12 ms·
Fifty Years of Tax Cuts for Rich Didn’t Trickle Down, Study Says
- dep_b 6y agoI think the golden age of the US lasted between the beginning of the 30's until the end of the 70's and especially that period was a time of higher taxes for the rich and a rapidly growing middle class. With the current lack of well paying middle class jobs together with high barriers for studying for the jobs that do poor people don't really have a chance to emancipate like they did until the 80's: work hard, earn enough money to send your kids to university and see them doing better than you did.
- runawaybottle 6y agoHow the hell is Europe getting by with their high social welfare and limited high knowledge industries (tech)? They must have wildly different expectations. Do they all expect to be a homeowner and have a nice salary? Our expectations might be out of whack in the states.
- bergstromm466 6y ago> Europe [and their] limited high knowledge industries (tech) Huh, where’d you get that idea?
- runawaybottle 6y agoTheir salaries suck. I would love to be told I’m wrong about this, and that parts of Europe are up there with tech hubs like NY and Cali.
- pjc50 6y agoThe same global companies exist in both places, for example Facebook Dublin: https://www.irishtimes.com/business/technology/facebook-ireland-staff-coin-it-as-average-pay-reaches-154-000-1.3714642 https://www.irishtimes.com/business/technology/facebook-irel... Even within the US, it's been the case up until 2020 that the premium for having a worker in SF or NY was absolutely huge. Now that everyone has been forced to manage over Zoom for a bit, is that sustainable? I genuinely don't know. (I have a 97th-percentile UK salary living in Scotland from an employer based in Austin, but that still probably doesn't compare to SF numbers)
- viraptor 6y agoCalifornia tech hubs are not a common US thing either. There's only one silicon valley and it comes with its own numerous issues. The actual cost of living and services is also very different. Pointing just at the salaries in SV won't give you a good comparison. (In the same way that pointing out lack of them in Broken Bow, Nebraska doesn't make the US as a whole bad at tech)
- dep_b 6y agoContracting salaries are much more similar. Not the same, but in the same ballpark. The ability to fire people easily, less holidays and less perks leads to higher salaries in the US but contracting jobs pay relatively bad.
- UncleMeat 6y agoThe US is a lot bigger than just NY and SF/LA. Further, there is a tremendous amount of poverty and near-poverty in these cities as costs like housing continue to rise. It is a great setup for software engineers at top companies being paid hundreds of thousands. It is less good for the restaurant chef or the retail worker or the car mechanic.
- pjc50 6y agoRegular reminder that Europe is huge and diverse, just as the US contains both extreme wealth and extreme poverty. It also has a lot of tech industry in it, just not high-visibility names that dominate the Internet discussion of "FAANG". It's not so much that everyone expects to be a homeowner as that it's easier to have a nice life without being a homeowner in many places. Long-term secure tenancies, acceptable quality social housing, that kind of thing. American housing tends to be much larger, though, unless right in middle of the very densest cities. The UK is backsliding on living standards and social welfare to the point that UNICEF have stepped in.
- ldng 6y agoIndeed your expectations about Europe are way off.
- Andrew_nenakhov 6y ago> between the beginning of the 30's Yeah right. [1] [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Depression https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Depression
- saddlerustle 6y ago> that period was a time of higher taxes for the rich and a rapidly growing middle class Tax revenue as a fraction of GDP is flat since the 60's, and the fraction of tax revenue paid by the top 1% was much lower in the 60's than it is today.
- Retric 6y agoEffective tax rate is more important than overall tax percentage here. Remember, the rich keep getting richer. the share of income going to the top 0.1 percent of the income distribution "was around 2.5 of total income in the 1970s and reached a peak above 9 percent of total income in 2000 Anyway, in 2020 payroll taxes make up 1340 billion vs 1620 billion in ‘income taxes’ and 221 billion in corporate taxes. So, overall talking about the percentage of income tax paid by the rich is misleading. https://www.usdebtclock.org/ https://www.usdebtclock.org/ Largest difference is the vast reduction in corporate taxes and the explosion in payroll taxes. https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna29861648 https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna29861648. But, critically the burden wasn’t handed to the top 0.01% but rather the top 20% as payroll taxes have a cap.
- CraigJPerry 6y agoSure - if you concentrate a higher proportion of income into fewer people, you would hope the tax burden should follow that income redistribution.
