5 ms·
You obviously don't need to pay people to not have kids because the fertility rate is already below the population replacement rate. The hard question would be
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
You obviously don't need to pay people to not have kids because the fertility rate is already below the population replacement rate.
The hard question would be how to maintain the existing programs that provide social assistance to the elderly without a larger population of working people to pay the taxes to fund them. The existing solution is to run preposterously large deficits every year, which seems problematic/unsustainable.
- toomuchtodo 6y ago> The hard question would be how to maintain the existing programs that provide social assistance to the elderly without a larger population of working people to pay the taxes to fund them. The existing solution is to run preposterously large deficits every year, which seems problematic/unsustainable. This boils down to “how much GDP are you willing to burn to keep the elderly cohort comfortable.” How each country handles this demonstrates their ingenuity and character. Can you be both compassionate and efficient? I think so.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoUnfortunately in a democracy it also demonstrates how large a percentage of likely voters are elderly, which also seems like it could cause serious problems during that sort of demographic shift. (Notice that almost everywhere, people over 65 get a vote but people under ~18 don't.)
- giantg2 6y agoWho was that Scottish economist that had a famous quote about something like once the citizens in a democracy realize they have the keys to the treasury they grant themselves services/money?
- dragonwriter 6y agoEconomists have enough trouble trying to predict economic behavior, they probably should be more restrained when branching out of their field into predictive political science.
- giantg2 6y agoEconomists study many things other than "the economy". Quite often they are involved in political or policy studies because many systems act as an economy.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Economists study many things other than "the economy". And, even moreso than is already notoriously the case with the economy, their predictions on those many other things tend to be based on conclusions drawn by abstract reasoning from ideologically-motivated assumptions with little empirical basis that are poor predictors of behavior of the real world.
- giantg2 6y agoIf that's the way you see it, then who do you look for to data? Seems like you can't trust anyone if you can't trust your own evaluation of an individual paper based on statistics.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> If that's the way you see it, then who do you look for to data? The subject of discussion wasn't data, but an abstract behavioral generalization that isn't drawn from data. But I wouldn't generally look to economists as my first source of data on things that aren't the economy, either. > Seems like you can't trust anyone if you can't trust your own evaluation of an individual paper based on statistics When did I ever say anything to which that would even approximately be relevant?
- 6y ago
- renata 6y agoAlexander Tytler, although apparently it may be misattributed: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexander_Fraser_Tytler,_Lord_Woodhouselee#Debatable_attribution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexander_Fraser_Tytler,_Lord_....
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]