3 ms·
Strong disagree with what you define as the "traditional, long-established" meaning. It is a departure from colloquial use to describe property damage as viole
by whimsicalism 6y ago
Strong disagree with what you define as the "traditional, long-established" meaning.
It is a departure from colloquial use to describe property damage as violent and it is counterintuitive to describe a "violent protest in which no one was hurt."
- hn_throwaway_99 6y ago> It is a departure from colloquial use to describe property damage as violent Maybe with your colloquialisms, but as someone in their mid 40s, I've never thought of violence in the narrow way you are describing it, and it does seem to me like this is a relatively recent redefinition of the term. I've always thought the primary characteristic of "violence" is rageful, wild, physical destruction, regardless of whether it was directed at a human or property. For example, graffiti and a riot that burns down a building are both forms of property destruction, but only one is violent. Similarly, killing someone with a chainsaw and killing someone by poison are both forms of murder, but only one is violent.
- rualca 6y ago> It is a departure from colloquial use to describe property damage as violent and it is counterintuitive to describe a "violent protest in which no one was hurt." I don't believe your assertion is remotely true. The term "vandalism" has its origins on how the Vandals tribe attacked, invaded and sacked Rome, and it refers to violence which results in widespread property damage. You'd be hard pressed to describe 5th century barbarian invasion with words other than violence. And by the way, car crashes are also described as violent even when no harm comes to anyone involved.
- true_religion 6y agoIt’s kind of weird though to say that someone burning down your house isn’t violence just because you aren’t in it. If it’s not violence it’s something equally bad not a prosaic term like “property damage” or “vandalism” which would imply you still have the property and only need to clean it up a bit.