7 ms·
How these rules apply for people with multiple citizenships and residence? That’s the case with a lot of people in Europe. How to find out to which jurisdiction
by mrtksn 6y ago
How these rules apply for people with multiple citizenships and residence? That’s the case with a lot of people in Europe. How to find out to which jurisdiction my FB data is bound to?
- dvcrn 6y agoIt’s not about citizenship but where you live. In place A the rules of place A apply. If place A is part of the EU, EU laws apply.
- avianlyric 6y agoIncorrect. With GDPR the EU extended their power to protect all EU citizens regardless of residency in, or out, of the EU. Of course the EU will have trouble enforcing that protection against companies that don't operate in the EU. But the protection remains, even if it's practically unenforceable.
- Dahoon 6y agoIncorrect. It protects PII in the EU. It has nothing to do with EU citizenship. It doesn't try to enforce outside the EU either. If you want to move PII out of the EU you have to agree by the rules given. That's not the EU trying to enforce anything outside of the EU but you making an agreement to move data outside the EU on certain terms. It is not the same thing as trying to force EU law on non-EU. I don't know why people keep repeating this myth. Laws like these are old as dirt. It could as well have been about blood samples from Denmark used in research in the US: the samples are protected by Danish law and to use them in the US you have to agree to certain rules. Again an example of you saying you will follow certain rules to be allowed to transport and use the samples outside Denmark, not Denmark forcing their laws on anything in another country. You are free to not sign anything and not use or move the blood samples or PII anywhere.
- Spare_account 6y agoI'm British and have a British passport and I permanently reside in the UK but I'm also technically an Irish citizen because my Irish father was born in Ireland. I have never applied for an Irish passport but I am automatically an Irish citizen based on my ancestry. Does Facebook know this? Do I need to inform them to benefit from GDPR protections on an ongoing basis? How the hell is any of this enforceable?
- geocar 6y ago> Do I need to inform [facebook] to benefit from GDPR protections on an ongoing basis? That depends on what you want to do. What GDPR protection are you trying to benefit from? > How the hell is any of this enforceable? You can try to reach out to the regulator if you believe your GDPR protections are being violated, https://www.dataprotection.ie/ https://www.dataprotection.ie/ My experience with the ROI is that they are unlikely to jeopardise Facebook pulling out of Dublin.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoIt's not even where you live but where you are located. An American tourist in Paris is protected by the GDPR.
- DaiPlusPlus 6y agoCitizenship matters not. Only residency. Just because I'm a Britsh person living in the US doesn't mean I'm not subject to the death penalty or am exempt from having to buy health insurance, for example.
- mrtksn 6y agoOkay, what does it mean “residency”? In the UK there’s no address registry where you declare your address. EU citizen works in the UK for 2 years then goes to Turkey for a vacation but likes the place so much, decides to stay for longer when still remote working for the same London company.Also connects through VPN because the Turks love banning websites. Where this person residence is? Are the UK, USA, EU or Turkish rules apply? How FB would know about it? That’s not an extreme scenario BTW, it happens all the time.
- notimetorelax 6y agoThere are clear rules regulating that, but they may depend on the country.
- lubonay 6y agoThey may also be very unclear or outright missing, depending on the country.
- mratsim 6y agoThe rules are anything but clear. Some countries require at least 6 months + 1 day to be considered a resident, others might have you have a resident even if you aren't there if "the country is the center of your family or economic interests".
- fauigerzigerk 6y agoThe rules for the UK are set out pretty clearly in the statutory residence test [1]. It covers all such cases in more detail than you ever wanted to know :) What causes difficulties though is that the rules in different countries, even if clearly defined, can contradict each other on the question of tax residency. So you may well be liable to pay taxes in two (or more) countries at the same time. You may even have to pay taxes in both countries on the same income or gains, unless there is a double taxation agreement that allows you to offset some of those taxes against each other [2] [1] https://www.gov.uk/hmrc-internal-manuals/residence-domicile-and-remittance-basis/rdrm11000 https://www.gov.uk/hmrc-internal-manuals/residence-domicile-... [2] https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/tax-treaties https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/tax-treaties
- throwaway2245 6y agoI understand that GDPR is based on where the data [edit reflecting comments below:] originates. The law doesn't make reference to citizenship or residency. If you're physically in an EU country then EU GDPR applies to you there; if you're physically in the UK then UK GDPR applies to you there.
- munchbunny 6y agoGDPR is generally based on where the data is located That is not correct. Specifically, the counterexample is if you are a EU citizen living in an EU country and the actual bits are stored in a datacenter in Texas. GDPR still applies in this case, as long as the website owner accepts EU users. If the website specifically doesn't do business in the EU, things are different.
- throwaway2245 6y agoAh, apologies, you're right to pick that up, it's not quite what I meant. Maybe "where the data originates" is better? Since the data originates where you are, the data has crossed a border to get to Texas and is therefore subject to GDPR (extra-territorially), I agree. If you were in Texas when that data was collected from you, and you returned to the EU, I doubt that GDPR would apply to that data.
- PHGamer 6y agogpdr on the other hand is tough to enforce on companies who wholly are in the US. from a sovereign perspective the EU can pound sand when telling Americans how to treat people in their own land. The only reason the EU is able to get away with this to a degree is the american governments wish cooperation to a point and our treaties. However, I suspect america will only tolerate so much push from the EU.
- tpxl 6y ago> gpdr on the other hand is tough to enforce on companies who wholly are in the US. If you do actual business in the EU they can block financial transactions, and if you don't do business in the EU, there isn't really any incentive to (ab)use the data GDPR covers?
- pjc50 6y agoGood question: there will continue to be a lot of EU nationals subject to the GDPR living in the UK. Including Northern Ireland!
- KorematsuFred 6y agoWell jurisdiction matters based on which soil you are on and not which citizen you are. This is overall a good move by FB that puts a lot of pressure on EU/UK to come up with more sensible laws. Note that EU/UK has barely produced any major company operating in consumer web/app. It is for a good reason.