3 ms·
The situation here is that the service was so borked that it didn't know what it didn't know. Hard-failing good addresses is a much worse bad than soft-failing
by dredmorbius 6y ago
The situation here is that the service was so borked that it didn't know what it didn't know.
Hard-failing good addresses is a much worse bad than soft-failing bad addresses. In the latter case, remote sender tries again later and eventually gets a hard bounce. In the former, good addresses are permanently dropped from numerous services, and sent mail is lost rather than retried.
Critical failures should soft bounce until positively determined otherwise.