3 ms·

How is this legal? Since EU members have to create laws for implement EU laws. So each country has a law for GDPR, including the UK. Those laws aren't going to

How is this legal? Since EU members have to create laws for implement EU laws. So each country has a law for GDPR, including the UK. Those laws aren't going to suddenly stop being on the books in the new year.

jnxx 6y ago
That's an interesting point. As far as I remember, there is quite a lot of EU laws which did become UK laws. Aparts from the question of the benefits to do so, it would take many many years to disentangle that. So, the UK governments solution is that all these laws will be re-written by the government in one big package and the UK parliament gives more or less an advance approval to that. I am probably not the only one who sees this as a significant weakening of parliamentary democracy in the UK.
buzer 6y ago
[edit] UK situation regarding GDPR might be a bit different though as, if I understood correctly, they implemented GDPR as separate national law (instead of it just being EU regulation). https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2018/12/introduction/enacted https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2018/12/introduction/en... GDPR is not an EU directive. Directives are the ones that member states will need to adopt to their own laws. One example would be consumer rights directive. It gives a list of goals, but member states can decide how to archive them. Regulations, like GDPR, come in effect automatically on the whole EU. One example of these, in addition to GDPR, would be various economic sanctions. If someone leaves EU, they would still keep all those laws they implemented before but are free to change if they wish by following their own law making procedures. However, they would no longer need to care about any of the regulations (they may need to follow some if they wish to trade with EU). They are free to still adhere to them if they wish. They may need to adopt some laws for them if their national regulation bodies don't have necessary rights to enforce such regulation (as earlier EU regulation would have triumphed national law).

jnxx 6y ago

That's an interesting point. As far as I remember, there is quite a lot of EU laws which did become UK laws. Aparts from the question of the benefits to do so, it would take many many years to disentangle that. So, the UK governments solution is that all these laws will be re-written by the government in one big package and the UK parliament gives more or less an advance approval to that. I am probably not the only one who sees this as a significant weakening of parliamentary democracy in the UK.

buzer 6y ago

[edit] UK situation regarding GDPR might be a bit different though as, if I understood correctly, they implemented GDPR as separate national law (instead of it just being EU regulation). https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2018/12/introduction/enacted https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2018/12/introduction/en... GDPR is not an EU directive. Directives are the ones that member states will need to adopt to their own laws. One example would be consumer rights directive. It gives a list of goals, but member states can decide how to archive them. Regulations, like GDPR, come in effect automatically on the whole EU. One example of these, in addition to GDPR, would be various economic sanctions. If someone leaves EU, they would still keep all those laws they implemented before but are free to change if they wish by following their own law making procedures. However, they would no longer need to care about any of the regulations (they may need to follow some if they wish to trade with EU). They are free to still adhere to them if they wish. They may need to adopt some laws for them if their national regulation bodies don't have necessary rights to enforce such regulation (as earlier EU regulation would have triumphed national law).