3 ms·
Sheesh, it seems like you would be against everything just because the information can be used for bad things... To use your logic (at least how I'm interpretin
by netsharc 6y ago
Sheesh, it seems like you would be against everything just because the information can be used for bad things... To use your logic (at least how I'm interpreting it), we should also abolish driver licenses as well, because look, there's a database of people! With addresses, etc!
And that would be a bad idea because untrained drivers may cause injury to others. The same logic applies to disease tracking, we have to know because someone might harm someone else. It's being measured so we know if prevention methods like lockdowns and masks are working. And just like a driver's license is not something you can volunteer to have (or not), neither should the knowledge of your virus status be optional.
Imagine running a country and being asked "So, how is your country coping with the virus?", and answering "I don't know, we don't have the numbers."...
- bmeski 6y agoThis is why we here in the US call it a free country. It is very different from the democratic freedoms of other countries. We founded this nation because of misuse of government power. You should always be skeptical of government oversight. Our constitution was written by very bright people who understood that mob rule and government overreach are very easy to fall into. Think of how phishing attempts sometimes use your emotions/anxieties against you, “Urgent, this is your boss, I need your email and PW to log in.” The same fear mongering has been used to shut down schools across the US when there is little statistical evidence showing spread occurs in schools. Many other nations know this and kids are still going to school. This is a prime example of when government overreach is entirely misguided and political. Edit: Thank goodness we still have free speech here. I fear many of our freedoms can easily be eradicated by the, “saving just one life,” argument. Edit edit: Also not trying to be too inflammatory but China has all the data in the world and they fudged the numbers they sent out. We already have entirely data driven societies and you can ask Hong Kong how much they wanted it.
- netsharc 6y agoYour edit edit basically is what I argued against in my original reply.. "China gathers data, China abuses data, therefore all data gathering is baaaad!". As for the rest of your response, eh, this is reddit-level response, but: standard "American exceptionalism" masturbation. The sooner you figure out you're nothing special, the sooner the world will be a better place.
- Talanes 6y agoIf people just don't test because they don't want to give info to the government, that's not an information gain for the government, it's just a loss for everybody else.
- pdonis 6y ago> that would be a bad idea because untrained drivers may cause injury to others One can always justify more government power and more government micromanagement of people's lives by claiming it will prevent some hypothetical harm. Here in the United States we're not supposed to accept that. > Imagine running a country Imagine having a country where no one person or small group of people gets to "run" things--where, instead, every adult citizen is assumed to be responsible for their own life and their own actions, and to suffer appropriate consequences if they cause harm to someone else. Where nobody is allowed to just declare by fiat what everyone else has to do or can't do. Where collective action is done by reasonable people persuading other reasonable people that a particular course of action is best for all, not by some people just dictating to everyone else what the "right" thing to do is. The United States of America is supposed to be that kind of country.
- netsharc 6y agoGeez, you can fantasize all you want but that's not what we currently have. As Donald Rumsfeld said (I think he's a war criminal but at least what he said here makes sense): "You go to war with the army you have, not the army you might want or wish to have at a later time." And governing by ignoring reality is not effective governing, sure you can say "Everyone has to be emancipated and be masters of their own fate!", but again that's not what we have right now, people are dying now. You can't just say "well, in the ideal USA, we just need to inform them how to protect themselves and they'll follow those 'suggestions', so that's what we'll do." because this is not the ideal world and people are too uninformed or have too many self-interests to listen. > A lot of people will call me a Libertarian [a]sshole [...] If you want to to force unusable fantasy world rules in this current world, well...
- pdonis 6y ago> that's not what we have right now In other words, you're saying that most adult Americans today are not capable of managing their own lives and being responsible for their own actions?
- 6y ago