- mpweiher 6y ago> fraction of tax revenue paid by the top 1% So you're saying that the rich have gotten so massively richer that despite the ridiculously low taxes, which they often manage to evade as well, their overall contribution is still more.
- cosmiccatnap 6y agoThis should be in the dictionary next to cherry picked
- woah 6y agoIt’s really hard to draw any conclusions about the 1940’s to 70’s “golden age”, since during this time, the US was the only intact industrial power in the world. Of course this was very profitable, and it was a situation in which American workers had a lot of power. It’s unclear whether taxes had much to do with anything at all.
- r00fus 6y agoWell considering, in the past, the the only way to wage war was to pay for it with increased taxes (ie, prior to deficit spending). So high taxes and being the only industrial power are correlated due to the US winning the war.
- ldng 6y agoAccording to Piketty, Nixon suppressing the inheritance tax lead to more money and power hoarding and generational partial reshuffling stopped. There is undoubtedly more to the end of this golden age but it's a credible factor.
- apta 6y ago> was a time of higher taxes for the rich Correlation vs. causation. The sources I've seen all have said that no one of the rich paid those high taxes, and the same will happen when Biden and his gang will attempt to increase taxes now. There will be loopholes and a million other things the rich can use to reduce taxes. The problem lies elsewhere, but no one seems to discuss it. It's not for no reason that Islam, Judaism, and Christianity prohibit lending money with interest. We look around us and see a debt heavy and debt ridden society, because it's easy to lend money with interest. The modern usurious economic system is inherently going to favor the rich. Ban interest and other usurious immoral and parasitic practices (e.g. stock shorting) and things will improve quickly.
- m4r35n357 6y agoDuh!
- gadders 6y agoAnyone got a link to the paper? The article doesn't present any evidence.
- the_rara_avis 6y agoHere: http://eprints.lse.ac.uk/107919/1/Hope_economic_consequences_of_major_tax_cuts_published.pdf http://eprints.lse.ac.uk/107919/1/Hope_economic_consequences...
- gadders 6y agoYour google skills are better than mine!
- fouc 6y agoTrickle down economics clearly hasn't worked, hopefully governments will stop going down that path.
- steve76 6y agoSo it worked in Hong Kong: https://www.wsj.com/articles/a-dearth-of-data-helped-hong-kong-succeed-11559944078 https://www.wsj.com/articles/a-dearth-of-data-helped-hong-ko... Might be cruel, but people are on their own anyways and stronger than most people think. Trickle down healthcare, education, civil rights, jobs, and housing hasn't worked either. Power uses problems for their own gain resulting in command economies and authoritarianism which are miserable compared to self-educated motivated individuals. Because everyone can mess up, laws declaring no mess-ups are impossible. Might as well plan for the western sunrise or uphill running water. What works? Respecting others. Leaving people alone. Problems fix themselves regardless of what powerful people do. Political arguments deserve the most cynicism. Violence with words by men in makeup who do very little and it's all only for themselves. If raising taxes hurts growth, lowering taxes helps growth. That's a fallacy, but take that thought one step further. Bad people get a tax cut too. They horde or harm. Why does that mean we need more intervention and taxes? Federal governments can be corrupted just the same. Often all the same people just putting a cap on the next horrible war.
- getmoheb 6y agoTo quote the late great Robert W Cox: > Theory is always for someone and for something. All theories have a pespective. Perspectives derive from a position in time and space, specifically social and political time and space ... There is, accordingly, no such thing as theory in itself, divorced from a standpoint in time and space. When any theory so represents itself, it is the more important to examine it as ideology, and to lay bare its concealed perspective In this case it could not be clearer that the theory of 'trickle down'/supply side/neoliberal economics - that is, liberalisation, privatisation and deregulation - were for the wealthy, and they were for the purpose of capturing a greater share of wealth (upward wealth redistribution). That's why they acquired prominence and political support, and that's why they've been so hard to dislodge in spite of the overall harm they've done. Personally I think it'd probably be ok to try something else
- jfengel 6y agoThat's true of the hard sciences as well, not just the soft ones. The types of observations you think to make, the types of experiments you can perform, are "laden" with your theory of what there is in the world: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory-ladenness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory-ladenness Scientific revolutions often start with puzzling "errors" in the measurements, and end up re-defining terms so that the new "correct" theory makes the error go away. But you're still theory-laden: the new theory is itself subject to eventual revolution. Even really fundamental concepts like mass, length, entropy, and temperature undergo redefinition. When they do, the way we measure them changes. The old way, which was considered scientifically solid and sound, seems quaint and backwards in retrospect. That's even more obvious in soft sciences, where the terms are even less rigorously defined than notions like "mass". I think it's important to recognize it in the hard sciences as well, because it's easy to get complacent thinking that we have all the terms perfectly defined. Scientists are human regardless of their field and are always burdened with assumptions that they don't realize.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hacker-ricky 6y agoDo you even need a study to prove that? It's just common sense!
