4 ms·
Journaling: a better UI metaphor than files/folders/desktops?
- gm 18y agoVery interesting... Except I suck at remembering dates. It would be a cool addition to the directory structure, not a replacement.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoYou can probably remember yesterday, 2 days ago and last weekend. I suspect those dates encompass 80% of the use cases for such a tool.
- gm 18y agoWell, you're gonna laugh, but... I usually don't know what day of the week it is. I stopped observing weekends a long time ago, so everything's kinda lost in time. Besides, with the things I do, I have to keep careful records for a long time, and be able to find anything really quick. Right now I organize things by theme (project, topic, etc...). An alternate organization scheme that does not get in the way would be cool. For me organizing anything by exact date is overkill. I need to be able to organize by day, month, week, or year (all at the same time).
- misuba 18y agoYes! This was the major mistake that doomed Lifestreams: the whole notion that UI and finding your stuff is an either-or proposition. Let's give people MORE ways to find their stuff, not (just) a different one. (And, naturally, provide a more sensible default than the desktop metaphor we provide by default now.)
- LurkingGrue 18y agoI am one of those weird people that can remember where I put files. I would have a hard time remembering when I put files so I am not sure I would like that interface.
- josch 18y agoCf. http://cs-www.cs.yale.edu/homes/freeman/lifestreams.html http://cs-www.cs.yale.edu/homes/freeman/lifestreams.html
- greyman 18y agoI quite successfully adopted an aproach from GTD methodology. The main pillars are three different folders: 1) INBOX - unprocessed input, usually files downloaded from the web or saved attachments. 2) PROJECTS - here, I create subfolders, one subfolder for one Project. In the subfolders, there are files I actively work on, like doc files. 3) REFERENCES - here, I store files I am not working on, like ebooks, texts, photos, etc. So, in the slide example, I would not lost the file location, since I know it will be in the folder Projects\Write-Essay-On-Teaching. If the project is finished, I remove the directory (and put final output into Refenrences, if necessary). I realized, at least in my case, that the main problem causing mess on the HDD was related to the fact, that unprocessed, working-on and reference files were stored together by topics.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- omouse 18y agoThe OLPC features something similar to this: http://wiki.laptop.org/go/Journal http://wiki.laptop.org/go/Journal http://laptop.org/en/laptop/start/journal.shtml http://laptop.org/en/laptop/start/journal.shtml You know, for all the trash talk about the OLPC and it's lack of a regular GUI, it sure does have a few innovative ideas in there that we could learn from.
- unalone 18y agoHow much trash talk is there regarding the OLPC itself? All the criticism I've heard is for the company designing it, not for the computers themselves.
- omouse 18y agoThere's always at least one person that will say, "give them food or water instead", and another saying, "how will this prepare them for the future? the OLPC's GUI is nothing like Windows, Mac or Linux. How can they get a job working with computers??" Maybe that isn't a lot of trash talk, but it quickly gets annoying and old.
- unalone 18y agoThe first comment: makes a little sense, I think. The second one: bleh. Theoretically, working with the Mac didn't give you experience with the iPhone. Two radically different interfaces, even with Leopard multitouch. It's the CONCEPT of computing that needs to be taught, not the INTERFACE. If you see those critics anywhere, slap 'em for me or something.
- cpr 18y agoMaybe, but the Lifestreams people are suing anyone who doesn't pony up for their patents. (E.g., Apple for Time Machine, which is a real stretch.)
- LogicHoleFlaw 18y agoHopefully software patents will be emasculated and stop being a 'big stick' for companies like that to carry around.
- defunkt 18y agoI love how these slides clearly demonstrate the difference between UI and graphic design: the examples are bare bones yet highly functional.
- ComputerGuru 18y agoGod, someone needs a better UI metaphor than those hideous slides!
- unalone 18y agoThat was terrible presentation. That would have worked much better as a document than as a slide. Aesthetic criticism aside, isn't this something that some OSes already have? Mac OS X lets you see all the files you edited yesterday, for instance. Doesn't that negate the need for a journal, or is there something I'm missing?
- orib 18y agoIt was prepared for an in-person talk at GUADEC (a Gnome conference). Documents don't work very well for presentations.
- unalone 18y agoThey could scroll down really, really fast... :-P Couldn't they have used Present, or whatever that OpenOffice thing is?
- derefr 18y agoI think it's a matter of the default or "root" UI, the one you have to go through to access your desktop metaphor of choice, and therefore the "safe" place that most people will return to. This was, in order of addition (but not necessarily replacement), the command line, the desktop, and most recently the "media center" menu. Having the computer start up with a calendar or infinite time-line filling the screen, and remain so when idle, would certainly encourage the metaphor.
- cosmok 18y agoI like the concept and it makes a lot of sense as I open a lot of different file, browse a lot of different sites and do not always remember the name. I created a bookmark app (very raw), that orders my bookmarks based on the time they were save and it is tremendously useful.(the url for the bookmarker is public and is http://www.trk7.com/install/xxx.php http://www.trk7.com/install/xxx.php (click on the calendar tab), just in case u want to check)
- rozim 18y agoGive the user multiple ways of accessing information, not just one. Remember this acronym: LATCH Location / Alphabetical / Time / Category ("tag"?) / Hierarchy. http://www.informit.com/articles/article.aspx?p=130881&seqNum=6 http://www.informit.com/articles/article.aspx?p=130881&s... It's a good mnemonic for GUI design - get a GUI up then consider LATCH and add another path or view of the info.