4 ms·
I don't get the criticism of the guidance being "voluntary". The bigger question is more in compliance, no? That is, if they have compliance rates that are co
by taeric 6y ago
I don't get the criticism of the guidance being "voluntary". The bigger question is more in compliance, no?
That is, if they have compliance rates that are comparable to the countries that do have legal recourse, do we have reason to think legal recourse would have gotten them better compliance?
- learc83 6y agoIf you're talking about wearing masks in public, it looks like their numbers are low--implying that voluntary compliance isn't working great. For an example, I was driving through rural Alabama, which has a state wide mask mandate, and at every convivence store I stopped in, everyone was masked. Right next door in Georgia, which has the opposite of statewide mask mandate (the governor made local mandates illegal), almost no one was masking. The same is true for my home county. There's a mask mandate--everyone wears a mask. Move one county over--no mandate and almost no masks.
- bzb6 6y agoVoluntary compliance is working great: people can do whatever they feel like doing, which is literally the point of voluntary compliance.
- 0-_-0 6y agoOr, the point of voluntary compliance is to balance between personal freedom and infection rate, in which case it's a failure.
- taeric 6y agoI haven't seen reporting on their numbers in compliance. The reporting is mostly like this one, focusing on it being voluntary. But then not stating how effective is otherwise it was. They definitely have high numbers of covid. So does most everyone. :(
- learc83 6y agohttps://www.statista.com/statistics/1114375/wearing-a-face-mask-outside-in-european-countries/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1114375/wearing-a-face-m... As of October--How often have you worn a face mask outside your home to protect yourself or others from coronavirus? Sweden: Always------- 4.3% Not at all-- 76.7% Spain: Always------ 95.8% Not at all-- 0.3%
- taeric 6y agoThanks! Do we know how accurate those are? I confess I have stopped driving on these numbers. Seems way more noise then signal. Death rates, for example, at a naive guidance look worse for Spain. Do you also have a good launch point to get caught up on analysts?
- learc83 6y agoThose numbers are self reported from scientific polls. But a 90+ percentage point difference even when self reported, probably means there's a large difference. >Death rates, for example, at a naive guidance look worse for Spain. Spain is about 4 times as densely populated as Sweden, you'd expect spread and death rates for a communicable disease to be higher.
- taeric 6y agoAgreed on the magnitude. The size of relative spike also looks worse. Such that I really don't know any obvious points to draw. My question on accuracy is more on how well we know the source. A scientific online passive poll is likely still pretty bad. Especially if taken from a partisan audience. Also, just to emphasize. I don't see any obvious points. But that not includes agreeing with the approach Sweden took. I just don't understand much of the reporting focusing on the voluntary aspect without establishing that Sweden had bad compliance with mask wearing.
- learc83 6y ago
- elliekelly 6y agoThis Yale study[1] collected data from every county in the US about which restrictions were in place and then tracked how many people got sick. Their data[2] distinguishes between “mask mandate” and a “mask recommendation” and the study author is quoted that the recommendation “doesn’t do anything”. Of course this is all US data so I’m not sure whether or to what extent it would apply to Sweden’s compliance with a mask recommendation vs mandate. [1]https://insights.som.yale.edu/insights/study-shows-which-restrictions-prevent-covid-19-fatalities-and-which-appear-to-make-things?fbclid=IwAR1OCQaB4LLgO8a-mVmqVDuar_92F8BlRQ1yT507kLuL38QKnl29i5sqjkU https://insights.som.yale.edu/insights/study-shows-which-res... [2]https://som.yale.edu/covid-restrictions https://som.yale.edu/covid-restrictions
- 0x445442 6y agoYep. In order to claim something a failure you need objective criteria to begin with. In terms of Covid those objective criteria never existed and thus the King's claim has as much meaning and weight as mine that Sweden's handling of Covid has been a wild success compared to other countries.
- jgwil2 6y agoThere are many objective criteria: case rate and death rate are just the most obvious.
- 0x445442 6y agoThose two criteria make no case for mask mandates nor lockdowns. Also, looking at those to data points alone is a woefully inadquate model for policy decisions.
- learc83 6y agoThe links in the comment you quoted were evidence in support of mask mandates. "while many of the available interventions work, mask mandates stand out for their effectiveness and relative lack of economic tradeoffs. “Mandatory mask policies seem to be as effective as policies that have higher costs,” says Tookes." The article is saying that mandating masks has a positive impact, but recommending them does nothing.
- jariel 6y agoThis is a fair question. Because I really do feel that systematically, it's not legal enforcement that is the issue. 99% of it seems to me would be workplace orders - if all governments spaces (aka public transit) require masks, and most corporations require public masks, then it's going to be hard to go to to many places without them. Maybe however a lot of individual small restaurants and gyms would flaunt the rules, even under threat of shame, which is maybe understandable since the proprietors are facing basically collapse and losing their entire life's savings etc..