- danaris 6y agoIt's vitally important to have studies proving things that are "common sense," so that when there are people in positions of power trying to claim the opposite, there's solid science to point to when you tell them they're wrong. It's even more important when it's things like this, disproving ideas that have been taken as gospel by parts of the political establishment for decades now.
- pintxo 6y agoEvery heard of Ignaz Semmelweis [1]? He challenged common sense, and lost his life in the end, but eventually it turned out he was right and the common sense was wrong. There is rarely a reason to not challenge common sense with the scientific method and see if we can poke a hole into it. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ignaz_Semmelweis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ignaz_Semmelweis
- jollofricepeas 6y agoNothing new here. There is a long list of papers from the right and left that say the same. - https://theamericanleader.org/problems/income-wealth-inequality/ https://theamericanleader.org/problems/income-wealth-inequal... - https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2020/09/rand-study-how-high-is-inequality-us.html https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2020/09/rand-study-how-high-.... - https://www.americanprogress.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/BerensteinInequality.pdf https://www.americanprogress.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/... For whatever reason, we felt that the techno-elite would be different than the robber barons that came before them and that the internet would lead to greater equality when all it’s done is erode unity, wealth, privacy and security. ...while they duck and dodge taxes through international shell companies and...moving to Texas
- woah 6y agoHow is moving to Texas “ducking and dodging taxes”?
- Jochim 6y agoProbably referring to the trend of California residents making a lot of money from being located in California and then re-locate to Texas. The implication is that they do this to avoid having to continue paying back California for the wealth they amassed there.
- ykevinator 6y agoWait til their kids attend the schools only to discover they're being taught creationism. I have a feeling this whole move to Texas thing is not gonna stick.
- slowmovintarget 6y agoPresumably they already paid California taxes for when they worked there. The people governing California have decided they want to take more. There's no debt there. "California" isn't owed. There's nothing to "pay back." Having a hostile tax environment makes people and businesses go elsewhere, if they can.
- CryptoPunk 6y agoThere is a pervasive inverse correlation between government spending, as a percentage of GDP, and the rate of economic growth: https://web.archive.org/web/20170821004405/http://ime.bg/uploads/335309_OptimalSizeOfGovernment.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20170821004405/http://ime.bg/upl... A tax cut that isn't matched by a spending cut translates to more government borrowing, where the rich take that money they save on taxes, and lend it to the government.
- RobertoG 6y agoThat paper is funny. In economics, it's possible to create a mathematical model that demonstrate anything you want. How was what John Von Newman said? "Give me four parameters and I will fit an elephant" or something like that. The private sector invest to get profits. If it doesn't get profits it will not invest. If the private sector investment fall, and nothing compensate it, the GDP will fall. If the GDP fall the population will suffer. So, in order to keep the economy going, the government share of GDP will grow (we can see a good example now with the pandemic). When those think tanks, like the one of your link, ask for a reduction of the government spending, normally what they are asking is put my profits before the welfare of the population. As they can't say it that way, because it would be too obvious, they say: "trickle down economics".
- CryptoPunk 6y agoAh yes, studies like the one on tax cuts for the rich are fine, but not ones on government spending levels. Any way, you're over-simplifying how an economy works. If there are not enough profitable investments to maintain current investment levels, then investment levels should decline. The government should not invest unprofitably just to maintain current levels. And no, GDP will not drop. Current productive capital will generate the same value of goods/service, and prices will drop to clearing level until everything produced is consumed. It's better for the population to enjoy higher consumption levels, or to create stockpiles for the future, than have their labor and capital output diverted to projects that will provide them with less resources than they put in.
