4 ms·
What costs more, $30,000 and 6 months, or $30,000 and 48 months?
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
What costs more, $30,000 and 6 months, or $30,000 and 48 months?
- rootlocus 6y agoI think this is the wrong question. Any commitment to education is an investment. At that point, you should be thinking in terms of ROI.
- pietrovismara 6y agoYou can think in terms of ROI only if you have enough resources to dedicate 48 months to study. Otherwise it's just a race against time to become profitable. That is, to be able to think in terms of ROI is a privilege.
- cjrp 6y agoIf you're using both the degree and the bootcamp to achieve the same goal (e.g. a paying job), then surely being ready for employment sooner is preferable?
- codingdave 6y agoNo. I can get a paying job right out of high school, while someone going to medical school will be hundreds of thousands of dollars in debt for over a decade. If you are just looking at wealth at age 25, people working in fast food made better choices than doctors. Yet somehow, 10 years later, the doctors are ahead. Clearly that is an extreme example, but it illustrates the point - getting a paying job quickly does not mean it is the best answer for long-term salary and career growth. Getting any old coding job just to get one is not the same thing as getting the full education that comes from a degree. That doesn't make it the wrong answer... getting a job matters. But if you are comparing long-term outcomes, you need to look at it with more context.
- st1x7 6y agoThe analogy doesn't scale because additional years of fast-food work don't add anything to your prospects. On the other hand, additional years of software development add a lot to your employability so the value of getting your first job is much higher. Once you have several years of experience, the lack of a 4-year degree is far less harmful to your employability.
- jcelerier 6y agoYou can get a degree for muuuuch less in europe. In france it'd be something like 1k€ at most over your whole post-high-school studies unless you go to specialized art school or something like that.
- Galanwe 6y ago(Did all my studies in France at public schools (university).) I think the fee was 300€/year, most of it was headed toward paying mandatory access to the university library. That would be 300x5=1500€ (~2k$) for a complete engineering degree. Lets not forget that all this is paid with tax money though. You will sort of pay back these studies when paying your taxes once working :)
- jcelerier 6y ago> I think the fee was 300€/year, most of it was headed toward paying mandatory access to the university library. In Bordeaux it's ~200€ for licence and ~300€ for master, but yeah, lowballed that a little bit. But ! Note that in France almost 40% of university students get the state grant (https://www.campusmatin.com/vie-campus/experience-etudiante/le-chiffre-36-8-d-etudiants-boursiers-en-2019-2020.html https://www.campusmatin.com/vie-campus/experience-etudiante/...) - and thus don't even have to pay the inscription fee. > Lets not forget that all this is paid with tax money though. You will sort of pay back these studies when paying your taxes once working :) People in the US pay income tax, too - https://www.companow.com/us-vs-france-where-do-you-pay-the-most-taxes/ https://www.companow.com/us-vs-france-where-do-you-pay-the-m...
- jokethrowaway 6y agoIn Italy, it depends on how much money you have. Under a certain threshold you don't pay anything, most people pay something, I had to pay full price which was around 3k per year. Also, forget having a campus, classrooms looks like they haven't been renovated in 200 years, you need your own computers because labs are too outdated, professors salaries are a joke, professors keep mixing their personal interests / companies with university - basically getting free work out of students for their businesses, majority of students move out of Italy after graduating because high taxes and bureaucracy make it impossible for profitable business to start up (estimated 250k€ in taxes invested in education lost per student). I'd rather live in Italy than other countries but I won't uniquely for tax reasons.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoDepends; do you get 48 months worth of education in 6 months? I doubt it. A lot of learning also takes time to process, to settle in. That said, half my 4 year software engineering education was hands-on, figure-it-out-yourself stuff; a year of internships and a ton of group projects.
- nicoburns 6y ago48 months of education still costs more, even if you get more benefit from it. And if you can't afford the time commitment then it doesn't matter how much benefit you might derive from it as it's not an available option.
- FeepingCreature 6y ago> Depends; do you get 48 months worth of education in 6 months? I doubt it. Depending on your university, focused education vs scattershot education, this actually sounds about right.
- thejosh 6y agoor an actual degree that can be used in other countries and isn't a complete joke
- bko 6y agoAverage in-state tuition is ~6.5k a year https://www.collegetuitioncompare.com/state/ https://www.collegetuitioncompare.com/state/
- dave_sullivan 6y agoBit of a fallacy to think you’ve become a better programmer by spending $5,000 per month on instruction instead of $625 per month, isn’t it? Or that the student with 6 months instruction is somehow more employable than the student with 48 months?
- sampsonitify 6y agoNeither is employable off the bat, and it takes time for someone with zero experience to be valuable. That makes question who is more employable: a student with 48 months of University, or someone with 6 months of Lambda and 2.5 years of real world experience? Note, I assumed the Lambda grad had a year unemployed.