12 ms·
Fun thought (for some defn. of 'fun' anyway) - what's the 'optimum' number? Selfishly, hyper-rationally, how many children would you have? It's not zero, becau
by OJFord 6y ago
Fun thought (for some defn. of 'fun' anyway) - what's the 'optimum' number? Selfishly, hyper-rationally, how many children would you have?
It's not zero, because of their later life. But it's certainly not infinite, because of their early dependence.
I suspect on average we're pretty good at arriving at the (ever-changeable) optimum, or close to it, naturally. Maybe it's just as simple as 'as many as you can afford the childhood of'. But then, what's 'afford'.
- jhanschoo 6y agoThere's so much of this that depends on one's present circumstances.
- OJFord 6y agoSure, which is what led me to 'as many as you can afford the childhoods for'. But then, that still varies according to poor a childhood you're willing to let them have (and to live yourself for the duration).
- hawktheslayer 6y agoAnecdotal but I pushed this number to the limit with 5 kids (went for a 4th and had twins). Our pediatrician said (subjectively of course) that she found her happiest families had 4 or more kids. Not sure why that would be the case, but we are certainly a happy bunch.
- smabie 6y agoShe probably just said that because she was talking to you. The happiest people have zero kids: https://ifstudies.org/blog/does-having-children-make-people-happier-in-the-long-run https://ifstudies.org/blog/does-having-children-make-people-...
- oooooooooooow 6y ago"There is nothing intrinsic to parenthood that makes people less happy—and nothing intrinsic to parenthood that makes people any happier, for that matter." "In some countries, most notably Norway and Hungary, parents are actually happier than non-parents." The fact that having children makes people unhappy only tells a truth about societies being wrongly structured, rather than anything about the happiness of having children.
- EVdotIO 6y agoThat's also from a strictly American perspective where having children is much different in aggregate than other societies. If you look at LDS communities they tend to be a pretty happy group while having much larger families than the average US household.
- smabie 6y agowell, you probably want to have one son and many daughters. You can trade your daughters for money (dowry, bride price, etc) and put a lot resources into you son so he becomes successful and get as much reproductive access as possible. If course this is a evolutionary perspective, if you're talking about what is strictly rational for maximizing happiness, you should go with zero kids: https://ifstudies.org/blog/does-having-children-make-people-happier-in-the-long-run https://ifstudies.org/blog/does-having-children-make-people-...
- jbay808 6y agoFrom the evolutionary perspective you "should" have about as many sons as daughters, which is why you do.
- OJFord 6y agoNot really, everyone (or just every woman, or man, however) could be predisposed to whether they give birth to sons or daughters; on average then it'd still work out OK. (Might even be better, since it'd discourage interbreeding.)
- jbay808 6y agoThat's a very interesting proposal, but I wonder how it would work out in practice. As all eggs have one X chromosome, that effectively creates a system three sexes: Female, Male (X-gamete predisposition) and Male (Y-gamete predisposition), which we can call F, Mx, and My. The "x" and "y" predispositions might also be heritable with some frequency ("h"). Perhaps the predisposition is not absolute, but just a probability "p" favouring one gamete over the other. I wonder what kind of equilibrium this system would come to. For now I'll assume that females have no preference for Mx over My or vise-versa. For reductio-ad-absurdum, let's imagine what would happen with p=1 and h=1. Then Mx fathers have only daughters, and after one generation, the population is entirely My and F. After two generations, it's only My, and there is no third generation. Next let's see what would happen with p=1 and h=0. Again, Mx fathers have only daughters; My fathers now have 50% My sons and 50% Mx sons. Starting from a population that is 50% F, 25% Mx, and 25% My, the second generation is again 50% F, 25% Mx, and 25% My, and with all parents having an equal number of offspring. So at a glance that looks like a stable population, but we'd need to look deeper to see whether any initial small unbalance between F, My, Mx returns to that equilibrium or diverges, and also whether there's any advantage to a higher "h" or a lower "p" that could gradually cause those traits to spread. For example if some kids with a "p=0.5" gene have an advantage over p=1, then over time the Mx and My distinction will get wiped out and we'd just end up with M and F. I'm too lazy to analyze it but it would be an interesting system to simulate!
- gwbas1c 6y agoMy Urologist told me three was a great number when I went in for my pre-snip consult. IMO: Two if you aren't into kids and have just a boy and a girl. After that, it's all about you and your spouse's personal preference. If you want more kids, start young.