5 ms·
Europe didn’t miss the internet bus because of regulations, there were no regulations until the dust settled. The thing is, there’s no US style capital in EU.
by mrtksn 6y ago
Europe didn’t miss the internet bus because of regulations, there were no regulations until the dust settled.
The thing is, there’s no US style capital in EU. The American capitalist bankrolled all the internet when there was no clear path to make money from it.
I remember when YouTube was burning billions per year, Facebook being labeled as “would never be profitable”.
Is there the kind of money in Europe that would take these risks?
There was no way for the internet to be EU thing because when it was fresh god knows how many billions had to be spent to have it operate and cross fingers to be able to recoup that investment. Simply, there is no that kind of money in Europe.
If you made the YouTube in Europe you would go bankrupt because you wouldn’t be able to pay the server bills.
- baxtr 6y agoI totally agree with you all your points. Just to be clear: I never said we missed the bus because of regulation. But the fact that we react like that now shows we don’t have other ideas or means to respond.
- mrtksn 6y agoHaving your communication run by foreign entities is dangerous. it’s no longer even direct communication, it’s curated. It can be used to create political problems, social unrest or movements, it can be used as commercial advantage on other areas. China happened to actually have a true competitor, TikTok and the first instinct of the USA was to try to ban it or force acquisition.
- themacguffinman 6y agoThe Big Tech that the EU is targeting is mostly US-based, and the US is an EU ally. The US wasn't banning or forcing acquisitions for foreign competitors like WhatsApp or Line, and the EU isn't making moves on Visa/Mastercard which are arguably just as critical. If the EU was making this move based on national security reasons, I'd also expect them to be upfront about it.
- Aerroon 6y agoJust because the US is an ally doesn't mean the EU can build themselves to be reliant on the US. It gives the US too much leverage. >and the EU isn't making moves on Visa/Mastercard which are arguably just as critical. They're arguably not as important in Europe. Credit cards aren't nearly as common here. It's largely debit cards and bank transfers. As I understand it, SEPA [0] allows Europe to sidestep Visa and MasterCard when necessary. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_Euro_Payments_Area https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_Euro_Payments_Area
- hollerith 6y agoYou describe the post-1993 evolution of the internet, but I feel the need to add that in 1993, the internet had already been in constant operation for 24 years; it was already the largest network of computers ever. And many could see that it would probably transform society (which I know about from personal conversations with people before 1993). And before 1993 there was basically zero investor interest in the internet. Before 1993 the internet was funded mostly by the US Government, which started funding research into packet-switched networking in 1961. In 1977, unhappy with the cost of operating the network, the US Government offered the internet to AT&T for a token sum. AT&T could see no way to make money from it, so declined. In 1987, they offered it to them for a token sum again, with the same response. (Some pedants maintain the internet did not begin until 1987 with the introduction of the TCP/IP protocol, and that before then there was the ARPAnet. I feel that using the word "internet" for the network before 1987 is justified because the same services, e.g., email, mailing lists, ftp, telnet, netnews (what we now call Usenet, i.e., the newsgroups) that ran on the 1987 internet ran on the ARPAnet. Many users of the network probably didn't realize (or were only dimly aware) that anything had changed!) Starting about 1986 for-profit corporations started offering access to the internet for a fee, but before 1993 even the largest of these for-profits -- Netcom probably -- was small as American corporations go. I would not be surprised if most of Netcom's revenue came from renting out shell accounts on Unix boxes with internet connections for $20 a month to individuals. (Before for-profit ISPs, the way an organization got on the internet was basically to lease a dedicated phone line from a telephone company. The organization at the other end of the dedicated phone line rarely charged money for routing the new organization's traffic.) Aside from government contractors (e.g., Bolt Beranek and Newman, Inc, and the Mitre Corporation) and the early ISPs I just described, possibly the largest internet for-profit at the start of 1993 was Brad Templeton's Clari-Net, which posted the output of some "news wire" (e.g., Associated Press or such) to netnews. (Netnews was much bigger then the web at the start of 93.) I doubt Clari-Net ever had more than 3 employees. It probably only ever had one. In comparison, before the start of 1993, the US government had spent many billions of dollars on the internet -- over the course of 32 years if we count the package-switching research, not just when the internet got deployed in 1969.
