7 ms·
RoboScan: Lego+Raspberry Pi-powered analog film roll scanner
- ingve 6y agoVideo of the newer RoboScan v4 in action: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yRDomN48SOs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yRDomN48SOs
- confiq 6y agothis should be in README.md
- mhasbini 6y agoThe picture in the README is a link to a (older) YouTube video. Self plug: I was annoyed by the lack of indicators: when it's a picture or a youtube link that I created https://mhasbini.com/blog/embed-youtube-in-github.html https://mhasbini.com/blog/embed-youtube-in-github.html E.g. of before & after: https://github.com/bezineb5/RoboScan/pull/2 https://github.com/bezineb5/RoboScan/pull/2
- confiq 6y agoohhh, silly me! The picture was actually link to youtube!
- mindracer 6y agoThis is really cool, scanning negatives can be a slow and laborious process. Reminds me of the mongoose by cameradactyl https://www.cameradactyl.com/mongoose https://www.cameradactyl.com/mongoose
- blcArmadillo 6y agoI'm also reminded of the Kinograph project: https://vimeo.com/66781749 https://vimeo.com/66781749. It scans movie film using a DSLR and extracts the audio from the side of the film.
- jojobas 6y agoI guess an extension to call ffmpeg for Super8 and the like could make sense. Perhaps direct projection onto the sensor (rather than using a lense) could make sense as well. Scanning movie films used to be ridiculously expensive (and it shouldn't).
- KaiserPro 6y ago> Scanning movie films used to be ridiculously expensive (and it shouldn't). It was expensive because it was pushing the boundaries of what was possible. the northlight (https://www.filmlight.ltd.uk/products/northlight/overview_nl.php https://www.filmlight.ltd.uk/products/northlight/overview_nl...) which I had the pleasure of working with the prototype of is a spectacular machine. Firstly it has really good registration, which means that in theory you should be able to scan the same film twice and it'll look exactly the same. Not only that its gentle, so you can scan really fragile stuff. Add to that it over scans the living snot out of the film, plus an IR pass to get rid of the dust. Also its not a square CCD, its a linear CCD that is scanned across the plate.
- wdb 6y agoI think I have found my holiday project. Got boxes full of dias that my dad made of Japan in the 70s. The idea is to follow my passed away footsteps and go to the same spots and try to make a similar photo over 50 years later :))
- phn 6y agoI would love to see the photos from 70s Japan. The ones you feel comfortable sharing with strangers, of course!
- albertzeyer 6y agoVery nice. We were just recently discussing how expensive this is, and that this would be nice for some hobby robotic project. From a quick glance over the code, it seems to scan over the film roll and takes photos using the camera. But I haven't really found much logic for post processing. You would need to adapt the colors in some way, right? It's a negative, so inverse them. But then they still need to be adapted in some way. Actually this was for me the most unclear aspect about such a project -- how to deal with the colors.
- dbrgn 6y agoAs suggested in another comment, the best way would probably to shoot in RAW (so you get the data directly from your camera's sensor) and then use postprocessing tools made for negatives. Darktable has a new module called "negadoctor" for this, see https://www.darktable.org/2020/08/darktable-3-2/ https://www.darktable.org/2020/08/darktable-3-2/ (ctrl+f negadoctor). Darktable also supports Lua scripting, maybe that could be used to automate a workflow.
- gsich 6y agoIf you have the money, buy Negativelab Pro for Lightroom.
- dvfjsdhgfv 6y agoI'd like to see an enlarged version of a negative scanned in this way. I experimented with taking pictures of film and the results were always far inferior than using a dedicated scanner.
- dbrgn 6y agoDid you watch the video? It contains a few very impressive examples.
- dvfjsdhgfv 6y agoYes, I saw whole images resized to fit the video, and they are very nice - but I'd like to see the scan 1:1 to see how the grain is rendered.
