3 ms·
>We are perfectly happy to give money to people for them to do things without fully understanding their inner thoughts and the processes behind those thoughts.
by Barrin92 6y ago
>We are perfectly happy to give money to people for them to do things without fully understanding their inner thoughts and the processes behind those thoughts.
yes, but we wouldn't say that we're programming them, which is the problem with the operational definition, it applies to everything. If my drunk uncle is great at horse-betting and I just need to give him a nice sixpack of microbrew and get measurable net worth increase out I've not turned into a computer scientist.
Hence my argument that legibility is what matters. Programmers must be able to reason, and rearrange, and understand relationship between syntax and semantics of a program.
I think it's more accurate to compare deep learning to running a sort of physical experiment, rather than programming.
- jpcooper 6y agoI agree that deep learning is not programming, and that maybe the title of the post is wrong. However, I agree with the sentiment of the article. The contexts that both operations are carried out in are closer together than the context of employing your uncle is to either. I was trying to highlight that it is more useful to focus on the similarity of the contexts and the net benefit of either method. Also, if your uncle is better than your computer, then stop programming it at all. However, if he was actually any good, then he shouldn't be talking to you, and you shouldn't be giving him any beer. Unless he was banned by the bookmaker.