13 ms·
>Another interesting tidbit is the answer to the common trope that 'private platform can act as they wish since they are private' : Now the EU is saying the sa
by ksec 6y ago
>Another interesting tidbit is the answer to the common trope that 'private platform can act as they wish since they are private' :
Now the EU is saying the same thing to Apple. It is their market, and they dictate the rules. Which is perhaps a taste of Apple's own medicine?
I wonder what those people who keep saying it is Apple's platform they can do what ever they want had to say?
I sometimes wonder had Apple not been such an arse with its App Store and monopolistic rules. Would these regulations ever come up.
- nickff 6y agoThe EU didn't create its citizens (unlike Apple which created its products); saying that the EU 'owns' their market is quite a big step in assuming control over the lives of residents.
- avianlyric 6y ago> quite a big step in assuming control over the lives of residents. Have you heard of laws and governments before? This is exactly what they do, it’s also why democracy is such a big thing. If you’re gonna give that much power to an organisation, you want to make sure you can change it if start going off the rails. > The EU didn't create its citizens (unlike Apple which created its products); It might not have “created” it’s citizens. But it certainly created and maintains the environment that make those citizens wealthy and capable of being a market for Apple.
- nickff 6y agoI was just answering the parent's question: "I wonder what those people who keep saying it is Apple's platform they can do what ever they want had to say?" With respect to political authority, I have some rather unpopular views... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Problem_of_Political_Authority https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Problem_of_Political_Autho...
- bserge 6y agoThey're nice views, I entertain myself that way sometimes, too. But they all fall apart at the first meeting with the police, especially when you're the suspect. We're powerless. And that's "just" the police, the military is the actual force of a government and they're absolutely not keen on listening to your philosophies. It's an interesting world, for sure.
- jariel 6y ago"do, it’s also why democracy is such a big thing" Voters of France and Netherlands strongly rejected the treaty upon which the EU derives is legitimacy. Referendums were cancelled elsewhere. Ursula von der Leyen did not receive any votes, she wasn't even part of the process, she was an unknown German figure until after the election, when she was plucked from obscurity by actors acting in total opacity, behind closed doors: "Here is your New Leader". I respect much of the commercial facility of the EU, but it's severely lacking in democracy. And while I think a lot of the intentions of the current system are reasonable, a lot of it is not ... and I'm super concerned that totally unelected and unaccountable elite are just going to be smashing their big hands into the economy, with the simplistic populist notions of 'American Economic Imperialism' and a kind of anti-American jealousy just under the surface. It'd be nice to see much more thoughtfulness here, but more importantly, mechanisms to improve European competitiveness.
- avianlyric 6y agoThe EU democratic structure is complex, that for sure. But it's hardly undemocratic. The EU has always struggled to explain how it works, why it's structure works the way it does. But all the leaders in the EU are elected, just not always via direct elections. A process that actually isn't that unusual in the world. The US is actually a bit of an outlier, because they have direct elections for almost every position in government, with some slightly mixed results. The EU it's common for countries to select and organise their executive bodies via in-direct elections. For example in the UK our prime minister isn't directly elected, the general public didn't "choose" Boris Johnson. Instead the conservative party did, via its own methodology which it can change any time it does. The current byzantine system exists out of a need to somehow balance the power of the EU as a federal entity, against the sovereignty of the individual nations. With irony come from the fact that the "unelected" leader only exist because it give more power to leaders of the member states, and takes it away from the EU as an organisation independent of its member states and their elected governments.
- Silhouette 6y agoThe EU democratic structure is complex, that for sure. But it's hardly undemocratic. I don't really want to start a rehash of the entire Brexit debate we had in the UK, but the EU does have a serious democratic deficit. Ask yourself this simple question: Can a citizen who is governed by the EU meaningfully influence who is doing that governing? In particular, can a large group of citizens affect who holds power within the EU and vote out those individuals they don't want, so any individual office holder has some degree of personal accountability to the electorate? It would take quite a leap to argue that the European Commission, which is where most of the real power still lies in practice, would meet any of those standards. It is debatable whether even the European Parliament does, though it is at least more directly affected by the public vote. For example in the UK our prime minister isn't directly elected, the general public didn't "choose" Boris Johnson. Instead the conservative party did, via its own methodology which it can change any time it does. Our arrangement here in the UK suffers from a similar problem of failing to faithfully represent the will of the electorate. FPTP is a deeply flawed voting system on purely mathematical grounds, and then the mechanics through which the PM and by extension the government come to power once MPs have been elected can be even more distorted. If you don't think it matters that many of our population have little influence over who occupies Number 10, I would respectfully remind you that one of the first things each new PM does is handwrite four letters that could literally cause the end of the world as we know it.
