3 ms·
> Windows Phone, WebOS, Meego and Ubuntu Phone all "failed" around the same time period as Firefox OS. I have a hard time laying blame solely on Mozilla there.
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
> Windows Phone, WebOS, Meego and Ubuntu Phone all "failed" around the same time period as Firefox OS. I have a hard time laying blame solely on Mozilla there.
I've seen a number of comments on Windows Phone since then (on HN), and one and all they emphasize how much better and nicer Windows Phone was -- from a consumer perspective -- than any other phone.
What was the failure? This isn't a retrospective that makes any sense.
- heavyset_go 6y agoI feel the same way about webOS: it was better and nicer than Android or iOS, and we had to wait half of a decade before Android and iOS adopted some of the features it shipped with in 2009. As of 2019, however, 52.4% of the mobile OS market belongs to iOS, and 47% to Android[1]. Neither of our favorite mobile phone OSes have succeeded in comparison. [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/266572/market-share-held-by-smartphone-platforms-in-the-united-states/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/266572/market-share-held...
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> As of 2019, however, 52.4% of the mobile OS market belongs to iOS, and 47% to Android. This doesn't pass the sniff test, unless you're doing something weird like measuring the mobile OS market in dollars spent on phones. > Neither of our favorite mobile phone OSes have succeeded in comparison. To be clear, I have no experience of Windows Phone. I'm just bemused that 100% of comments about what it was like are so glowing. For some other product, you'd expect to see some comments saying "this was the greatest product ever to be commercially available" and some others saying "no, I had one of those, and it sucked". That doesn't seem to happen for Windows Phone.
- cozzyd 6y agoThe source is for the US, where it's at least plausible.
- skinkestek 6y ago> What was the failure? This isn't a retrospective that makes any sense. No YouTube, no Snapchat etc. With YouTube Google used their position to keep it that way. It also wouldn't surprise me if someone told certain app developers that "that's a nice app you have there, it would be shame if there was a bug in the Play store that made it hard ro find". When it comes to App Store I have heard it is pretty well established that you won't get featured, no matter how great your app is if it is available on other platforms.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> No YouTube, no Snapchat etc. > With YouTube Google used their position to keep it that way. YouTube is available to anyone with a web browser, such as people using a smartphone.
- lolinder 6y agoYes, but YouTube on mobile (in Firefox at least) is crippled in comparison to the mobile app or the desktop site, probably intentionally.
- nemothekid 6y ago>What was the failure? This isn't a retrospective that makes any sense. Windows Phone had great, snappy, intuitive UI (which was really surprising coming from Microsoft). However it had no apps. If you look at the top 10 iPhone apps in the app store, only Facebook and Netflix were officially supported on the platform. I recall there being (great) 3rd party apps for apps like Instagram, but there was a dearth of anything else.
- addicted 6y agoWindows Phones biggest problem was a lack of major OEM support. They needed Samsung and HTC to have adopted them at the time.
- addicted 6y agoWebOS wasn’t tried in any meaningful sense. It was abandoned within less than a single product lifecycle by the various companies under which it operated. Windows Phone was an epic disaster in how badly it was rolled out. It was Ballmer at his worst. MS kept oscillating between whether they wanted Windows Phone to be an iPhone competitor or an Android competitor. They picked the worst of all worlds, by choosing to focus on distributing through 3rd party vendors, but refusing to allow them to make any changes to the interface, therefore basically eliminating any major vendors from adopting and promoting Windows Phone. It’s still amazing that MS was unable to unseat Android at a time OEMs were desperate for an Android alternative thanks to the uncertainty around the Oracle lawsuits (and were already paying more to MS than Google for Android! thanks to MS’s OS related patent portfolio). Ubuntu Phone never made any sense, targeting the most expensive niche of the market as it did.
- lenkite 6y agoGoogle forced Microsoft to remove Youtube and other apps. Also Microsoft kept 're-inventing' the phone OS multiple times requiring app authors to keep rewriting the app to new API's. A lot of patent fees paid to Apple and Google for every phone sold. Windows Phone was really good and it had millions of fans. It would probably do well in today's duopoly market if relaunched but MS has lost interest in phones presently.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> What was the failure? This isn't a retrospective that makes any sense. People didn't buy it. Simple as that. Doesn't matter how much better people think the consumer experience is if nobody's buying it.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoExcept that, again, that makes for a completely nonsensical theory of what happened. You can't just say "it was vastly superior to everything else, so it failed because no one would buy it". You need to explain why no one would buy it, because the only data in your model says that people should be buying it in droves.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> You need to explain why no one would buy it I don’t need to do anything! The only thing that matters is people didn’t buy it. It wasn’t a success.