2 ms·
To add more context to your point, originally the "algorithms are biased" people were arguing (or strongly implying) that all algorithms were biased and that th
by throwaway894345 6y ago
To add more context to your point, originally the "algorithms are biased" people were arguing (or strongly implying) that all algorithms were biased and that they would always be biased so we should never use them (or something to that end, anyway). I don't know that their opponents were arguing that algorithms "aren't biased" as much as for a clearer understanding of what is meant by the claim "algorithms are biased" because there's no obvious definition for "bias" that lends itself to the conclusion that algorithms will always be more bias (or "worsely biased" in case that's not the same as "more bias") than people. The latter camp specifically argued that algorithms aren't inherently biased, but rather they "inherit" any biases encoded in the training data, and thus the "algorithms are biased" group would do well to frame their concerns in terms of concerns about training data sets and focus on how we can mitigate those concerns.
Over time, as is often the case with healthy debate, the "algorithms are biased" people did start to frame their concerns this way and now we have robust and productive conversations about ethically training algorithms (instead of a strict prohibition on algorithms). This is strictly a good outcome, except that some people are misremembering the argument as one group arguing that "algorithms can't be biased" in any sense of the phrase (although I'm sure there are some fringe few people for whom that's true as well, but as you point out, that was never a prominent position) and we forget that the "algorithms are biased" people weren't always making the nuanced arguments that they've been pushed to make today.
- throwawaygh 6y agoExcellent clarification; thanks for taking the time to write this up!