3 ms·
> Devil's advocate: why should I choose this yet-to-exist distribution over something already existing, such as Oracle Linux? Because there's a whole ecosystem
by bayindirh 6y ago
> Devil's advocate: why should I choose this yet-to-exist distribution over something already existing, such as Oracle Linux?
Because there's a whole ecosystem (HPC and Scientific computing to be exact) which depends on CentOS (not RHEL, not Oracle, not Ubuntu, not Debian) primarily. A CentOS compatible distribution is not some FOSS pride thing.
IBM and RH really blew a sucker punch in this regard.
- niea_11 6y agoWhen you say that they depend on CentOS, are they using something CentOS-specific. Centos is supposed to be compatible with RHEL (minus the logos/trademarks) and shouldn't have additional fixes or features. ("bug for bug, feature for feature" <= centos wording :)). No?
- bayindirh 6y agoCentOS don't have to have a specific feature to be preferred over RH. Being free in both beer and speech is important enough. People (incl. us) install 1000+ server clusters with CentOS. The absence of licensing fee allows us to buy more servers. The absence of licensing fee allows "small researchers" to have a verified platform to work with. If you don't have a verified platform, you cannot trust your results. CentOS carries a legacy from Scientific Linux (which was RH compatible too) and has a lot of software packages developed for/on it. It might be a regular .tar.gz or RPM distribution but, they're validated and certified on CentOS. This is enough. Some middlewares used in collaborative projects (intentionally or unintentionally) search for CentOS signature. Otherwise installations fail spectacularly (or annoyingly, it depends). I have to run my own application on every platform with a relatively simple test suite which checks results with 32 significant digit ground truth values. If these tests fail for a reason, then I can't trust my application's results for a particular problem. My code runs fast and it's relatively simple (since it's young). Some software packages' tests can run for days. It's not feasible to re-validate a software every time after compilation on a different set of libraries, etc. CentOS provides this foundation for free.
- niea_11 6y agoThanks for your explanation. I think I understand a little better your point of view. CentOS became so important for the HPC community that most software is now validated against it. So even if RHEL itself were to become free (as in beer), people won't switch to it (or at least be reluctant).
- bayindirh 6y agoExactly. My all personal systems are Debian, however when I install something research related, it's always CentOS. There's no question. I even manage a couple of research servers at my former university. They're CentOS as well. Moreover service (web, git, documentation, etc.) servers are CentOS too to keep systems uniform even if there's no requirement. So it powers the whole ecosystem, not the compute foundation. That's a big iceberg.
- mrtweetyhack 6y agoPeople like you who make a profit but refusing to pay for a license is exactly why Redhat shut down CentOS.
- cyberpunk 6y agoIn 2020 why aren't you packaging your apps as containers? Yeah, it sucks that ibm killed centos, but depending on some single distro's version of libm or libc or whatever is not their fault it's yours. Doing your job properly in this case means shipping you deps with your application, and the easiest way to do that these days is with containers.. Christ; it's either the 90s or kindergarten..
- aetimmes 6y agoAssuming based on GP that this is in a HPC environment, there is often a delineation between the people writing HPC software and the people maintaining the clusters and the software installed on them. Telling a brand-new graduate student with zero software development experience to just throw everything into a container results in running code that is not optimized for the hardware it's running on, which in turn negatively impacts the other users competing for compute time on HPC clusters. There is a movement to incorporate technologies like Singularity into the HPC workflow but for established projects, it often looks like a lot of bikeshedding for negative results compared to just running the code on bare metal.