4 ms·
Wow, this feels like something out of the mid-2000s. The problem with the semantic web is that the incentives are mostly wrong. People make websites to be view
by bawolff 6y ago
Wow, this feels like something out of the mid-2000s.
The problem with the semantic web is that the incentives are mostly wrong. People make websites to be viewed by people. Doing the semantic stuff is work that can be difficult to get right. If it doesn't bring you visitors, why would (most) people bother.
Sure you can get fancy tools that use the data (lets ignore the scaling issues that many of them have), but fancy tools separates the data from the context, further reducing incentives (for many content creators). If they ever did take off, we would have massive spam/quality problems, because we have now separated the data from the website, with all the visual indicators of how spammy it is, which is perfect for dark SEO and other spammers/phisers.
For that matter, just look at metadata on the web in general and what a mess that is. <meta name=description (or keywords) - spammers took over and nobody use them. <link rel="next" i think old opera is the only thing to ever do anything with that metadata.
The only metadata systems that have ever worked is when the site author gets something out of it: e.g. technocrati tags, <link> to rss feeds, facebook opengraph, various google things, etc. Or on the other side, when that is their whole reason for being, like https://wikidata.org https://wikidata.org and maybe some glam stuff. Everyone making arbitrary metadata out of the goodness of their heart, and having it be of consistent quality and meaning is a pipe dream.
Not to mention the negative incentive of obliterating the walled garden which as much as it sucks is something the corporate overlords like a lot.
- jka 6y agoTo be honest, I think we already have the spam/quality issues[1], it's just that web spidering systems have to wade through and discard most of the presentation-layer cruft before they begin to determine the value of the content. Allowing users to access information more directly and reducing the cost + complexity of content extraction seem like worthwhile goals. [1] Edit: clarification: even in embedded semantic web data (microformats, etc)
- holri 6y ago> because we have now separated the data from the website That is why microformats exists. With it the visual representation is at the same time semantic and parseable. https://indieweb.org/microformats https://indieweb.org/microformats
- usrusr 6y agoI think it can be summed up as people show zero constraint lying to machines. Both on the the personal and on the organizational level. The meta tag was about as truthful and useful as age verification with a big "Yes (I'm 18 or older)" button that has all the UI trappings of a default operation. We need to stop reading the "web" in semantic web as the post-Gutenberg form of publishing and take a step back, consider it an archipelago of (semi-)independent databases. It's about schema, not about text markup.