5 ms·
Nah, flying is totally defensible. I fly everywhere. The problem is offsetting your emissions. Most people are offloading their externalities to the Earth. Sinc
by renewiltord 6y ago
Nah, flying is totally defensible. I fly everywhere. The problem is offsetting your emissions. Most people are offloading their externalities to the Earth. Since climate change is a non-local phenomenon you can be carbon negative for very cheap if you pay to reduce carbon emissions.
Also, it's a little bit rich to listen to any sort of climate talk from anyone in cold countries¹. They emit so much carbon just to be warm. Well, I don't, because I live in California.
¹ Between 14% and 30% of total emissions are from heating in Germany for instance https://www.bmu.de/fileadmin/Daten_BMU/Download_PDF/Klimaschutz/klimaschutz_zahlen_2019_fs_gebaeude_de_bf.pdf https://www.bmu.de/fileadmin/Daten_BMU/Download_PDF/Klimasch...
- freeflight 6y ago> Since climate change is a non-local phenomenon you can be carbon negative for very cheap if you pay to reduce carbon emissions. How does that work in practical reality so it doesn't just turn into a money making scheme with no real impact akin to Catholic indulgences? > Also, it's a little bit rich to listen to any sort of climate talk from anyone in cold countries¹. They emit so much carbon just to be warm. Well, I don't, because I live in California. How many emissions in the US come from the use of AC and heating due to basically zero federal building standards for energy efficiency? [0] Afaik AC is generally considered way more inefficient, heating can be captured as a side-product from a lot of processes, cooling not so much. [0] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/328701132_A_comparison_of_building_energy_codes_and_policies_in_the_USA_Germany_and_China_progress_toward_the_net-zero_building_goal_in_three_countries https://www.researchgate.net/publication/328701132_A_compari...
- renewiltord 6y ago> How does that work in practical reality so it doesn't just turn into a money making scheme with no real impact akin to Catholic indulgences? As a matter of policy? Universal carbon-tax with increasing fee schedules. Everyone pays for their carbon emissions. The sum is then distributed back to everyone evenly as a Green Dividend minus admin costs. Net zero cash to the government, whopping undirected green energy subsidy possible by tuning amounts. It already worked for Sulphur Dioxide. As a matter of personal preference? Well, I get nothing from this except the right to brag I'm carbon negative so really it could totally be equivalent to indulgences. As it so happens I do care to be doing my part, but you're right in that there's no incentive for that. > How many emissions in the US come from the use of AC and heating due to basically zero federal building standards for energy efficiency? Right, but I live in California and have no AC.
- dash2 6y agoI think the practical question is, how do you know when you buy carbon offsets that you are really offsetting carbon? There's an awful lot of scope for fakery out there.
- renewiltord 6y agoI trust TerraPass because I can go see their stuff.
- eganist 6y ago> Most people are offloading their externalities to the Earth. I'm having a hard time understanding this sentence.
- schrodinger 6y agoReally? They’re saying that most people who fly are unaware and unaccountable for the negative impact their flight has on the health of the planet due to carbon emissions, among other things.
- jnxx 6y ago> Nah, flying is totally defensible. I fly everywhere. The problem is offsetting your emissions. You are in denial about the destruction you do. No, you can't offset emissions. A single short flight will release as much as 400kg CO2 to the atmosphere. This amount of carbon was bound by huge forests about millions of years. It is not possible to undo that release by planting a tree. Ask a geologist if you do not believe me. And I am not saying it is not good to protect forests. Of course it is. But if you have any rational choice between offsetting and not flying, offsetting and flying, not offsetting, not flying -- not flying is always the best option.
- renewiltord 6y agoOne mature oak tree is like 20 kg / year. You can easily plant a sufficient quantity to cover that. Especially since Earth is not at carrying capacity yet. But that's hardly necessary. I can just pay you the minimum necessary to get you to shift off fossil and I make some good savings.
- mrpopo 6y agoPlease note that all coherent carbon neutrality scenarios use tree planting for carbon offsetting PLUS a reduction in plane travel. There are more essential services that will require carbon sinks to function at full regime. Air travel is easily replaceable by low-carbon alternatives that exist today. When you do the accounting of carbon offsetting/carbon sinks capacity, it becomes quite obvious everything unnecessary must go.
- renewiltord 6y agoOf course, I don't disagree with the reduction. But an economically efficient reduction will reduce from people who can't afford to pay the premium and leave people like me to spend appropriately. This is possible precisely because it is unnecessary. If air travel were necessary then we'd have to ration it by person. Since it is not, we can afford to ration it by the dollar.
- 6y ago
- jnxx 6y ago> Between 14% and 30% of total emissions are from heating in Germany Heating is a large factor in emissions but if you fly several times a year, it is without doubt the largest source of emissions.
- jnxx 6y agoYou can check that here yourself - it is a carbon footprint calculator from the German Federal Environment Agency: https://uba.co2-rechner.de/en_GB/ https://uba.co2-rechner.de/en_GB/ https://uba.co2-rechner.de/de_DE/start https://uba.co2-rechner.de/de_DE/start