- alacombe 6y ago> Have you heard of laws and governments before? This is exactly what they do, it’s also why democracy is such a big thing. The EU has been designed to be as anti-democratic as can be, from its very inception.
- raffraffraff 6y agoDon't the citizens create the government in a democracy?
- Sargos 6y agoNo, at least not in the semi-democracy systems that are in use today. In most western countries the citizens are allowed to vote on a portion of the people that create and run the government. It varies between countries but even in those nearest a system that resembles democracy the citizens don't have much power over what happens or who most of the people running the system are.
- renewiltord 6y agoI suspect a vast amount of policy is made by perma-bureaucrats.
- Mountain_Skies 6y agoGovernments do however create corporations, which is an artificial structure that can only exist due to government control over the intersection between the marketplace and the legal system.
- alacombe 6y agoI'd be tempted to think the concept of "corporations" pre-dates "government" as we know them today, and these secular traditions were merely enshrined in Law.
- dariosalvi78 6y agoyou know what sort of corporations you get without governments? without schools and universities that educate their employers? or the research that has supported ALL the technologies that these companies have exploited? or build ALL the infrastructure (roads, electricity, water...)
- alacombe 6y agoThat wasn't the point.
- bla3 6y agoThe EU is its citizens. So in a sense the EU did create its citizens.
- nickff 6y agoI'm actually an EU citizen, who has never lived there, and never even visited. I did not create the EU; did the EU create me?
- Fargren 6y agoIf your parent are EU citizens, and the EU 'is it's citizens' (which is controversial but defensible) then yes, the EU did create you.
- nickff 6y agoNone of my family have ever resided in the EU either. I think I understand the argument you're trying to make, but it relies on some rather tortured logic.
- mnl 6y agoI fail to understand how your particular case works. Not having a horse in the race but just a piece of paper you don't care about doesn't help you to make a point, which is what exactly?
- Barrin92 6y agoOf course the EU created her citizens, do you think European citizenship is some sort of fact of nature? Like people woke up in Europe in a cave and were like "Yeah of course we're cosmopolitan citizens of the United European states" ? All the rules, all the borders, all their values have been created, quite hard earned in fact, with a lot of blood and sweat along the way I might add, even more so than at an Apple smartphone factory if you can believe it.
- alacombe 6y agoThere is no such thing as "EU citizenship". I am a French citizen, my passport says I am a French citizen, and I do not have a SINGLE legal document mentioning "European citizen".
- Mijka 6y agoJust checked the cover and first page of my french passport (made in 2013). There's 3 lines written in different languages in this order : - Union européenne - République française - Passeport It doesn't says "French citizen" either, just "French Republic" and "European Union" multiple times.
- alacombe 6y ago> It doesn't says "French citizen" either, just "French Republic" and "European Union" multiple times. Yes it does, it's clearly written: "Nationalite: Francaise" NOT: "Nationalite: Francaise, Europeenne"
- emteycz 6y agoThat's your nationality, that's different from citizenship. The EU uses the term a lot officially
- CaptArmchair 6y agoHow about the passport of the European Union? [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passports_of_the_European_Union https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passports_of_the_European_Unio...
- avianlyric 6y ago> I sometimes wonder had Apple not been such an arse with its App Store and monopolistic rules. Would these regulations ever come up. Nah these regulations were always coming. Everyone always likes to pick on Apple and the App Store, but quite frankly in the EU (where iPhones market share is only 24% compared to 49% in the US) Apple is small fries compared to companies like Facebook which basically owns 100% of social media.
