4 ms·
Is this a full discrete logic implementation? Other Apple 1 kits I've seen have cheated on various bits such as the video/character generator and keyboard inte
by musicale 6y ago
Is this a full discrete logic implementation?
Other Apple 1 kits I've seen have cheated on various bits such as the video/character generator and keyboard interface by using an embedded microcontroller, which seems to defeat the purpose of an Apple 1 recreation.
It's not too hard to generate a simple black and white video signal, and it's an interesting bit that I would definitely want to try.
The Apple 1 is unfortunately a disappointing game machine because of its serial-style terminal interface, so you can't really create an interactive display, even with block character graphics.
Obviously an Apple ][ recreation would be an excellent game machine, but it's quite a bit more complicated, particularly things like video, PAL chips, and especially storage (which you'd probably want.)
- duskwuff 6y agoGiven the size of the "Keyboard", "Video", and "Hi-Res Video" chips, I'd wager a guess that they're ATmega microcontrollers with sticky labels on them. The kit looks like it's taken some other shortcuts as well. The original system used an array of DRAMs, for example, not the single SRAM in this kit (which didn't exist when the Apple I was made). The original Apple II was almost entirely discrete logic -- no PALs. It'd actually be a great target for reproduction.
- dhosek 6y agoAnd it came with a circuit diagram of the computer.
- OJFord 6y agoI'm really curious about when that changed as a norm, I assume it was gradual, but there must have been some 'turning points' (said with my apologies to mathematics). I used to be keen on '80s Pioneer stereo amplifiers, the SA-8xx range if I recall correctly, (I'm younger than them) and they all came with schematics. Nothing contemporary to me did (that I had) though.
- reaperducer 6y agoI'm really curious about when that changed as a norm The Commodore 64 didn't have one in the box, but IIRC, it was part of the Programmer's Reference Guide. That would have been about 1983ish. That was the last one I ever saw.
- dhosek 6y agoI think the circuit diagram was no longer included with the //e but definitely was with the ][+ so for Apple., at least, that provides a boundary line.
- sergpanarin 6y agoYes, you are right – controllers are made on ATmega328PU chips so drivers could be easily modified and uploaded to the chips via FTDI cable. E.g. you could change color of the screen
- ardy42 6y ago> The kit looks like it's taken some other shortcuts as well. The original system used an array of DRAMs, for example, not the single SRAM in this kit (which didn't exist when the Apple I was made). Are the parts still widely available enough that you could realistically build an accurate replica? If not, I wonder if parts are available that someone could still design a kit computer (without cheating) that could be assembled from discrete through-hole components with reasonable amount of skill.
- peteri 6y agoFor the Apple II there are already some reproductions of the Rev 0 PCB but there are already plenty of originals (non-rev0) out there in the wild, they're not really rare enough (particularly given their use in the US schools system). I have six a ][ EuroPlus, three //es, a //c and an ITT2020 and once upon a time had a lot more. The biggest issue is the RIFA caps going in the PSU. As Apple I diy kits these are a little bit too modern for my tastes. I prefer my retro remakes to stick much more closely to the original design. The only real "fake" that I have is the PiDP 11/70 front panel which has a Raspberry PI running an emulation as it's CPU. There are a long list of modern remakes around in the retro computing community, but most stuff earlier than 1981 uses discrete components so if the CPU is still available should be cloneable.
- sergpanarin 6y agoNo, we use ATMegas for Keyboard and Video. About gaming and serial terminal – we had an idea to make it possible to have some pixel graphics run by our Apple-1 - e.g. to use ASCII codes above 127 as commands to video driver to set pixels or lines. Similar to how VGA registers work. So it still will be a kind of serial terminal, but it could draw graphics (TFT screen basically uses also serial connection via SPI).