3 ms·
Ask HN: A thought experiment about human cloning (warning: a tad macabre)
This HN submission https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25406054 about ‘How A Dead Millionaire Convinced Dozens Of Women To Have As Many Babies As Possible’
The wool gathering led me to several thought trains. Robert Heinlein and his Howard Families. About how in poor countries, people had more children because it meant more hands to work in the field. Sometimes because infants died due to illnesses and having more was the only way to ensure you had even more.
And then I remember reading at some point about parents having a child to be a donor for a health compromised older child.
Which got me thinking something macabre. One of the ways to create longer lifespans would be to have an extra set of organs/stem cells/blood. If I were to write science fiction, I would create clones and remove consciousness. Maybe this would mean a body within a head. The clone would exist just to harvest organs.
Theoretically speaking, one would need a non ageing clone. Because what’s the point of bodies and organs that continue to age.
So perhaps now we are looking at skin sacs and transferable consciousness.
Assuming this is possible, why stop with one non ageing skin sac? Why not have different avatars and different ages? It’s like we time travel for our bodies.
If such a tech were available, how many here would sign up for it to download consciousness and to obtain multiple skin sacs.
- emteycz 6y agoThis is an interesting submission in that part of what you're proposing has been discussed on HN, and the ethical dilemma got nowhere. In that discussion it was just about growing brainless humans for scientific and medical needs. I think these topics have a lot of cover area. Many people don't consider a body soulless, and many people don't consider decephalization moral to the potential human.
- jelliclesfarm 6y agoI have no qualms about decephalization. But it makes no sense to grow entire humans when we can grow just the organs. Lengthening telemores seems to be most ‘ethical’ option as of now. ETA: do you have a link for that HN thread/discussion?
- DerDangDerDang 6y agoThe Altered Carbon books / TV show explore this, both with reusing bodies and growing augmented clones.
- jelliclesfarm 6y agoYes, I remember that. It also appeals to me as in different bodies at different ages. Why look the same when we can be anything we want. What can the downside be?
- haspoken 6y agoThe Walking Transplant Trope https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/WalkingTransplant https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/WalkingTransplan...