4 ms·
She and Sarte appeared to have been despicable human beings, certainly by modern standards--they made a point of grooming their students for sex. Some even call
by tomcam 6y ago
She and Sarte appeared to have been despicable human beings, certainly by modern standards--they made a point of grooming their students for sex. Some even called her his pimp.
https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2005/09/26/stand-by-your-man https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2005/09/26/stand-by-your-...
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y ago> Beauvoir described meeting Fidel Castro, “a truly exceptional man of intelligence, warmth, vitality, and it is overwhelming when you walk with him to see how much the people adore him”. Sounds like she was also attracted to despicable human beings as well.
- tomcam 6y agoDownvoters should be aware that Castro and Che were bloodthirsty, homophobic, freedom-hating killers who imprisoned journalists by the boatload and literally sent their worst criminals to us on flimsy boats. Of course they "adored" him. That's how you act around a dictator, because you'll be tossed in the gulags if you don't--often, your family too.
- joncrane 6y agoSounds like a pattern that may have been repeated by Ghislaine Maxwell and Jeffrey Epstein.
- xenocratus 6y agoExcellent reading, I had no idea of any of this, thank you for the link.
- claudiawerner 6y agoThis either calls into question 'modern standards' or the interpretation of their actions, from my point of view. They were certainly no saints, but to a couple whose writings ranged from anti-statism, skepticism of morality, and (proto-sex-positive) feminism, I'm not too keen to call them hypocritical, despite that. The intellectual dissonance is not uncommon among philosophers, who generally cannot be expected to behave any more ethically than the rest of us. Unlike moral philosophers and Spinoza, however, de Beauvoir never claimed to be fighting the moral realist's crusade - and after Nietzche, I can't blame her a bit. But to a person like Sartre who subscribes to the maxim that 'morality [...] is but a bourgeois pretension" in the words of one of his intellectual sources, I find more sympathy for him than the grave crime of.. grooming adult students and the ambitions of a New Yorker journalist feeling like he's blowing the lid of the sordid lives of the philosophers. By these words we hang de Beauvoir in a weird game of cancel culture to own the literati because we clicked on an article from 2005 in an American paper.
- tomcam 6y agoI made no claims of hypocrisy. I do feel if they did those things they were not role models, and that they are people I would not enjoy on a personal level--especially around my daughters. BTW it is not "proto sex-positive feminism". They were very late to the game. You can go back to the free love movements of the late 19th century. Whole communities were based on it (and failed) here in the good ol' US of A. Bernard Shaw had a keen interest in these ideas too.
- lawnchair_larry 6y agoInterestingly, she is also responsible for the currently fashionable idea that gender is distinct from sex, and that one is not born with a gender. This had no basis in science of course, but people repeat it now under the assumption that it has always been the case. They have always been synonymous and she literally just made it up and started telling people that gender is performative. Judith Butler latched on to this and took it to extremes with Critical Gender Theory and attacking the “patriarchy”, and started teaching it at Berkeley, which popularized it in the 90s and 2000s. Why anyone listened to these people is a mystery to me.