4 ms·
> A interesting point missing from the BBC article is that they have different levels of expectations between small to medium businesses and large ones, to avoi
by throwaway894345 6y ago
> A interesting point missing from the BBC article is that they have different levels of expectations between small to medium businesses and large ones, to avoid regulatory capture ? :
It's easy to overlook, but the BBC article does have this line:
> It introduces a sliding scale, under which firms take on more obligations the larger and more influential they are.
> Another interesting tidbit is the answer to the common trope that 'private platform can act as they wish since they are private' :
In the US we have a similar trope with respect to social media companies, that they don't have a responsibility to protect free speech because they are a private entity; however, they also argue that they aren't responsible when they curate illegal content.
EDIT: Wow, I didn't expect this to be a controversial or particularly unpopular comment. I wonder if downvoters could elaborate a bit on their objections?
- core-questions 6y ago> they don't have a responsibility to protect free speech because they are a private entity It continually amazes me when I see people who are ostensibly on the left trotting out this chestnut like as though it's even remotely a valid argument for the curtailment of one of the most important rights over the past few centuries. It's like as though they're in complete denial about the idea that this kind of speech control could ever negatively impact them. Must be nice to be completely aligned with corporatism to the extend that your personal set of values is literally dictated to you by the Google HR department.
- avianlyric 6y agoStrange argument your making there. One of the interesting side effects of free speech rights is also the prevention of forced speech. After all how can you have free speech if someone else can force to express views you don’t hold? Why should my right to free speech trump your right to not be forced to speak? Equally what right to I have to force any corporation to publish and distribute speech they don’t agree with? Based on the argument your making, you’re saying that I have the right to go to your home, plaster it with posters that you disagree with, then prevent you from removing them. Does that sound like free speech to you?
- cgriswald 6y agoA fairer comparison is Facebook as a community bulletin board in a public space but that is privately owned. What the conclusions should be and whether technical, philosophical, or practical matters should take precedence, I’m not entirely sure.
- lovecg 6y agoIt’s a bulletin board with a bunch of hired people with megaphones around it. The company decides which announcements the people with megaphones shout out. It’s free to decide not to.
- core-questions 6y agoI don't see how I am forcing you as a person to say a damn thing. You've entered into a new level of tactical nihilism here. > you’re saying that I have the right to go to your home, plaster it with posters that you disagree with, then prevent you from removing them. How is your personal home the same thing as a gigantic, billion-user social network that has effectively (especially in 2020) replaced the pub, the bar, the town square, and the public forum? It's not, and you know it isn't. Step back and look at yourself: you're defending the right of billion dollar corporations to tell you what you can and cannot say. > Does that sound like free speech to you?
- throwaway894345 6y ago> How is your personal home the same thing as a gigantic, billion-user social network that has effectively (especially in 2020) replaced the pub, the bar, the town square, and the public forum? It's not, and you know it isn't. I think the scale is a good point (no idea what your original post contained since it was flagged before I read it). Twitter and a handful of other social media companies handle (by which I mean "choose who gets to see what content") such an enormous volume of speech that its moderation policies can influence elections and therefore public policy. Moreover, their power is inherently anti-competitive--users can't take their network to another platform because these platforms don't interoperate by design. It seems like this is an antitrust issue, especially since these networks tend to lobby together to protect their interests.
- jariel 6y agoI think you have the FB issue upside down. Do you think the EU is interested in 'free speech'? No, the EU want to make sure that they able to suppress language they don't like. In some cases, it's probably for the common good, but in many others ... not so much. The EU, US and other actors definitely want FB et. al. to suppress information which they deem as 'factually innacurate' (things that can sway elections, scare people away from vaccines etc.) in addition to a few other points of interest, for example, things they deem 'hate speech' etc.. Edit: Personally - I'm not sure how I feel about any of it really, but it's definitely not the case that either the EU is primarily to ensure 'free speech'. Austria high court ruling for a form of censorship: "that Facebook remove a post insulting a former Green Party leader, keep equivalent posts off its site, and do so on a global scale." [1] And at then at the EU level: "Facebook Risks EU Court Order to Censor Hateful Posts Globally" [2] This is the general theme of EU judicial and legislative activity. I don't see anything really that much in the other direction. [1] https://slate.com/technology/2020/11/austria-facebook-eva-glawischnig-piesczek-censorship.html https://slate.com/technology/2020/11/austria-facebook-eva-gl... [2] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-10-02/facebook-risks-eu-court-order-to-censor-hateful-posts-globally https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-10-02/facebook-...
- throwaway894345 6y agoI didn't mention Facebook at all...? My comment certainly wasn't intended to be subtext about any particular Facebook drama.
- newsgourmet 6y agoFacebook is an example of the type of big company you were talking about.