3 ms·
Yeah, I know it's not actually recommended anymore, but the policy makers don't care. They're doing CYA policy. They do whatever seems to be the strongest possi
by Jtsummers 6y ago
Yeah, I know it's not actually recommended anymore, but the policy makers don't care. They're doing CYA policy. They do whatever seems to be the strongest possible thing, users and reality be damned.
I was in a team whose security group eliminated the use of DVD drives for reading (not writing) data except for a few permitted individuals. Creating a massive chokepoint in every process where data had to come from off-network. Security didn't care, it took the realization of the cost (delays, people too busy moving data to do their actual jobs) for management to step in and end the nonsense.
The same will be required for things like password policies. Until the issue becomes realized (weak/written passwords lead to a compromise), these policies will stay in place within organizations and teams. It doesn't help that the majority of the policy setters are not IT professionals (or only in the loosest sense, they can install software but have no real understanding of IT systems). In DoD, most come from a physical security background (retired/separated security forces).
- mumblemumble 6y ago> They do whatever seems to be the strongest possible thing It's not that, it's inertia and poor incentive structures. In a large organization, if a policy was set in place by someone else, then, even when you know it's a sub-par policy, it's still in your interest to leave it alone. Doing so gives you a way to deflect blame in the event of a breach related to that decision. You can just blame the policy itself. If, on the other hand, you change the policy, you're more likely to be held personally accountable. That said, you're also absolutely right about the expertise problem. I don't know much about government, but, in private industry, I've observed that the best way to get put in charge of cybersecurity is to start from somewhere completely outside of IT, and become good friends with the CEO.
- craftinator 6y ago> It's not that, it's inertia and poor incentive structures. This is the psychological/economics point of view, and I think it's the correct one for this problem. The other tricky issue, besides the CYA prioritization, is that being a dynamic entity requires other entities to do the same. If you start changing procedures in your section, other sections that rely on you need to adapt to these, and they may have the CYA attitude and resist that change.
- Godel_unicode 6y agoIt's certainly possible that in some cases that's true, but there are a lot of government check-box security people who genuinely believe complex passwords rotated frequently are a good security control. There's also a general heuristic with many people in security that the more convenient something is, the less secure it is. Therefore smart card auth must be worse!