3 ms·
Ask HN: If you merge PRs from GitHub bots do you own full repo copyright?
I basically automatically merge "security" and "dependency" updates from GitHub. Until today I never thought about the copyright implications. I want to maintain copyright ownership of my repos, so do I need a copyright assignment from GitHub? I think it's an interesting issue, because if you accept a contribution from a human author, they obviously have a copyright claim over your repo...but what's the situation with these bot commits from GitHub? Does GitHub have some control over my work in a copyright sense now, in that if I want to sell license exemptions for corporates, or sell ownership of the repo, do I need to get some sort of release, or assignment or permission from GitHub?
- speedgoose 6y agoI wonder if one can claim a copyright on updating a list of dependencies with version tags. It's not really creative work.
- graderjs 6y agoI'm thinking more because they made a contribution they're a "contributor" who has copyright in the work. I think that's the case, I just wonder what the deal is with bots as per my question.
- yorwba 6y agoBeing a contributor and owning copyright are two different things, because not all contributions are copyrightable. When a photographer takes a picture, the camera manufacturer contributed to the result (some smartphones even add a "shot with X camera" watermark by default) but that doesn't mean they own copyright. When an author uses a spell checker that suggests a correction, that doesn't grant the spell checker copyright of the resulting novel. The copyright owner of a mechanically produced creative work is the person who provided the input, not the person who built the mechanism.
- graderjs 6y agoThat's a nice sentiment that I understand and I get the argument. Tho I'll need and am hoping for a more reliable legally sound comment from GitHub or someone who's qualified to answer definitively. I'm also thinking about the case of, like, a typo contribution to a README, and considering if that would give a "contributor" a copyright claim on an owner's repo that the owner would need to get a release / assignment from when that owner wanted to sell their work. If that did, then it's sort of like a very low-effort "copyright troll" action to go around and make very small typo contributions on projects that don't have copyright assignment agreements, because then that work is forever beholden to that "contributor" in any future sale due diligence, I would imagine. I'm hoping I'm incorrect about this, but I do not have the legal background to know either way, hence the Ask HN.