2 ms·
Strict Chinese capital controls are going to hobble CNY's utility for quite a while. Having a bunch of CNY is kind of useless if you can't freely exchange it w
by bobthepanda 6y ago
Strict Chinese capital controls are going to hobble CNY's utility for quite a while.
Having a bunch of CNY is kind of useless if you can't freely exchange it with the country in question, and the one benefit above all else is that the US hasn't had any sort of strong capital controls in modern history that might result in a dollar crunch.
(It may also be a colossal economic collapse when China lets the floodgates open, since inflated Chinese property values being the majority of domestic household investment are a symptom of the capital controls, and the ensuing rush may cause both a collapse in those values and asset inflation elsewhere.)
- xapata 6y agoContinuing the dam metaphor: Why would they open the floodgates when they can release pressure more safely?
- bobthepanda 6y agoLong term we know that opening the Chinese market would probably be the most healthy thing for global commerce. The problem is that currency markets are ruthless, and past crises with other currencies shown that it is unclear what kind of opening can and cannot be clamped down on. Opening up something innocuous may end up inadvertently creating a large crack. And the Chinese market is so large that even a trickle in releasing Chinese capital controls can be a deluge in other smaller markets. On the one hand China is not shy about reestablishing capital controls if need be, on the other hand using that as a tool makes CNY undesirable as a reserve currency.