4 ms·
>The other thing is individual accountability: chemical engineers who facilitate this insanity should be held responsible. How would they be expected to know w
by whatshisface 6y ago
>The other thing is individual accountability: chemical engineers who facilitate this insanity should be held responsible.
How would they be expected to know what the results of their chemical will be? Drug companies focus exclusively on biological effects and can't even get drugs to regularly pass phase 1 trials, and you're asking for a single chemist at Industrial Sealants Inc to do what entire pharma companies can't? Putting lead in gasoline sounds dumb, but so does putting mercury in vaccines. The only way to tell the difference is to do studies, which would take teams of people. It is absolutely not possible to expect individual chemists to accurately predict the biological consequences of their products.
- tehjoker 6y agoMaybe we should have tiered rules for how much testing is done based on the number of tons that are going to be produced and how they are being disposed of. (And if we already do, then the rules for the higher tiers need to be tightened.)
- whatshisface 6y agoGiven the extreme differences in badness per ton I'm not sure if that's a reasonable metric. Maybe instead we could mandate yucca mountain level storage for everything that hasn't been evaluated, and then let companies decide for themselves whether or not they will be making enough of the stuff to justify studying how to dispose of it more cheaply.
- tehjoker 6y agoIt might be possible to establish categories where if your molecule has XYZ properties it falls into this bucket. I think a category for really novel molecules that haven't been evaluated is a good idea with tight restrictions on how much can be produced. There should also be a presumption that minor edits to known dangerous molecules should be presumed dangerous without testing.
- mcguire 6y agoBe careful about diluting responsibility---if everyone can point to someone else, no one will make a hard (and not immediately profitable) decision. In all of those studies, etc., there is someone at the top who does, and should, make the ultimate decision, just like when building a bridge, there is an engineer who puts his career on the line.
- whatshisface 6y agoIf you're going to assign responsibility, you need to assign it to people who know the right decision to make. If you assign responsibility to a janitor or a chemist for any torts set against the company, then janitors and chemists will simply quit working there. The only person who could begin to approach responsibility would be an executive with the authority to organize and pay for clinical trials and toxicity studies.
- ska 6y ago> authority to organize and pay for clinical trials and toxicity studies. But further to that, if said executive does follow regulatory guidance and accepted practice but the product has a problem, should they really be held individually responsible? For the clinical trials example, if a trial fails to turn up a significant problem, is it the exec's fault or the regulators? The regulators or the legislative body?
- whatshisface 6y agoOftentimes, regulatory bodies make companies immune to lawsuits in exchange for compliance. That leads to there being no incentive against creating products that are compliant, yet dangerous. It might be a good idea to reform the system so that harm is the ultimate decider.
- ncmncm 6y agoPutting mercury in vaccines was also dumb. It is impossible to quantify the damage just from the direct consequence of people beginning to avoid vaccines because of it. They don't put mercury in vaccines anymore.
- bsder 6y ago> so does putting mercury in vaccines Putting a known biologically tested and FDA cleared preservative into vaccines is not "dumb". Having to remove said preservative because because people committed medical fraud (and later lost their licenses) to create fear about it and because a bunch of people picked up on it as a desperate, now-negatively validated reason for their child having autism? That's dumb. But the manufacturers did it anyway because people are dumb.
- whatshisface 6y agoYou missed the phrasing slightly. I said they both sound dumb, and it's only testing that can distinguish them. In an alternate universe, it's leaded gasoline that is safe and mercury in vaccines that is poisoning people.
- refactor_master 6y agoBut in this universe, you can eat a can of tuna and have both!