2 ms·
> ...should there be any punishment for taking something classified and putting it into public domain... "something" is a word that goes to a core issues of th
by roenxi 6y ago
> ...should there be any punishment for taking something classified and putting it into public domain...
"something" is a word that goes to a core issues of the whole thing. For democracy to function, people need to be able to argue that things are bad ideas.
Say the military classifies a video because it would undermine public support for a war. There should be no punishment for leaking that, as it is information that is relevant to the public - if it would sway their decision making, then it shouldn't be kept from them.
Say the military classifies troop deployments that are irrelevant to all public decision making - leaking that should be punishable.
So to decide if something is punishable or not, we have to deal with a specific issue and make a judgement on whether that specific issue could reasonably have influenced public decision making.