10 ms·
Considering that Apple won't sell their chips to anybody else, and the M2, M3, Mn could be increasingly faster than the x86 chips, how long before we start movi
by pmontra 6y ago
Considering that Apple won't sell their chips to anybody else, and the M2, M3, Mn could be increasingly faster than the x86 chips, how long before we start moving along this path?
1. Amazon, Google, Microsoft start building their own chips for their own clouds. The most efficient chip could translate into the cheapest cloud, or the fastest one at the same price. Their choice.
2. There will be N somewhat compatible ARM chips, that is to say they are somewhat incompatible. Remember the home computing landscape of the 80s / early 90s but also the diversity in server architectures and OSes.
3. At least Microsoft is likely to sell their chips to third parties (they used to sell their software). Probably Amazon and Google have reasons to sell their chips too (Google -> Chromebooks)
4. Some of those chips will end up in development laptops and desktops.
5. If you want to develop for AWS you'll be safer to have a laptop with an Amazon chip, if you want to develop for Google Cloud a Google Chip, for Azure a Microsoft chip. This is not unheard of because if you want to develop for iOS you must have Apple hardware since 10+ years ago.
6. The chip manufacturer that wins the war for the developers' machines wins the war for the cloud, because it won't be possible for (let's say) Google to compete with (let's say) Amazon if Google has to buy chips from Amazon because 90% of the developers have a laptop with an Amazon chip.
Or we'll end up with 5 different laptops (unlikely) or one that connects to a remote desktop running in the appropriate cloud with the correct chip. That laptop could be a Mac or anything else, something powerful or a thin client.
So: fragmentation and then remote desktops? Back to mainframe / time sharing?
- ddorian43 6y agoThe clouds should start building their own bytes so they can get cheaper bandwidth.
- danieldisu 6y agomaybe you will be able to compile everything in the cloud and then it doesn't matter what type of computer you have
- nitrogen 6y agoThat would be the end of interesting software. Censorship at the compiler level.
- klelatti 6y agoWhat do you mean by somewhat compatible? Why fragmentation when Arm sets the ISA standard?
- nitrogen 6y agoThe base ISA is set by ARM, but every vendor has their own set of features turned on or off, and their own extensions, and potentially their own way of laying out memory mapped IO and identifying peripherals.
- klelatti 6y agoEvery vendor does not have their own set of extensions. Different x86 chips have different extensions (from a pre-defined set) - I don't see panic about x86 fragmentation.
- xxpor 6y agoIs there any difference between AMD and Intel these days in terms of instructions other than AVX512?
- klelatti 6y agoNot aware of any but there are significant extension variations even within Intel e.g. lack of AVX on Atom.
- greatpatton 6y agoIt's not panic but this is really annoying like with AVX-512. The side effect is that people are making choice for the target architecture.
- tartaglia 6y agoThere is no incentive for AWS to add restrictions like Apple with XCode. Indeed, I think that this would just reduce the amount of the customers they can reach. I don’t think that other computers manufacturers are going to follow Apple’s lead. Maybe Microsoft will do it if they decide to get serious with their Surface line. The one company I see benefiting the most from this is Qualcomm. They have the customers and the money to invest in R&D.
- geogra4 6y agoAmazon already makes their own chips on the Graviton line. I wonder how long before you can get a graviton pc? maybe never?
- tartaglia 6y agoI just had a vision: Amazon Basics Laptops
- FredFS456 6y agoI would assume that they would go under the Fire branding, like FireBook.
- easton 6y agoThat's very interesting. A CR-48 looking, basic laptop with workable keyboard and trackpad. Chrome/Chromium OS (similar to CloudReady) since all the schools are on Google. If they could get it to $249 with reasonable performance, they could crush it.
- sandworm101 6y agoThere is more to a cloud than the chips. Having the cloud chip in your dev laptop wont mean you have the same memory/power/cooling/storage services. Code optimized on your laptop, despite having the same chip, wont necessarily run perfectly in the cloud.
- tartaglia 6y agoAlso it’s the architecture that matters, not the specific chip. And we got virtualization and containers for that.
- viktorcode 6y agoJust use the gap in performance among smartphones. M1 utilises the same high performance cores A14 has. And A14 is ahead of competing Arm by roughly 2 years. Here's your answer, hardware-wise. But in the world of software things are far more complicated.
- lights0123 6y agore: 6: eh, it's less than that, as long as you're in the same architecture. Linux applications virtualized on M1, running on a Pi 4, and Graviton2 are going to be binary-compatible with each other, and although you'll get the extra atomic performance out of the M1, they won't be massively different other than just scaling up. Cross compiling after some testing to ensure the right atomic order was used should be fine cross-arch. If one were to add more ARM extensions and actually push them for third-party usage, that might change though.
