4 ms·
> in fact the government does have the right to do that Not necessarily. It is certainly true that the government has the power to do it. But the point of hav
by pdonis 6y ago
> in fact the government does have the right to do that
Not necessarily.
It is certainly true that the government has the power to do it. But the point of having a free country with the rule of law is supposed to be that might does not make right. The fact that the government can take your house if it decides it wants to does not, in itself, mean it has the right to.
Any such right ultimately depends on the government being responsible to the people and the people accepting that the government is acting in their interest and that what it does is for the overall good of society. The larger and more bureaucratic the government becomes, and the more it uses its power based on utopian visions of people who do not suffer the consequences if they are wrong, the harder it is for the people to accept that the government is acting in their interest and that what it is doing is for the overall good of society.
- mypalmike 6y agoIn the US, the takings clause of the fifth amendment lays out the government's right to eminent domain if it provides just compensation.
- pdonis 6y ago> the takings clause of the fifth amendment lays out the government's right to eminent domain if it provides just compensation. And if the property is taken for public use. Not all takings that have been claimed to be justified under the eminent domain power have been for public use by any reasonable interpretation of that term.