5 ms·
> > No, dear white flight homeowner, we will not build you a tunnel just to avoid taking a few houses through eminent domain. > What makes someone so callous a
by AnimalMuppet 6y ago
> > No, dear white flight homeowner, we will not build you a tunnel just to avoid taking a few houses through eminent domain.
> What makes someone so callous about using the power of the state to expropriate people from their homes?
First: "Expropriate" is both emotionally loaded and inaccurate. It looks like you're trying to be manipulative here rather than present a sound argument.
Second: If we're going to build a road or a rail line, we're either going to spend some money and buy peoples' homes, or we're going to spend more money and create a tunnel. But money doesn't grow on trees for local governments; if they spend it, they have to take it. So either we're going to take money from people to buy houses from people, or we're going to take more money from people to create a tunnel. Why should they take more money from people to save peoples' houses? Why should my taxes go up to save your house?
Note that this is a completely separate discussion from whether eminent domain actually pays people market prices for their homes.
- zdragnar 6y ago> Why should my taxes go up to save your house? Simple: because it is my house, not yours. Why should I lose my house so you can drive your car on a new road when there are other alternatives?
- chordalkeyboard 6y ago> First: "Expropriate" is both emotionally loaded and inaccurate. Wrong. Expropriate is a technical term for taking property from someone, usually by the state for public use. The emotion you're referring to is all associated with the act itself. You've also failed to identify an inaccuracy. > It looks like you're trying to be manipulative here rather than present a sound argument. All I did was ask a question. > Why should they take more money from people to save peoples' houses? Why should my taxes go up to save your house? Your taxes are going up because the government has decided to build a road or rail line. Why should the cost of that be artificially low because the government is able to expropriate people's homes? > Note that this is a completely separate discussion from whether eminent domain actually pays people market prices for their homes. By definition, it does not. This is why your statement: > we're either going to spend some money and buy peoples' homes, elides the relevant factor: people are being <strike>expropriated</strike> deprived of their homes through threat of violence in order to lower the cost of infrastructure. > we're going to spend more money and create a tunnel. But money doesn't grow on trees for local governments; if they spend it, they have to take it. Perhaps the government needs to exercise fiscal discipline. Perhaps the government can't afford a new rail.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoExpropriate can mean taking by eminent domain, but it also can mean taking with no compensation whatsoever. And the context in which we (all right, I) most often hear the word is the latter - when a government takes property without paying for it, or paying only a pittance. Mea culpa, though: Until I looked at dictionary.com, I didn't know it could be used for eminent domain. > All I did was ask a question. "How can someone be so callous?" That's a question, but it's not just a question. It's pushing a viewpoint. > > Note that this is a completely separate discussion from whether eminent domain actually pays people market prices for their homes. > By definition, it does not. By definition? I call BS. In fact, the Constitution requires "just compensation". Now, have governments abused that, and actually offered less than just compensation? Of course. But "by definition"? No. > elides the relevant factor: people are being <strike>expropriated</strike> deprived of their homes through threat of violence in order to lower the cost of infrastructure. Nice whine. But in fact the government does have the right to do that, and for quite good reasons. And, if they make the tunnel, they're going to have to take different peoples' houses. > Perhaps the government needs to exercise fiscal discipline. Perhaps the government can't afford a new rail. On that point, I agree with you at least some of the time.
- chordalkeyboard 6y ago> Expropriate can mean taking by eminent domain, but it also can mean taking with no compensation whatsoever. Yeah, it just means 'taking property.' It doesn't reference compensation. > "How can someone be so callous?" That's a question, but it's not just a question. It's pushing a viewpoint. Well it does imply that the person referenced is being callous towards the concerns of the property owners, which is why I asked the question. I'm not sure what viewpoint you think I'm pushing. I'm wondering how someone can be so dismissive of the concerns of a homeowner regarding the government depriving them of their home in a place they chose to live. They picked that house and that place for a variety of reasons then invested their time, their life, their families, and their money in that community. Then some bureaucrat says "we need this for <aquaducts>, get out or die. Here's a check." Its one thing to exercise your best judgment and believe that when the public interest is balanced against the private interest, this is the greater good. But when someone callously disregards the interest of the homeowner in the home and community they have chosen to be part of, it raises serious questions about whether their interests are actually being balanced fairly. When someone is casually dismissive of a person's interest in continuing to own the home that they chose to buy and live in, one wonders if they are even considering the homeowner as a person and not an obstacle. > By definition? I call BS. Yes, by definition market value is the amount that must be paid to achieve a voluntary transaction on the market. Eminent domain forces a person out under threat of violence and pays an amount that the forcing party deems to be acceptable. If they were offering fair market value, by definition, they wouldn't have to threaten violence. > In fact, the Constitution requires "just compensation". I'm confident you understand that the constitution is a document and does not compel obedience to its words. Furthermore "just compensation" implies the question "just according to whom?" Its not a synonym for "market value." > Nice whine. So when I used a technical term correctly, you whined. Now I break it down into it technical components in a purely descriptive sense, so I'm not expecting you to know the meanings of technical terms, and you say I'm whining. What am I to make of this? > But in fact the government does have the right to do that, and for quite good reasons. Referring back to the question that started this discussion, when people are so callous about the manner in which government exercises its powers, it calls into questions whether those reasons are in fact very good. Minor quibble: governments have powers, people have rights. > And, if they make the tunnel, they're going to have to take different peoples' houses. Asserts facts not in evidence. The point of the tunnel is to go underneath extant structures. > On that point, I agree with you at least some of the time. glad to see I'm making my point.