- ChuckNorris89 6y ago>The American capitalist bankrolled all the internet when there was no clear path to make money from it. Umm, no, the US DARPA bankrolled the intrnet, then corporations took it mainstream and for profit, not for loss. The modern WWW originated at CERN in Switzerland. >Simply, there is no that kind of money in Europe. Europe definitely has money to throw away, just look at Berlin airport and all the useless projects being bankrolled from EU tax money. How many startups could that have funded? >If you made the YouTube in Europe you would go bankrupt because you wouldn’t be able to pay the server bills. Edit: Dailymotion(not Vimeo) is European and it seems to be able to pay their server bills.
- rrdharan 6y agoNo, Vimeo is based in New York City and I believe always has been? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vimeo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vimeo
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoOh damn, my bad. I always though it was french for some reason.
- I-M-S 6y agoYou've probably got it mixed up with Dailymotion
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoOh yes, that was it, thank you.
- mnouquet 6y ago> Europe didn’t miss the internet bus because of regulations, there were no regulations until the dust settled. False. In France at least, state-monopoly Minitel services shadowed early initial Internet development. Even as Internet took over, communication state monopolies clamped development with overpriced phone bills for a couple of years minimum. It is only when France Telecom got privatized and Free (owned by a former Minitel erotic chat mogul) disrupted them with widescale ADSL development that thing really took off. > If you made the YouTube in Europe you would go bankrupt because you wouldn’t be able to pay the server bills. False again, EU Youtube was Dailymotion, nothing but mismanagement over mismanagement, bad political decision over bad political decision.
- mrtksn 6y agoThat's not internet regulation, that's utility regulation. Not different than electricity connection and doesn't have anything to do with the stuff on the internet that turned out to be big deal and countries are now looking to regulate those. And, nobody cares about Dailymotion. The Americans are shooting for complete take over of a media, not being just another small business doing video. That's why the huge capital is needed and that's why Youtube was never profitable until being acquired by Youtube and that's why only now "Youtube ads are so annoying".
- 908B64B197 6y agoMinitel demonstrated that online purchases were possible and that folks were willing to pay for things using a "computer". I really wonder why it took PayPal and Ebay to demonstrate that the same thing could be done on the real internet. > former Minitel erotic chat mogul I had to read this sentence twice to make sure.
- PoignardAzur 6y agoXavier Niel is an... interesting businessman. He's kinda our national Jeff Bezos. His video on 5g (in French) is amazing: https://twitter.com/free/status/1338754060434944002 https://twitter.com/free/status/1338754060434944002 "There's a Weber effect and the Weber effect stops the 5g from working because of the sandals."
- Pandabob 6y agoI don’t think you’re wrong about the lack of VC funding having an effect on the European startup scene. That said, I’m a little baffled that Ottawa can produce a behemoth like Shopify which has a market cap ($130bn) larger than Spotify (~$60bn) and Adyen (~55Bn) combined.
- cambalache 6y agoDont underestimate being next to America, having a FTA, same language and same timezone,among many other advantages for Canada compared to say France or Italy
- 908B64B197 6y agoThe thing is, Shopify isn't a new business model. We've had payment processors for years. If you missed on Stripe, PayPal or Square then Shopify sounds like a pretty good investment. Same thing with them building online shopping websites; Amazon and Etsy already did the market research for them. It's either go with Amazon, setup your online sales infrastructure really fast or get crushed. Now, in terms of market defining companies like Google or Apple, Canada has none. BlackBerry got crushed and failed to innovate. Nortel was wiped by Cisco and Huawei. Finally Bombardier's flagship plane was pretty much gifted to Airbus by the Trudeau administration who immediately submitted to the Trump administration.
- nr2x 6y agoCERN invented the web on public money, Google at al came a lot later.
- creato 6y agoCERN invented the text format of a webpage. I think that is roughly 0% of the R&D required to make the internet work as we know it today. This is like me developing a text rendering app on my laptop and claiming credit for the work of hardware engineering companies like Intel, Apple, etc.