- hugi 6y agoWhat utter nonsense. Different ARM chips aren't "somewhat compatible" anymore than Intel/AMD x86 chips. It's a standard instruction set. And even if we'd get different instruction sets, we have much better toolchains/compilers to work with multiple architectures now than we did in "the home computing landscape of the 80s / early 90s" (GCC and LLVM aren't really comparable to Sinclair Basic). The M1 has been out for a month and we already have hundreds/thousands of natively compiled binaries—and Windows and Linux are up and running. Choice is not a problem and competition is good.
- bhouston 6y agoI thought the m1 has dedicated js instructions.
- ssutch3 6y agoIt's just part of the ARM instruction set.
- Reason077 6y agoYeah, but any guesses as to which ARM architecture licensee submitted these instructions to the ISA? It was probably the one who was first, by several years, to implement them, right? ;)
- rsynnott 6y agoWhere'd you get that from? The m1 _does_ have one weird non-ARM extension; it can adopt an x86 memory model on demand.
- count 6y agoIt's got better/more floating point capacity, which makes it faster at JS because all the numbers in JS are floating point number.
- ducktective 6y agoWhat are js instructions and what does javascript(?) have to do with ISA?
- mirekrusin 6y agox86 line of processors is fragmented with tons of extensions.
- geogra4 6y agoI don't think any of the major cloud providers would be interested in #5. Better to have a wide open list of hardware that can develop for your platform. You can still run Windows VMs in AWS, Oracle DBs in Azure, etc.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Amazon, Google, Microsoft start building their own chips for their own clouds. At least Amazon (Graviton) and Google (TPUs) already are. Google is also reportedly looking into its own ARM CPUs for its own mobile devices (Pixel line); if it does, I can’t imagine Cloud would be far behind. > At least Microsoft is likely to sell their chips to third parties (they used to sell their software). I would expect MS would keep its chips for its hardware, rather than selling them. But, sure, either they or Google might sell to partners, to help out the ecosystem for their OS's. > If you want to develop for AWS you’ll be safer to have a laptop with an Amazon chip, if you want to develop for Google Cloud a Google Chip, for Azure a Microsoft chip. In either case, cloud-as-dev environment is being actively pushed by all players, and negates that issue. It doesn’t matter what chip (or OS, or much of anything else) I have on my laptop if my dev environment is in the same cloud that I’m deploying to.
- GeekyBear 6y ago>There will be N somewhat compatible ARM chips, that is to say they are somewhat incompatible. This isn't how ARM's architecture license works. All ARM implementations are required to pass the same standard test suite. >Architectural licensees get a set of specs and a testing suite that they have to pass, the rest is up to them. If they want to make a processor that is faster, slower, more efficient, smaller, or anything else than the one ARM supplies, this is what they have to do. https://semiaccurate.com/2013/08/07/a-long-look-at-how-arm-licenses-chips/ https://semiaccurate.com/2013/08/07/a-long-look-at-how-arm-l...
- FredFS456 6y agoSure, for the instruction set all the CPUs are required to be compatible. However, Apple seems to be going in the direction of having many many hardware accelerators builtin to their SoC and integrated into their software ecosystem. I assume that if Google and Amazon were to build their own chips, they'd do the same. Those accelerators will not be intercompatible, and we'll have a dozen different vendored drivers, like how GPUs work.
- rayiner 6y ago> However, Apple seems to be going in the direction of having many many hardware accelerators builtin to their SoC and integrated into their software ecosystem. I think this is overstated. There are quite a few differences between Intel and AMD extensions these days and they don’t create much of a problem. Apple’s architecture isn’t reliant on accelerators or special instructions to get good performance on general purpose code.
- skohan 6y agoBut it could exist right? For instance, what if MS created an ARM variant with special instructions to accelerate C# garbage collection? You could imagine a world where vertical integration throughout the entire stack leads to software which kind of works everywhere, but only really gives a good experience on 1st party hardware.
- janmo 6y agoIt has nothing to do with their architecture. Here are the facts: The M1 is a 5nm chip, while the i9 is a 14nm chip! The M1 has about 16b transistor, the i9 has only about half of that amount. No surprise the M1 is faster. Most credit should go to TSMC for being able to manufacture 5nm chips.
- tartaglia 6y agoThe surprising fact is that M1 in a 999$ MBA can beat a 3000$+ MBP 16”, or get near the performance of a desktop CPU that cost ~400$.
- cr3ative 6y agoThis... isn't a fact. It's the opposite from what I've read - the architecture is just as important as the smaller nm process. This post is good reading on the matter: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25257932 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25257932
- janmo 6y agoI really doubt the M1 would perform nearly as good if it was a 14nm chip with 8b transistors.