- mitjak 6y agohere you go: https://www.dropbox.com/sh/rmiaquw3wnv3cvu/AACqp9bLXiDY5oCCUhrlzvSSa?dl=0 https://www.dropbox.com/sh/rmiaquw3wnv3cvu/AACqp9bLXiDY5oCCU... There are 16 bit TIFFs and JPEGs, along with a zoomed in crop (PNGs bc i wanted to have them be the same size for a side by side comparison). For the 2 scanners, these were scanned fully "raw", without any software colour correction or sharpening (FlexColor for the Imacon, Epson Scan 2 for the V600). The camera scan is using my 2012 Fuji X-E1 with a Micro-Nikkor 55mm @ f/8, and the V600 negative carrier, with an iPad as a light source (there's some barrel distortion; i'm still ironing out my rig). Final results corrected by my meatbag eye in Affinity (I had to increase saturation of the V600 scans to match the other two), hence the slightly different colour rendition, but the difference in grain resolution and overall detail should be pretty clear.
- puzzlingcaptcha 6y agoDon't people normally use document scanners for that? What are the upsides/downsides? This seems like more difficult to control exposure.
- jrockway 6y agoI do a lot of film photography and do use a flatbed scanner to digitize. I like taking 4x5 negatives and making 100MP digital images that you can infinitely zoom into. But! It is a lot of work. (I wet mount, and take several scans to get the focusing perfect across the entire negative.) You can get 90% as good results by putting the negative on a slide viewer (more commonly sold for tracing these days) and taking a picture with your digital camera. Will you extract every bit of information that the film captured? No. Will an amazing picture look amazing when digitized in this way? Absolutely. So it's worth considering if you already have a digital camera and are just getting started! I have taken pictures of negatives hanging to dry with my phone, inverted them in Photoshop, and posted them to social media with good results. You don't need expensive equipment and to spend hours getting things perfect if you don't want to.
- gsich 6y agoIf you want to wait minutes for a single frame, go for it.
- tmjwid 6y agoWhat a great little project. I find it strange somehow, through the wind, someone always posts a project that relates to me in my current hobbies here on hn. I've just started scanning my 35mm negatives with my dslr (with macro lens) and a film holder on a lightbox. It's easy and much quicker than a dedicated flatbed, but more work post process. For anyone wanting to do this, you will need to invert your b&w or colour negatives with software capable of processing RAW files (lightroom, darktable, rawtherapee) white balance the negative, invert and then colour/exposure correct the final image. I use darktable for this and the latest version has a real nice plugin called negadoctor that can give you a great starting point. For lightroom, NegativeLabPro is the goto tool and works in a similar way to negadoctor but is better at producing the initial image.
- renw0rp 6y agoI'm curious, how is the quality of such a setup vs dedicated scanner?
- scrdhrt 6y agoI am using both a dedicated 35mm film scanner (not flatbed) and a DSLR with macro for repro, the latter for medium format film. The outcome quality of both processes is identical and great quality, but the DSLR repro way is a little bit more cumbersome. It takes me longer to get a really good result with a lightbox than with the dedicated film scanner. Not by long, but it adds up if I have a couple of 120 film to repro. I shoot repro with a Nikon D700 in RAW using a 105mm macro lens on a regular stand, with a bubble calibrator. The lightbox is a small cardboard box spray painted in black, with flippable/removable cutouts to fit 6x4,5 up to 6x7. I use an old discarded iPad mini, setup with a white image on max brightness as backlight. Using Capture One (my preference of editing suite), I connect my camera with a USB cable and import directly into the editing suite. No need for importing of a CF/SD card. Smooth process.
- tmjwid 6y agoPretty much what scrdhrt has said is spot on. Quality is very much the same, and the output is rather good. I don't have anything to show you from my own work as a comparison, but there is plenty of reference material on reddit and photo blogs about the process. Time wise, the speed of snapping a photo is also mostly outweighted by the time needed to post process the image (neg invert, white balance, colour correct) versus the slow scanning speed of a flatbed negative scanner. Never used the cheaper 35mm scanners you can buy, but from what I’ve seen they're just the dslr approach without the quality. I think it comes down to two questions. 1: Do you own a dslr with a macro lens? 2: Do you know how to use raw editors like lightroom or darktable? If yes to both, then dslr scanning is easily the cheaper of the two and is most likely the best route to go to test the process.
- bronson 6y agoThe machine learning to find each frame is impressive. Has anyone seen a utility to recognize and deskew prints on a flatbed scanner? Found some interactive apps, but nothing that is automated to work in a pipeline like shown here.