3 ms·
I have a friend whose car was torn apart with a knife by cops during a traffic stop. Cops didn't find whatever they thought they would, and my friend was never
by heavyset_go 6y ago
I have a friend whose car was torn apart with a knife by cops during a traffic stop. Cops didn't find whatever they thought they would, and my friend was never charged with anything.
According to the law, none of his rights were violated. He can't recoup the thousands of dollars he had to pay after having his car destroyed by cops, either.
- phkahler 6y ago>> He can't recoup the thousands of dollars he had to pay after having his car destroyed by cops, either. Is that his lawyers opinion or theirs? Would this ruling change that?
- heavyset_go 6y agoIf I'm recalling it correctly, he said something about it being legal search based on probable cause, and that the cops aren't liable for damage done during a search. I doubt this ruling will change anything, because his rights weren't violated according to the law. I shared it because cops can do a lot of damage based off of a hunch, and there isn't much you can do about it if they don't blatantly violate your rights while doing so.
- frankydp 6y agoMost of these statements are inaccurate in almost all states. Most department have a clerk that specifically handles these types of claims. Unless there is a bunch of other details around the arrest, would probably be worth the time to file a claim.
- solidsnack9000 6y agoThis has to do with qualified immunity. It's not so much that his rights weren't violated, as that, per qualified immunity, it doesn't matter, because there is not a very close precedent (like, once upon a time, some sheriffs cut apart a stage coach interior with a bowie knife and got charged) that can be used to base a ruling on. If that seems like a strange doctrine to you, you're not alone! https://www.cato.org/blog/may-15th-supreme-court-will-finally-decide-whether-hear-cases-calling-abolition-qualified https://www.cato.org/blog/may-15th-supreme-court-will-finall... I wonder if this ruling does not have an impact on qualified immunity as a sustainable doctrine. In this ruling, SCOTUS has recognized a claim against law enforcement for rights violations not by finding a matching precedent but by reasoning from (recent) positive law.
- closeparen 6y agoWhy would police need to personally reimburse the costs of a search? This seems like something the department should have to pay for. Qualified immunity has no bearing on that.
- solidsnack9000 6y agoQualified immunity has to do with what the OP was talking about -- about whether rights are considered to be violated.
- webinvest 6y agoThat’s awful but it happened to one of my family members. She no longer consent to US police car searches even though she’s never in contact or possession of drugs simply because she doesn’t want her car to embarrassingly get ripped apart by police again (unreimbursed).