3 ms·
>It's kind of a prime example of how the scientific model isn't the correct one to be using in the first place. What's your proposed alternative to science for
by whatshisface 6y ago
>It's kind of a prime example of how the scientific model isn't the correct one to be using in the first place.
What's your proposed alternative to science for determining the products of tire breakdown? Asking psychics? Polling facebook moms? Voting on it in Congress?
- hombre_fatal 6y agoUnfortunately, alternatives to science are being pushed right now in the current culture war. Google “other ways of knowing”. Worth pointing out just because your appeal to absurdism (which most of us would agree with) is losing steam in the marketplace of ideas.
- stfp 6y agoLook up scientism. The whole point is we need to accept that no single method will give us this kind of visibility and understanding, and given that fact we should be more careful about certain things, especially things we just seem to keep miscalculating and that have long-lasting, terrible effects. That's actual science vs. commercial/industrial marketing masquerading as science.
- monkeycantype 6y agoThe scientific method enables us to rigorously build models. But it takes effort, so the model only expands in the directions where a person chooses to the do that work. Scientific models are a communal human artefact, flawed with the bias and inattention of those that built them. The is a lot we know about the world, from history, from our experience, that we are not able to express with enough rigor to include them in a scientific model. So we can be confident that our scientific understanding of any new compound, will not gives us a complete understanding of the impact of that compound in the world. From history we have a partial map of our ignorance. We know from past experience that there are realms of unknown - ecological effects, decomposition products, birth defects, health impacts - associated with new products. We know there is a very big difference between safe and no known adverse impacts Rather than an alternative to science, we need a more vigorous meta model, better appreciation of where the model ends, and a better model for how we should act given our ignorance. I don't think we lack the ability to do this, it's a matter of will and power.
- whatshisface 6y ago>The is a lot we know about the world, from history, from our experience, that we are not able to express with enough rigor to include them in a scientific model. Of course, gut feeling and "pontification-based" methods still have to prove themselves effective. You would need to have one group pontificate about the future using your meta-level thinking, and another group just focus on the concrete-level, and demonstrate that the proposed meta-model would improve the situation. A system to figure out what scientific discoveries were going to be made before they are made would be nice, but you can't just pick an oracle and say you've found it.
- derbOac 6y agoMaybe what I wrote was misleading or vague. What I mean is that to do a study, you have some model. It's implicit in the way the data is collected, whether that be experiment or observational study. But it's a model with assumptions. The problem is that all models are wrong to varying extents, but often in the scientific community the wrongness of models isn't recognized. You estimate your effect size or the p-value or posterior predictive p or whatever it is, but all those themselves are some estimates based on assumptions, and there's always some probability of being radically incorrect. My concern isn't with science per se, it's that science as a community is often too arrogant and underestimates the extent to which it is likely to be incorrect. I just think critics need to be given more respect, especially when the argument against the critics is "we did a carefully controlled lab study under isolated conditions." Maybe there needs to be a greater meta-scientific perspective with these things, like some policy that explicitly asks "how often when these types of evidence are submitted is something wrong?"