4 ms·
They are keen to claim that it's not a wankel engine.
by pjc50 6y ago
They are keen to claim that it's not a wankel engine.
- lvs 6y agoYeah, but it basically is. The most important difference, as it appears, is they've ported the intake and exhaust through the piston rather than through the block. I don't quite understand the claim that it has a different thermodynamic cycle...
- fastball 6y agoHere is their diagram[1] of the cycle. Wankel engine uses the otto cycle (blue), theirs is what they are calling the High Efficiency Hybrid Cycle, or HEHC (in red). In terms of shape they do seem approx. the same, so when LiquidPiston says theirs is different I think they are just saying it is a more efficient cycle, not fundamentally different in terms of stages. [1] https://uploads-ssl.webflow.com/5f6086e9bbbabd41a20f2984/5f7d7a4ab14f906c57d07892_cycles-1024x676-1-768x507.jpg https://uploads-ssl.webflow.com/5f6086e9bbbabd41a20f2984/5f7...
- lvs 6y agoThanks, that is quite obviously the identical thermodynamic cycle between the two engines.
- cardiffspaceman 6y agoThe rotor in the center of the LiquidMotion device is shaped more like an oval (or race track) while the Wankel rotor is shaped like a bowed-out triangle. The LiquidMotion rotor has volume within that is carries gases, while the Wankel rotor is solid (or at least if it's hollow the volume inside isn't used). I don't recall ever seeing a counterweight on a Wankel but then I'm not even a little acquainted with Wankels in the field so it could be that Mazda forgot to tell me. There is of course the possibility that this is a Wankel as far as patents would say. As different from a Wankel as a true Hemi is from a regular V8.
- lmm 6y agoSomeone above posted https://uploads-ssl.webflow.com/5f6086e9bbbabd41a20f2984/5f6086e9bbbabd8f300f29a9_engine.png https://uploads-ssl.webflow.com/5f6086e9bbbabd41a20f2984/5f6... which gave me a much clearer sense of how this is an "inside-out" Wankel.
- lvs 6y agoThere's nothing inside-out about that design. They've just moved the location of the exhaust/intake porting. It's a neat reconfiguration idea, but it's still a Wankel engine.
- lmm 6y agoInstead of a triangular piston in an oval chamber it's an oval piston in a triangular chamber. Seems pretty inside out to me.
- ben_bai 6y agoYep. Instead of the seals on the rotor, the seals are on the chamber (much better cooling and lubing opportunities). Instead of the intake/exhaust ports in the chamber, the intake/exhaust goes through the rotor (at first...)
- elihu 6y agoThe Mazda RX-8 uses a counterweight. (Actually, on the manual-transmission version it's a flywheel that has a sort of lip around the rim that's thicker on one side than the other.) Aftermarket flywheels are generally symmetrical, with a way of bolting on a separate counterweight piece. (The reason I know this is that I'm working on converting an RX-8 to electric. I got the car cheap with a messed-up engine, and I bought an aftermarket flywheel to replace the lopsided stock one because I don't want the car to shake itself to pieces. I haven't gotten around to ordering the adapter plate yet, but CanEV makes an RX7/8 transmission adapter plate along with two different versions of a coupler that attaches the motor to either a tapered-shaft style flywheel, which is what the car had originally, or a six-bolt variant for some other version of the engine.)