purpose of Google's "ethical AI" team in the first place is to just provide a "veneer of morality" over what are some fairly unnerving practices and consequences of AI. But regardless, the honorable thing then for anyone on that team is to simply resign, say that "I don't agree with Google's values", and find someplace else to do your work (it's not like these people couldn't get highly paid jobs elsewhere). Instead they're throwing tantrums.
- panpanna 6y agoSo basically Gebru was fired for turning Googles fake ethics group into a real ethics group?
- cbozeman 6y agoWell, its like HR. The Ethics group is there to shield the company, not the customer. Apparently she didn't understand that.
- googlethrow3134 6y agoShe wasn’t fired for trying to publish the paper. She threatened to resign if her demands were met, so Google pre-empted it by accepting her resignation. The narrative around her being “fired” is completely false and is a lie that needs to be stopped in its track.
- baron_harkonnen 6y agoSo do you honestly believe that if Gebru were to interview at another company and they performed a background check asking why her last position was terminated if she put "voluntary" it would come back with no problems? Do you likewise honestly think that if she applied for unemployment services in the US should we be denied because of willful termination from her last job? Everyone I know who has been fired, when it's reported to the company, the phrasing is always "Person X and the company have come to a mutual agreement", but in my experience it's never really mutual. I've known many coworkers that threaten to quit over issues, but it still depends on them making that choice formally. Otherwise they are fired.
- googlethrow3134 6y agoIf she didn’t send an ultimatum threatening to resign, she would still be at Google. The reality is that Timnit thrives on drama and attention. That’s how she remains relevant. Look at the way she treated LeCunn, it’s no wonder that we’re in this current situation.
- BitwiseFool 6y agoI've noticed a trend where toxic people hide behind a veneer of a righteous cause, usually something related to social justice. It's effective and usually short circuits the public's willingness to see the nuance of the issue.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoMy term for this is "Karen's twin", i.e. generally you think of a "Karen" as some right wing, extremely disagreeable, potentially semi (or very) racist individual making outrageous demands. Here you just have some left wing, extremely disagreeable people making outrageous demands while wrapping themselves in the cloak of moral superiority.
- zdragnar 6y agoThe "right wing racist" bit is very new. It primarily represents the stereotype of an overly entitled, highly strung soccer mom insisting on talking to managers when she doesn't get her way with front-line employees at retail stores.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nvrspyx 6y agoI think you're conflating "Karen" with "entitled asshole". There are tons of entitled assholes in this world and "Karens" are just one type. As another commenter mentioned, "Karen" is used for entitled, soccer-mom-types, especially for treating front-line workers like crap and attempting to get a manager for their demands. As for the right-wing association, I don't think being right-wing is inherent to being a "Karen". I think that association was borne from the current political climate and viral videos. It's like how in elementary English class they teach that all words ending in -ly are adverbs, but not all adverbs end in -ly: All "Karens" are entitled assholes, but not all entitled assholes are "Karens".
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- claydavisss 6y agoSundar Pichai is a weak leader who has allowed this to fester. Likewise, this anger-mob is just going to continue cashing Google's paychecks anyway. So eventually, the only result will be all the sane people leaving, with Pichai and the Left Mob remaining to passively sneer at each other. If Pichai would just man up, he'd send an all-hands to the company telling everyone to decide by EOD if they want to be on board at Google or standing in the parking lot chanting.
- datavirtue 6y agoReminds me of the recent post about how not to be high-maintenance, directed at wikipedia editors. The demands and fits seem to be a thing plaguing the over-educated. I get mad when I don't have anything to do at work either.
- ashtonkem 6y agoSecondarily, the level of management craft displayed by Google here has been awful. Both in hiring and creating such a situation, and in their inability to effectively defuse it. Probably not a primary cause, but contributory.
- googlethrow3134 6y agoGoogle reaped what it sowed by hiring a toxic employee like Timnit whose had a history of tantrums on Twitter.
- pron 6y agoI don't think anyone would claim corporations are democracies, but the view that the corporation is its CEO and/or its shareholders isn't so obvious, either. There are clearly cultural differences here (e.g. see the situation in Germany [1]), but I don't think that the American view of what a corporation is and who it serves is necessarily the only reasonable one. I don't know any more details on this matter than those in the article, but I don't see why you assume that if employees -- well paid or otherwise -- make demands of management then it must be them who are toxic, or, indeed, that anyone is. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Codetermination_in_Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Codetermination_in_Germany
- mpweiher 6y agoAs a German who has tested the labor laws himself: behaviour such as that displayed would absolutely be grounds for getting fired without the notice period ("fristlose Kündigung") here. And it's actually pretty hard to legally fire people. The reason is "Verlust des Vertrauensverhältnisses", i.e. loss of trust. You start making demands coupled with threats, and public ones at that, you are no longer an employee.
- pron 6y agoBut if employees are well-represented on the board then such actions might not be necessary in the first place. In this case, they might have determined that they have no other recourse to change the company's behaviour. Both firing them or dealing with them are expressions of management's political power, and making their demands public is an expression of the political power of those employees, and it's up to both sides to figure out what result is best for them, a result that will likely be determined by the relative political power of the sides. I see no moral prerogative that says that management's exertion of political power is good, but workers' is bad.
