3 ms·
> It's almost as hard to come up with a fair number on how much help a given person should get due to being adversely affected by the pandemic. Yet that's not s
by smt88 6y ago
> It's almost as hard to come up with a fair number on how much help a given person should get due to being adversely affected by the pandemic. Yet that's not seen as a barrier to provide money.
Absolutely not. That is ludicrous.
There are measurable effects to the pandemic: changes in income, medical expenses, etc. There is certainly an emotional toll for even the best-off people, but no one is proposing paying people for emotional pain. It's all about getting them through this exceptional (and temporary) time.
Reparations for slavery are about things that can't be measured (generations of lost opportunities, not months), immense/immeasurable pain, and a long tail of policies (like racist zoning laws) that outlived slavery by 100+ years.
Your analogy to the pandemic actually makes it even more stark how difficult it is to calculate something so large, complex, and obscured by the fog of history.
> As a collective? Yes.
OK, let's say you do this. Let's say you decide the amount that a particular official/organized tribe should get is $1T. You don't have to decide who gets the money because the tribe has already done all that legwork for you and has an official roll.
Now how do you decide who pays? Do you try to trace the heritage of every American and determine when/how they took tribal land?
Maybe not. So do you just take it out of social programs? The same social programs that are intended to fix some of the cycles of poverty that people descended from slaves are relying on to get them some equity?
Well, you can't do that either. So how do you decide who pays, and who decides who pays?
Eventually you get into the business of punishing or rewarding people for their ancestors' crimes, which is not at all different from forcing a murderer's child to give money to his victim's family. If you look at it in a microcosm, it seems completely insane because it is.
Your ancestry definitely has a big effect on your life, but that's not the same as being culpable for their crimes, and it's not deterministic. My family was fantastically wealthy until my dad's generation, and then they were poor. Should my dad, as a completely broke 25-year-old, have had to pay reparations to someone for his ancestors' wealth (which I'm sure was gained unfairly)?
- seph-reed 6y ago> Reparations for slavery are about things that can't be measured If it can't be measured, it should be omitted. Nobody is suggesting making up random numbers based off feelings. > Should my dad, as a completely broke 25-year-old, have had to pay reparations to someone for his ancestors' wealth (which I'm sure was gained unfairly)? First off, if your dad is actually 25, you are fantastically intelligent for your age (and props for that). But also, there are ways to use math to make things fair. For instance: progressive taxation based off wealth. Lower income pay a small percentage (probably less than 1%) while higher income pays 1-2%. And given that slavery lasted ~90 years, so too could the timeline for paying reparations. There are solutions here. Nobody is saying do it all at once and make people starve. But there is a way to pay off -- if nothing else -- the debt of unpaid hours. It's better late than never, and if there is one thing the world respects about Germany, it's that they owned up. We can too. Honestly, I'd be willing to say this could be one of the best cost vs benefit long-term PR investments the US could make on the world stage. But only if it's done right, and not as a punitive thing.
- smt88 6y ago> If it can't be measured, it should be omitted. Nobody is suggesting making up random numbers based off feelings. Then reparations for slavery are completely off the table. You can't measure the economic output of someone who died 150-400 years ago. There are major disputes about what a human life is worth now, when we know every possible detail about them. > First off, if your dad is actually 25, you are fantastically intelligent for your age I think you missed where I said "have had to pay" (meaning "when he was 25"). > But there is a way to pay off -- if nothing else -- the debt of unpaid hours. Let's assume, first, that people are owed money that rightfully belonged to their great-great-great-great-great-great-great-great-great grandparents. I would disagree with that, but I'll leave that aside for now. How much are the following worth, in today's dollars? - 1 hour of planting crops at 3pm on a sunny day in Alabama in February of 1802 - 1 hour of planting crops at 10am on a cloudy day in Georgia in March of 1791 - 1 hour of breastfeeding a slaver's baby - 1 hour of cooking food for a 10-person family Are those worth $5? Surely not, because minimum wage is higher than that. But that is what a lot of undocumented immigrants get paid for the same work, so maybe $5 is correct? Or is it worth $50, because those people's bodies were in constant pain from beatings, over-work, malnutrition, and poor health care? Let's say we settle on $25/hour. If we divide it up between that person's 1,000+ descendants, it's not much money. But then we have to consider the interest! Should we use the national rate of inflation? Should we just peg it to the adjusted dollar? Should we assume that money would've been invested in gold? I think you see my point. There is no way to come up with a formula for any of this that makes any sense. And then once you get to the end and decide on a number, how do you decide who pays it? Should recent immigrants pay reparations for slavery? Should a rural, white meth addict lying in their own vomit pay reparations for all of their "privileges"? It makes far, far more sense to just have a strong society safety net and not try to figure out what events 100, 200, or 500 years ago resulted in someone's current situation. > if there is one thing the world respects about Germany, it's that they owned up. We can too The example of Germany supports my point. Here are the major differences: - Germany was forced to pay most of its reparations by the Allies - Planning for German reparations began a few months after the war ended - Many Germans were enslaved by the Allies as a form of reparation, and those people were then paid reparations - Much of the rest of Germany's reparations were paid directly to Holocaust survivors[1] or their spouses or to Israel, not to millions of their descendants hundreds of years later[2] The best number I can find for the total reparations paid by Germany is ~€60B, which translates to €4.3k for every living Jew (~14M) since 1945. I know that's not perfect, because some Holocaust survivors are dead and many living Jews are not descended from one, but bear with me. If you look at that number yearly by person, you get €57/person/year. That is not a meaningful amount of money compared to the consequences of slavery, even if you change it by a couple of orders of magnitude. Germany arguably owes Jewish people trillions of euros, not billions. 1. https://www.nytimes.com/2012/11/18/world/europe/for-60th-year-germany-honors-duty-to-pay-holocaust-victims.html https://www.nytimes.com/2012/11/18/world/europe/for-60th-yea... 2. https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/german-holocaust-reparations https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/german-holocaust-repara... 3. https://www.bundestag.de/resource/blob/410502/23e348e9f5c6c046abd707258f284eae/wd-4-086-07-pdf-data.pdf https://www.bundestag.de/resource/blob/410502/23e348e9f5c6c0...