3 ms·
> Central planning is neither useful nor efficient when the planners are stupid and corrupt. To make use of David Friedman's observation about a similar remark
by pdonis 6y ago
> Central planning is neither useful nor efficient when the planners are stupid and corrupt.
To make use of David Friedman's observation about a similar remark, unfortunately this sentence remains true if you take out the last seven words.
Which makes the author's faith in central planning even more problematic.
- danielheath 6y agoIf capital requirements are reasonable, the market will figure it out. However, that’s far less true for capital-intensive problems; there’s few enough actors for them to collude. For that reason, central planning works out passably for predictable problems with high capital requirements like sewerage, roads and electrical grids.
- pdonis 6y ago> there’s few enough actors for them to collude And those who collude become the central planners. So central planning doesn't fix this problem: it worsens it, because now the colluders have government power on their side.
- afarrell 6y agoRegulation makes the central planning explicit so that an anticorruption layer can (hopefully) be designed.
- chordalkeyboard 6y agoThen the anticorruption layer is vulnerable to corruption.
- StanislavPetrov 6y ago>To make use of David Friedman's observation about a similar remark, unfortunately this sentence remains true if you take out the last seven words. I don't disagree with that statement, but reasonable people can debate and disagree in a hypothetical fantasy world where central planners are thoughtful and competent. This is why I find it more useful to address the situation in the actual world we live in, where stupid, incompetent and corrupt people like Chirlane McCray (wife of NYC Mayor Bill DeBlasio) are appointed to spend billions in taxpayer dollars to do the "planning". Unfortunately with this issue, as with every other, most people are more interested in ideology than reality.
- andbberger 6y agoMan, Paxos for transit agencies is going to be a game changer.