4 ms·
Although the author doesn't say it, he does come across as implying that books don't emphasize the curiosity aspect. While this is true for Nonviolent Communica
by BeetleB 6y ago
Although the author doesn't say it, he does come across as implying that books don't emphasize the curiosity aspect. While this is true for Nonviolent Communications (NVC), I have seen it in other books. Here is an example from Difficult Conversations (DC):
> There’s only one way to come to understand the other person’s story, and that’s by being curious. Instead of asking yourself, “How can they think that?!” ask yourself, “I wonder what information they have that I don’t?” Instead of asking, “How can they be so irrational?” ask, “How might they see the world such that their view makes sense?” Certainty locks us out of their story; curiosity lets us in.
The heading of that section is Move From Certainty To Curiosity
I've always said that the NVC book is great on teaching the how but not the why, and that DC is the exact opposite. The latter gives you a lot of insight, but with a lot less practical guidance.
Similarly, the book Crucial Conversations specifies the following 4 ingredients to listening:
- Be sincere
- Show curiosity
- Stay curious (i.e. don't react)
- Be patient
- nfin 6y agoWhich book do you recommend more, Difficult conversations or Crucial conversations, or is it worth reading both? (I‘ve read NVC and love it) Edit: oh, and there are a couple books with those names, so metioning the author would be nice :)
- BeetleB 6y agoI would say both. If you had to pick one, go with DC. However, there were some things in CC that I didn't find elsewhere. As an example, it focuses on how a lot of people don't realize they're in a poor/tense conversation until it's too late, and it emphasizes the need to develop the skill to become aware of this. OTOH, CC attempts to prescribe how to behave are pretty poor. I would not focus too much effort on emulating those. At first read, all 3 sound like fairly different books. A year after I read them, I was going over all the notes I had made for them, and was surprised to find out that all 3 are mostly saying the same things. As for the authors: Difficult Conversations: https://www.amazon.com/Difficult-Conversations-Discuss-What-Matters/dp/0143118447 https://www.amazon.com/Difficult-Conversations-Discuss-What-... Crucial Conversations: https://www.amazon.com/Crucial-Conversations-Talking-Stakes-Second/dp/1469266822 https://www.amazon.com/Crucial-Conversations-Talking-Stakes-...
- kalind 6y agoI would argue that NVC emphasizes curiosity because the aim is to understand the feelings and needs (what is alive) in the other person. This requires a deep curiosity and being present in the current moment so that one can connect with what is going on in the other person. NVC does not encourage immediately asking questions to increase your intellectual understanding of the situation when someone is hurt/upset and it is not yet clear what that person wants from the interaction. For example, take the author's example sentence: "I’m furious with my husband. He’s never around when I need him.". I would say that it's pretty clear that the person is feeling furious because their need for support isn't being met. What is less clear is what the person wants from me right now. My guess would be that the person wants empathy and understanding of their pain, but it may also be that they want some advice on how to solve the problem they're having with their husband. Now this is where NVC says it's better to err on the side of the other person wanting empathy by guessing their feelings and needs (and this doesn't have to be done in the "classical" NVC way or even verbally at all depending on the situation). And if it turns out they actually wanted advice then of course it's fine to start asking questions to get a better intellectual understanding of the situation, but jumping immediately to "fixing" mode when the other person hasn't yet received sufficient empathy can be very hurtful.
- BeetleB 6y agoOh, I didn't mean to imply that NVC doesn't want you to be curious. Just that the book focuses on getting you practice curiosity without telling you that the point of these questions is to spark curiosity, which leads to empathy. The problem the author had with the example is the response has a little too much mirroring. Your response: > I would say that it's pretty clear that the person is feeling furious because their need for support isn't being met. Is better as it is rephrased, and mentions support.
- cainxinth 6y ago“Instead of asking yourself, “How can they think that?!” ask yourself, “I wonder what information they have that I don’t?” Not being facetious at all, but that heuristic doesn’t work for anti-maskers. The information they have is widely viewable on Trump’s Twitter feed and Newsmax. I know what they know and I still have trouble understanding how they can think the way they do.
- loopz 6y agoIt's still possible to understand, although not condoning toleration of lies: https://theconversation.com/why-hard-core-trump-supporters-ignore-his-lies-144650 https://theconversation.com/why-hard-core-trump-supporters-i... It is often a facet of populists and underdogs, that they do not understand what is required of power. Also, if intimidation and lies have been tolerated in school and working lives without reprecussions, it may be part of the conditioning creeping up into seats of power. Look at it as a mirror of consequences. Stay curious.
- mistermann 6y agoHonestly, how would you know what they know, from skimming a few articles or watching a few videos? Can you genuinely not see the flaw in this thinking?
- cainxinth 6y agoI read and watch their media all the time: Fox News, Newsmax, OAN, Drudge, NY Post, Trump's Twitter, etc. I used to lurk /r/the_donald on reddit and /pol/ on 4chan back in the day. I'm fiscally moderate and socially liberal, but... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DWjJlErBPX4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DWjJlErBPX4
- mistermann 6y agoI was referring to this: > that heuristic doesn’t work for anti-maskers. > I still have trouble understanding how they can think the way they do. Indeed you have watched some media, and you have observed some behavior, but you are extrapolating that into a confident perception of knowing what an entire group of people comprehensively think and believe, are you not? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_mind https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_mind If you were to observe someone else doing the same but with a different logical grouping, say, by ethnicity or certain religions, would you consider that acceptable?
- benkuhn 6y agoThanks for the recommendation! Sounds like I may have just been reading the wrong books :)
- agumonkey 6y ago> - Be sincere my issue is that 90% of the time, my sincerity would mean leaving the convo