4 ms·
That's not what the sentence you quoted means. When you say "asset X has never traded down over a 5 year period", it means if you look at any day, and then look
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
That's not what the sentence you quoted means. When you say "asset X has never traded down over a 5 year period", it means if you look at any day, and then look at the price 5 years later, the price 5 years later will be higher. For a 12 year old asset class, just taking daily prices that means you have over 2500 pairs of prices (1 day compared to a day 5 years later) to look at, and in this case, in all of those 2500 pairs the later price was higher.
- contravariant 6y agoWell sure, but those 2500 pairs aren't exactly independent now are they? In fact you can't identify more than 2 independent pairs. You'd be better of just pointing out it increased quite a bit those two time periods of 5 years, as that would already imply that those 5-year differences were unlikely to be negative in-between. At least if Black–Scholes is to have any merit.
- drdeca 6y agoThis is a substantially better way to make the point I tried to make.
- mszcz 6y agoOk, humor me here, you guys are certainly smarter than I am. This would be based on a flawed assumption that history is a good indicator of future performance. I choose an entry point into Bitcoin somewhere in the last 12 to 5 years. From that point on, 5 years later, the price is always ahead. Those pairs as you said are not independent. How does that matter here? Edit: And why would that make a bad observation or a bad strategy?
- drdeca 6y agoI think what we are saying is mostly just talking about how strong the evidence (how it has gone) is, for the outcome that it will be like that in the future. I don't think I'm "clearly smarter", I just happen to have taken a class that said a little about stochastic processes, which I think are neat, and therefore jumped at a chance to try to apply it a little bit. I don't have any deep understanding of investment. (contravariant might though, idk.)
- contravariant 6y agoIt's not necessarily a bad observation but if you look at a lot of dependent observations then you can't simply count the number of observations. I mean sure 'it has never decreased' is slightly stronger than just the fact that it increased over 2 independent 5 year time periods, but that's mostly because 'it has increased' is a pretty weak observation. The information it adds is that it must have increased quite a bit, which you already knew. So rather than a bad observation it just doesn't tell you much, hence my tongue in cheek observation that they're basing decisions on the basis that it has happened 'twice'.
- viraptor 6y agoIt's still a weird thing to note. If the price goes down to 3k tomorrow and stays there forever, they can still make the same claim for 2 more years.