- an_opabinia 6y ago"Small fries" and 24%... Anyway you're right but it's like, how would any of this concretely improve competition? In my experience, the problem is that giant companies steal your stuff, whether it's your code or your users, and that even when you want to enforce something like that, they can afford better lawyers than you. Like nobody here is working on social networks, cellphones or web browsers. I bet you interact with IP law almost every single day though, and a lot of truly disruptive things have termination conditions like, "And then a giant company sues you for IP violations and you go bankrupt, even if you're in the right." Maybe this benefits giant European tech companies, but it certainly doesn't benefit competition.
- avianlyric 6y ago> "Small fries" and 24%... Everythings relative. You've got to start somewhere. > Anyway you're right but it's like, how would any of this concretely improve competition? I don't think this is just about competition. There has to be a recognition that social networks etc are natural monopolies, it's very hard to have competition there. Regardless of HNs utopian view of open protocols and distributed and federated social networks, the reality is that it's just not gonna happen. So a I feel a big part of these laws isn't about creating competition, it's about making sure that mega-corporations like Facebook can't amase more power than democratically elected governments. These law make it clear that if you get to big, the EU will step in and make sure you're operating in line with their ideals, not the other way around.
- alacombe 6y ago
- SllX 6y agoThe difference is that Apple is not a government. That means they are not an organization which can legally stop, detain, arrest, charge, prosecute, convict, imprison, and kill you.
- username90 6y agoEU have about much power to imprison you as Apple does, as in they can't unless they can convince the local police you have committed some crime. They lack power compared to US feds.
- SllX 6y agoThey’re still a collaborative governmental entity with governments enforcing its laws, so they pass muster as far as being a “State” goes, unless you want to go into specifics about the various treaties and how this is really a treaty organization and blah. In the looks, walks and quacks like a duck, with all the other ducks around treating it like a duck, it’s a bloody government with all the powers that entails, even if enforcement is a matter left to the member nations that do have all of the powers I just outlined. I actually did write recently in a HN comment outlining the difference between the EU and Feds, but in terms of power, the EU is closer to the US Federal Government than to Apple because it still has laws. Apple is a private organization with a corporate charter, owned by shareholders, controlled by its Board of Directors and with the ability to engage in lawful business activity, with none of the powers that governments have. They don’t have jurisdiction, they have stores. They don’t make laws, they write policies. They don’t levy taxes, they trade. The fees of the App Store are a known quantity, and you can take them or leave them. So in that light, does it still make sense to try to control Apple like a government entity or treat them like some kind of pseudo-government or rhetorically refer to their business practices using language we use to describe governments? Why do we demand so much more accountability from governments including supranational intergovernmental treaty organizations controlled by governments than we do from private shareholder owned and controlled organizations? Honestly think about it.
- jevgeni 6y ago
- Grimm1 6y agoThis is weird to me, the argument is not just that company X is a private platform so they should be able to do what they want it is that they're a private US platform and in the US they can do what they want because that's generally the law and social understanding of companies in the US. At least for me it was never that company X can do what they want globally. That's silly they're subject to the laws of the jurisdiction under which they operate. The EU is free to regulate them just like the US is free not to regulate them.
- LudwigNagasena 6y agoThe argument against/for what? Do you think people who call for new legislation think it is already illegal? This would make no sense.
- Grimm1 6y agoThe argument that since they're a private platform they should be able to do what they want. I don't think it's ever been a blanket argument globally because the concept of a private entity is very different from nation to nation.
- LudwigNagasena 6y agoI am not sure anyone aside from a tiny minority of hardcore libertarians believes that "since they're a private platform they should be able to do what they want" is a valid argument.
- Grimm1 6y agoSure, I think I'd agree there but the OP phrased this like "Take that all you people who have been saying this" I was like that must be a fraction of a fraction of people who were.
- coliveira 6y agoCorporations cannot do "what they want" in the US, they're subject to regulations and to anti-trust laws. The problem is that the government (both parties) has been very lax about anti-trust enforcement. So now we have companies that are virtual monopolies and oligopolies trying to remove whatever regulations still remain in the books.