6 ms·
...and yet somehow people tell me I'm crazy when I demand that software not autoupdate without user intervention. Automatic updates are RCE vulnerabilities.
by sneak 6y ago
...and yet somehow people tell me I'm crazy when I demand that software not autoupdate without user intervention.
Automatic updates are RCE vulnerabilities.
- drak0n1c 6y agoElection officials in two counties claimed that an automatic update to Dominion machines was to blame for their multi-hour outage during the election. Automatic updates are not only vulnerabilities but can undermine trust in elections. https://www.politico.com/news/2020/11/04/georgia-election-machine-glitch-434065 https://www.politico.com/news/2020/11/04/georgia-election-ma...
- HALtheWise 6y agoIn this case, it doesn't appear to me that having the update be a manual process would have made it any easier to detect.
- arkadiyt 6y agoNo one is arguing a compromise of the update server doesn't allow compromising all customers. They're arguing that the benefits out auto-updating software (especially consumer software) outweigh the risk of a compromised update server, which is generally true.
- sneak 6y agoWhat about users who don't consent to that, who would prefer to manually update in a safe manner? Making the decision for a user is the issue. Consent to run software A on Monday is not consent to run unknown/unexamined software B on Tuesday. In the vast majority of cases, receiving userspace updates in a timely fashion is not worth this real-time remote access vulnerability.
- cookiemonster9 6y agoTo be clear, given that one never knows if or when a provider has been compromised... is the plan to just not update? What if they were compromised before you initially obtained the software? There's not much that can stop attacks like this. Preventing lateral movement, escalation, exfiltration, detection, and remediation, among other things, would be the way to go.
- tedunangst 6y agoDepends how you weigh timing. If attacker doesn't know when you update, they have to hang out and risk detection at the supplier. (Who added this update?) If they can push updates, they can move quickly and compromise the target.
- sneak 6y agoThis is the key. Additionally, updates can be verified to be the same thing that everyone else got, by checking them from multiple different clients/IPs/countries. Targeted attacks are much harder, and if the compromised update is untargeted, detection risk increases drastically.
- jlgaddis 6y agoSome companies (and even some individuals) are of the opinion that, since they are "good" or "smart" or spend $x amount for "security", they aren't going to get compromised. Even worse are the ones who still concentrate their efforts on their firewalls and assume that, inside the network, all is well. They're the ones whose networks and systems are going to be completely and thoroughly "pwn3d" when someone does eventually get in. Nowadays, the general attitude amongst the "experts" is to assume that you/your company/organization WILL -- at some point -- get compromised and to, instead, plan for that eventuality and work to minimize the damage an attacker can do once they have gotten a foothold inside your network. That means doing just the things you mentioned: preventing oateral movement, privilege escalation, and exfiltration of data, concentrating on RPO/RTO (a.k.a., getting things back up and running as quickly as possible once the shit hits the fan), and so on. I've certainly not heard of anyone recommending that software and systems NOT be updated. There's only so much you can do, though. You can make sure that all of your software is only coming from "trusted sources", verify the published checksums (if any) and attached digital signatures, scan files with an up-to-date anti-virus (although, nowadays, that may not actually be worth anything), and yet STILL get hit by something like this. So, you do what you can, try to protect yourself and your organization as best you can, and prepare yourself for when the day comes that it's your name in the headlines instead of the Commerce Department and Treasury Department. (Personally, I'm of the opinion that if a nation-state wants in your network, they will -- one way or another -- get in. I'm looking forward to the day that hosts don't have a default route, are blocked at egress, and all "external" traffic has to go through firewalls and proxies before it can get out.)
- Analemma_ 6y agoIf Windows didn't autoupdate without user intervention, the number of hacks and breaches would be thousands of times higher than it is today. Ordinary people do not update if they're not forced to; it's unpleasant but true.