- redisman 6y agoThe nanometer process is not an actual standard. So it's apples and oranges to compare two fabs
- janmo 6y agoYou are right, there different ways to measure transistors, but if I recall it correctly this should not account for more than 20 or 30% difference.
- The_Colonel 6y agoof course, but no matter the standards, TSMC 5nm is significantly smaller (and efficienter) than Intel 14nm.
- Symmetry 6y agoNuvia is a startup aiming to make server chip in a more Apple style. They have some serious heaveyweight designers including people who worked on Apple's chips and have gotten a lot of investment. https://nuviainc.com/blog https://nuviainc.com/blog I don't think the most important thing here is the ISA. A64 is a pretty nice and I don't see any reason you would want to be incompatible with it, especially since getting an ARM architecture license requires you to be compatible with other ARM chips. But Amazon isn't going with Apple's very wide and deep pipeline strategy and there's nothing to say that other ARM chips would either.
- ksec 6y agoAmazon already has Graviton 2, and considering the rapid pace they are switching over their infrastructure suggest to me they are going All In. Microsoft and Oracle is partnering with Ampere. And Google is all over the map as usual, OpenPOWER, ARM, RISC-V. And I would not be surprised if they roll their own just like AWS. Marvell has ARM offering as well. ( They really should consider buying Ampere ) So it does seems like Server ARM CPU are consolidating to a few players anyway. And Despite what they claim, Ampere and Graviton 2 are pretty much customised from ARM's Server SoC reference design. Apple will have a super large M1 like design for future Mac Pro. What I am interested in is if Apple would use this, assuming rack mountable Mac Pro for their own DataCenter usage? ( i.e Installing Linux ) Or Bring back Xserve?
- beagle3 6y agoYou’ll just be developing remotely. Amazon has had graviton for a while. Google has had TPUs you can use online but can’t buy locally. What makes you think you’d have to have a local laptop? In fact, it’s in every behemoth’s interest to keep the good hardware managed and let the plebs work remotely using inferior technology.
- eeZah7Ux 6y ago> Back to mainframe / time sharing? Back to the entirely proprietary mainframe of 1970 with dumb remote terminals. But this time the mainframe performs pervasive surveillance.
- wrsh07 6y agoAll of the predictions / claims except for (1) seem very incorrect to me At the big corps that I've worked, my laptop is just a client to the machine that hosts the code & does the builds (that machine has been a giant Linux desktop & an ec2 instance) We already see Apple chips in ec2. Today it's ostensibly "rent a machine to run your test suite" (although iiuc there's a 24h minimum rental), but I don't see any reason why it won't eventually be "just run your server on an apple cloud instance on ec2" (or develop locally in a container and deploy to that) Software is actually reducing the friction of deploying to a different machine than you develop on, and the proliferation of high end custom chips isn't going to change that
- ineedasername 6y agoN somewhat compatible ARM chips, that is to say they are somewhat incompatible. Remember the home computing landscape of the 80s / early 90s but also the diversity in server architectures and OSes I'm not so sure. Or at least, I don't think a balkanized landscape like that would last very long before the market converges on some type of de-facto standard, much like things ultimately did in the 80's/90's, and late alternative ::ahem, Itanium:: failed to gain traction in the market. Also, instead of a variety of (often vendor-specific) OS's, we're really only dealing with two major candidates: Windows & Linux. Linux with its multiple distributions is more complicated, although AFAIK the main server distros there are Ubuntu, Red Hat, Debian, and CentOS. So the chips that best support these OS's would likely be the one the industry converges on, assuming it's available as a commodity component. (i.e., not just in a propriety cloud) And it would be smart to make sure desktops/laptops can run the flavor of chips running in clouds because that's where much development/coding happens.
- TYPE_FASTER 6y ago> 1. Amazon, Google, Microsoft start building their own chips for their own clouds. https://aws.amazon.com/ec2/graviton/ https://aws.amazon.com/ec2/graviton/ > 5. If you want to develop for AWS you'll be safer to have a laptop with an Amazon chip, Since I mostly work on Java that runs at Amazon, I develop locally using Amazon Corretto (https://aws.amazon.com/corretto/ https://aws.amazon.com/corretto/), less for performance than for greater confidence I won't run issues between JVM differences when deploying at AWS. > Or we'll end up with 5 different laptops (unlikely) or one that connects to a remote desktop running in the appropriate cloud with the correct chip. We're already there when deploying Python with dependencies that need to be compiled from a different OS. The options that I've used so far are 1. Only using pure Python dependencies, which mostly works, and 2. Running a container locally. Thinking about the CPU you're going to be running on might make sense if you're working on native code, but it probably won't be a big deal.
- smilekzs 6y agoIMHO even if fragmentation happens (quite likely as RISC-V gains traction), this will force developers to actually take cross platform compatibility AND performance seriously.