- mpweiher 6y agoNo, they are expression of the fact that employees are employed and paid by the company to work for the company. You can agitate against companies all you want, it's a free country. But you can't expect to be paid by them while you do it. Not sure what "morality" has to do with it. EDIT (Since parent added the bit about boards): No, having employee representatives on the board changes nothing about this. The board is legally (and ethically) obligated to work for the benefit of the company.
- jasonvorhe 6y agoThat's quite the statement considering that there's lots of PoC, women, queer people, sexual abuse victims, etc who have been suffering through toxic work environments for ages. What makes this group "the most toxic group" you've ever heard of?
- lawnchair_larry 6y agoConsidering that she has started falsely calling her former coworkers including Jeff Dean a bunch of racists who fired her for being black, I’ll agree that she sounds extremely “toxic” and essentially impossible to have in your team. I don’t really understand where you get the idea that those minority groups have it any worse these days.
- microtherion 6y agoIt appears that some people in her management hierarchy (notably NOT including her direct manager, who thought highly of her) found themselves in conflict with her. Her peers (which is more how I would generally define "coworker") appear to be backing her in this conflict, and blaming management as well. A number of posters (mostly using throwaway accounts) are interpreting this as a group of fair and reasonable managers being beset by the most toxic team that ever toxied in the history of toxicity. I submit that the facts in evidence permit the opposite hypothesis: That it is Google that has difficulties living up to ethical standards of conduct, and that it is the management of the ethical AI team that is not living up to their professional responsibilities. For all the posturing about Social Justice Warriors run amok, the idea that Google has some 'splaining to do about its conduct is not exactly confined to left wing circles, as evidenced e.g. by yesterday's lawsuit filed by Texas et al. And I suspect it's exactly this increased scrutiny that is leading to these ham-handed and probably counterproductive attempts to first hire "ethical AI" teams and then try to silence their output.
- renewiltord 6y agoThis is just how you behave: when faced with opposing pressure you roll over. That's fine, I do the same in some situations: I don't fight people who can cause me great damage like police or air stewards or immigration agents. But rolling over all the time is not an optimal strategy. The more power you have, the rarer you should roll over. And of course many without power will see those with power and say "In their place, I'd roll over". Yes, naturally. That's because you don't have any power. So being a pushover comes naturally to you, you've optimized well.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y ago> So being a pushover comes naturally to you, you've optimized well. Talk about damning with faint praise. While my mind is honestly saying "seriously, fuck off", I'll try to put this in a more constructive response. It's not about "rolling over". It's about having the maturity to realize when you are dealing with management, if by your demands you put them in an absolute no-win situation, then you've only screwed over yourself. That no-win situation was the demands by Gebru and the ethical AI team that management throw their colleagues under the bus. Management simply can't accede to that demand without saying to a huge portion of their employees "We're going to trash the reputations of other employees based on who yells the loudest". Gebru and the ethical AI team most probably could have gotten huge portions of what they wanted (perhaps not all, but most), and especially would have better actually implemented the organizational change they say they want, if they hadn't handled the situation so extremely unprofessionally.
- arvindamirtaa 6y ago> She sent a letter that made a bunch of (IMO) outrageous demands Is this letter public? Is there anyway we can see what those demands were? Alternatively, anything that shows that you have indeed read the letter?
- baron_harkonnen 6y agoEven reading just your own, clearly biased, summary, it sounds like you are describing "worker solidarity". People just shrug when "leadership" at a company fires people randomly, places bad managers on good teams, demands unwarranted apologies from workers and makes everyone obey arbitrary demands. But when a group of employees try to take any of these powers into their own hands they are immediately written off as toxic. Tech workers have been fooled into thinking that they are a respected and privileged type of labor. Anyone who has been in the industry long enough has already seen this degrade over the years. A decade ago engineers made much more decisions at companies, had some say in the quality of code and technical direction companies were in. Software devs are still paid well but are increasingly told to keep their heads down and focus on code, and zero consideration will be given to any technical concerns if they remotely impact some PMs quarterly goals. As boot camps ship out more and more "good enough" engineers, and a "just ship it" mentality dominants, quality technical skills become less and less of an advantage. Technical workers squandered their advantage by thinking that some how they really were better than everyone else, and that they would forever enjoy easy employment, high salaries, respect at work and comfortable working condition. In a few years I think most technical workers will see that in the long run Amazon's engineers and Amazon's warehouse employees become more and more a like. Sadly, comments like this show most engineers will still rabidly support management rather than risk rocking the boat, deluded into believing it will extend their privilege in the marketplace just a bit longer.
- bisectable 6y agoYou're raising an ethics concern. Strangely, no self-styled 'ethicist' lavishly employed by BigTech appears to be interested in such a topic. It's almost as if the answer to why BigTech hires a certain brand of loudmouth 'ethicists' is to DDOS the public space and keep questions about economic inequality levels that surpass even the Gilded Era from gaining any traction. https://inequality.org/great-divide/america-2018-more-gilded-america-1918 https://inequality.org/great-divide/america-2018-more-gilded...
- kyleblarson 6y agoI blame academia. Seems like most of these people spend years on degrees in critical theory, the whole time being coddled and told they are victims and never confronted or forced to argue with logic. Then when they leave the bubble of academia and get into the real world they expect the same treatment and the only thing they know how to do is play the victim card.