2 ms·
As usual for Schneier, a thoughtful, complete, balanced article. It will be hard to put guardrails on this stuff. It's pretty much 100% "gray area," easy to ca
by ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago
As usual for Schneier, a thoughtful, complete, balanced article.
It will be hard to put guardrails on this stuff. It's pretty much 100% "gray area," easy to cast in many ways.
- sneak 6y agoI'm a little sad to see him falling into the "we are under attack and something must be done!" narrative around free and open discussion on the internet. By all accounts, the election system in the US is working, most people aren't antivaxxers, and belief in an undetectable wizard in the sky seems to be falling. We are winning the war against misinformation. Why are so many smart people claiming that we aren't, and that more censorship is required? > [TFA, Schneier] In this regard, the United States, already extremely polarized, sits on a precipice. Citation needed.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoHere's one. There are plenty of others. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-social-media-makes-us-more-polarized-and-how-to-fix-it/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-social-media-...
- sneak 6y agoIt doesn't offer any indication that social media is the root cause of the current state of political polarization in the US, or any indication that polarization is bad or harmful. I think people place far too much stock in US partisan screaming. It simply doesn't matter that much. I'm not arguing that the US isn't polarized, that much is clear. I just don't see any precipice.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoSocial media is not the cause of any of this. The techniques used, are probably hundreds of years old (maybe thousands). Social media is just a new medium; but an effective one that allows scale. I'm old enough to remember when television occupied the same slot.
- sneak 6y agoWhy does social media not pose the same polarization threat to large free countries other than the US? We're not seeing any large-scale global shift toward political polarization, and, Facebook is pretty much everywhere in the west.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI wouldn't bet that other countries are exempt. If I remember, Europe has had quite a lot of trouble, due to polarization. I grew up in Africa, where tribal conflicts were absolutely horrifying. These types of campaigns are usually multi-pronged, sustained and coordinated. They aren't really effective, unless they are all managed by a central director. Dog whistles only work if you train the dogs. I think that it's about where the effort is directed. The US is a huge target. This nation has an oversize influence on the world, and it's natural for other nations that either resent this influence, and/or want to exert their own, to do as much as possible to damage the US. Looks like they've done a fairly good job.
- aaron695 6y agoYou are right. Witchcraft accusations (which honestly in the 80's there were a lot) are way down. People understand glass is not a liquid. All music is now mainstream. String Theory is being exposed as a religion. But people are very polarised on what they do disagree with. You wouldn't fire someone for being in the KKK 30 years ago. Now you fire someone for naive accidents. I don't know what to think on your point.