- 6y ago
- traveler01 6y agoMy country, Portugal, is the best example how that "tax the rich" mentality clearly didn't worked. First of all you have to consider what in your country is considered as "rich". Here people who's wage is above average are taxed as "rich"... so yeah that creates another issue. Also, the rich are rich because they offer very need services to the middle class. You tax the rich and they increase the prices of their products, which means you're basically increasing taxes on the lower classes instead of the rich. The solution? An overall decrease of taxes.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoYou tax the rich and they increase the prices of their products So why didn't they do that before? If there is one thing I know about the rich it's that they won't pass up an oportunity to earn more. The reality is prices are driven by supply and demand, someone can't expect to magically increase prices just because their tax burden is higher. The market won't support that.
- traveler01 6y agoYet these taxes are always represented in the final price of the product. Rich people have power, they can go take those taxes money from whatever they want: - Price of their products - Their employees wages - Whatever the hell they want to. And this is happening in a socialist country. If I'd guess any better in countries like the US this would be way worse for everyone. Taxes aren't the answer for all problems like many people like to think they are.
- mafuy 6y agoThe point was: If they have the power to increase prices because taxes increased, then why do they not increase prices because they want to earn more? If they do have the power, they should get as much as possible! And that's the thing: Their power is limited to what is possible. That's the free market at work actually. Increasing taxes would certainly increase prices, but not fully compensate.
- jelliclesfarm 6y agoRight. Let’s see. First of all..this is a political hit piece. Secondly, it is untrue. The world has eradicated crippling poverty due to trickle down capitalism. Anyone who denies this is purposefully being dishonest. Having said that..why it’s political.. > That will be comforting news to U.K. Chancellor of the Exchequer Rishi Sunak, whose hopes of repairing the country’s virus-battered public finances may rest on his ability to increase taxes, possibly on capital gains -- a levy that might disproportionately impact higher-earning individuals.[..] Rishi Sunak is the husband of Akshata Murthy and son-in-law of Narayan Murthy. https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/diaspora/narayana-murthys-son-in-law-rishi-sunak-in-row-over-not-declaring-wifes-wealth-in-uk-ministerial-register-report-177136 https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/diaspora/narayana-murthys-... [..] Akshata Murthy, who married Sunak in 2009, is the daughter of one of India's most successful entrepreneurs. Her father co-founded the technology giant Infosys, and her shares in the company are worth £430 million, making her one of the wealthiest women in Britain, with a fortune larger than the Queen's, The Guardian reported.[..] [..] But Sunak's entry mentions no family members other than his wife, and only refers to her ownership of a small, UK-based venture capital company. Research by the Guardian shows that Murthy and her family hold many other interests, including: * A combined £1.7bn shareholding in Infosys, which employs thousands of staff in the UK and has held contracts with government ministries and public bodies.[..] [..] The Guardian reported that after becoming chief secretary to the Treasury in July 2019, Sunak revealed for the first time that he was the beneficiary of a blind trust. He also included Murty for the first time, stating: "Mr Sunak's wife owns a venture capital investment company, Catamaran Ventures UK Ltd."[..] While the wealth of the Murthy clan is staggering and Akshata Murthy(and the Sunak family by extension)‘s inherited riches are impressive making her ‘richer than the queen’, Infosys has also created a new middle class for the millions of educated youth who came out of educational institutions and ended up being gainfully employed. Everyone climbed a couple of rungs in India due to companies like Infosys. I don’t think anyone can deny this. What a bafflingly blatantly dishonest article/study. Nothing to see here. Ok to move on.
