3 ms·
With the end-of-statement period, I agree you can make that case, but it's done with other punctuation as well, since the American rule is more of a typographic
by _delirium 16y ago
With the end-of-statement period, I agree you can make that case, but it's done with other punctuation as well, since the American rule is more of a typographical rule than a semantic one (you put low-on-the-line punctuation before high-on-the-line punctuation).
For example:
British: "I would not", he objected, "enjoy that".
American: "I would not," he objected, "enjoy that."
The period is arguably part of the quoted statement as you say, but the comma definitely isn't.
- mike-cardwell 16y agoStrange. I am British and I was taught your American style. And have always done it that way.
- timknauf 16y agoThe British style would actually include the period/full stop in this case, since it's quoted speech and the quoted speech ends with a period.
- RuadhanMc 16y agoHence the "logical" bit. It's not logical to have the period or commas outside of the quote if the quote actually includes a period or comma.