2 ms·
> My understanding is that FISA requests data using warrants. Your understanding is wrong. The classified (and, statistically speaking, rubber stamp) FISA cou
by sneak 6y ago
> My understanding is that FISA requests data using warrants.
Your understanding is wrong. The classified (and, statistically speaking, rubber stamp) FISA court issues demands under the authority claimed by FISA Amendments Act (FAA) section 702, which is designed to target foreign surveillance subjects and thus under current public understandings would not require a warrant ("because foreign"). FISA surveillance orders are not warrants and do not require probable cause and are not subjected to any unclassified oversight.
However, the FISA court has a special, secret interpretation of the FISA Amendments Act (FAA) that they believe entitles them to use it to spy on everyone without a warrant as soon as the data enters or leaves the US, even if the communication is by and between solely US persons. Edward Snowden gave this as the reason he came forward about the PRISM program (PRISM being the internal, classified NSA codename for FAA702 data collection).
The large tech companies process so many of these warrantless FISA spying orders each year that they have special interfaces for the FBI/IC to request and download the data. This is what was meant by the reporting that said "direct from the servers" [of tech companies].
They don't have root on the machines, but they have programmatic access to download data for any user without a warrant. It may or may not require an approval click on the service provider side, but, in any case, that doesn't much matter.
> It’s entirely possible that they never actually do perform geolocation on the log data, and that they scrub or anonymize IP addresses before storing them longer term. They state that they use such practices in general.
It doesn't matter whether they run geolocation on the IP logs; logging the IPs is collecting a coarse tracklog regardless of whether they store it as such or not.
Second try: Please stop calling me a liar, and I'd appreciate it if you'd stop replying to every single one of my comments on this topic to cross-examine me, which is explicitly against the site rules. I'm not going to engage with you any further; I request the same from you.
- zepto 6y agoThanks for explaining the FISA part. I deliberately didn’t claim certainty on whether these legally compelled requests counted as warrants because I didn’t know for sure. > It doesn't matter whether they run geolocation on the IP logs; logging the IPs is collecting a tracklog regardless of whether they store it as such or not. The weasel words here are ‘as such’. If they substitute the IP address with an anonymous identifier after ingestion, without having first performed geolocation then they have not recorded the location data, and they do not have a record of the location data. I realize you don’t want to be critiqued, but it’s clear that you don’t have any evidence that Apple is actually storing location data on people. You only have an explanation as to how they could potentially be storing it. On almost every post regarding Apple, you insert alarming sounding statements like “Apple is recording your travel history”. You must know that you don’t actually know this for sure, and yet you persist in inserting this falsehood over and over again. Liar is a strong term, but if you had actual evidence for the claim you are making, you’d have presented it by now. When you make the claim as if it was a truth, when you know you really don’t know for sure, I think it’s fair to say you are lying. Perhaps the first time it could have been that you were just mistaken or making incorrect assumptions, but at this point it seems deliberate. It’s true that I’ve challenged you on this a couple of times. It’s simply not true that I have replied to every one of your comments on this topic. As I pointed out earlier, elsewhere on this thread you pointed out that IP addresses can leak coarse location data. I didn’t respond to that. As for ‘cross-examining’ you, I agree that is against the site guidelines, however I don’t see myself as doing that to you in general. The site needs to have some way of distinguishing between cross-examination and challenging outright lies. It would seem weird to tolerate polemics which veer into misinformation as comments, and yet not allow this to be challenged. I’m curious why it’s so important to insert this particular idea about Apple into the conversation? It seems especially weird when we’re taking about cellphones, whose location is of course logged by cell companies and is definitely accessible to both law enforcement and other government agencies.