- jelliclesfarm 6y agoIf we tax the rich, the taxes go straight to the government. A thriving economy needs CHURN. Please note: it’s not about the taxes..plain old taxation creates stale economies..it’s about how much people spend and buy and produce and keep money in circulation. The economic churn. More churn, more prosperity because we are creating movement of spending money that came from capital to keep alive a thriving economy. Taxing the rich ..those few amongst us..will result in a welfare state with no vibrant economic activity and everyone being dependent on the state because if there is no income, there is no movement. No small businesses, no new start ups, no way to spend money in all those conspicuously consumptive ways. While it’s fun to act shocked at the number of billionaires amongst us..most of it is tied up in stocks that can’t be liquidated. The high stock price determines dividends..pension funds, investment firms, wealth funds, retirement funds, universities, everyone invests in these stocks that allows people to retire and spend and splurge and buy homes etc. The hypocrisy of the outrage is laughable. Case in point: Chicago teachers Union protested in front of Jeff Bezos home with a guillotine because he became the first man to be worth 200 billion. [1] The same Chicago teachers Union owned 45k AMZN shares which brought its investment in amazon to ..wait for it.. $86 million+. In year ending 2019. Trickle down capitalism doesn’t work? .. right then! [1] https://www.thecentersquare.com/illinois/ctu-sparks-controversy-with-tweet-about-guillotine-outside-amazon-ceos-home/article_d7c8ba36-e957-11ea-9bc7-e3e466d3ef28.html https://www.thecentersquare.com/illinois/ctu-sparks-controve... [..] The Chicago Teachers Union sparked controversy Thursday when it said it was "completely in support" of demonstrators who built a guillotine outside of Amazon CEO Jeff Bezo's home. The union tweeted a video of the guillotine and wrote, "We are completely frightened by, completely impressed by and completely in support of wherever this is headed." The tweet generated both support and outrage online. The controversial tweet came as Bezos reportedly became the first person to acquire a personal $200 billion fortune.[..] [..] The Chicago Teachers’ Pension Fund owned 45,754 shares of Amazon stock worth $86,641,147 at the end of fiscal year 2019, according to its 2019 Comprehensive Annual Financial Report. The pension fund is governed by a 12-member board of trustees. Active teachers elect six of the pension board's trustees. The report showed the pension fund's Amazon stock was its second-largest domestic equity holding behind Microsoft in 2019. In addition to Microsoft and Amazon., the funds top 10 domestic equity holdings included Apple, Facebook, Alphabet, Chevron, Visa, Berkshire Hathaway and Johnson & Johnson, according to the report.[..]
- redflame8 6y agoIt led to the greatest trickle down of knowledge in the history of man: the Internet.
- danaris 6y agoYou...know the Internet came out of government projects (DARPANet), right? It wasn't something that was developed by private companies out of the goodness of their hearts...
- redflame8 6y agoYeah it was invented at my school UCLA but that thing is not even close to the Internet is today that was done by capitalism and capital investment
- danaris 6y agoMost of what "capitalism and capital investment" have done for the Internet are the things I, and many others, hate about it. The original protocols and specifications still lie at the core of most of the Internet, and the infrastructure was, in large part, paid for by government subsidies to the telecom companies, the full terms of which many of them never fulfilled. Even if one could realistically claim that "capitalism and capital investment" made significant positive contributions to the modern internet, the idea that any significant amount of those contributions would not have happened without the utter failure that is "trickle-down economics" doesn't hold water, either.
- redflame8 6y agoThen setup your own private virtual network. I think what you are actually complaining about Is human nature to profit which will always exist no matter what government type there is. Since profit is a zero sum game it’s pretty dangerous in a society built around the commune. The people in charge of distribution always end up with a little bit more
- mpweiher 6y ago
- ykevinator 6y agoThe presumption is that the amount taxed is needed. This is absurd and is a false dichotomy. We should reduce taxes fairly and cut staffing and military spending and provide free health care. It's all possible, we just don't have good fiduciary representation in govt.
- umvi 6y agoIf government coffers are a barrel with a bunch of holes in it, and taxes are water pouring into the barrel, why are we constantly fixated on increasing the rate of water entering the barrel, and not on plugging the holes water is spilling onto the ground on? The government is notoriously wasteful with tax money, so why are we unable to incentivize more efficient usage of existing taxes vs. increasing tax income? It's like a software developer who always adds more and more RAM to their PCs and always frames the problem in terms of how much more RAM they need to make things work instead of taking some time to close a couple thousand chrome tabs.
- mikestew 6y agoThe government is notoriously wasteful with tax money In comparison to what, exactly? The burn rate of SV startups? You say "notoriously" like it's just a given. I turn that around and ask, "fine, what examples of spending in large organizations do you have that a government should follow?" Because at the couple of large corporations I've worked at, waste was plentiful as well.
- apta 6y agoThe problem is the usurious economic system. Prohibit interest and reduce taxes, and things will improve almost by definition.
- RickJWagner 6y agoI'm sort of tired of backwards-looking studies that align directly with the political thinking of the publisher. How about a study that tries to predict what will happen under the next administration, and by the way, include the relevant metrics? Something like: Unemployment rates Stock market rise/fall Worker's wages In truth, the current US administration has had pretty good marks in these departments. I'd love to see the next administration better them. But I'd also like to see the metrics provided before the judgement is made on what works or doesn't work. Sort of like 'the scientific method'.