11 ms·
Understanding mRNA Covid-19 vaccines
- jbaudanza 6y agoDoes the fact that Covid-19 is an RNA virus make it easier to target with an mRNA-vaccine? Could this technology also be used to target a DNA virus as well?
- rolph 6y agoin short, yes; and yes. the limitation is an understanding of the virus+host interaction at the level of molecular structure and function. when you have the amino acid sequence of a protien that triggers the immune system you can work backward and derive an mRNA that would be responsible for coding the protien. there are multiple layers of complexity in getting from stage 1 to end product but this is a quick simple layout. DNA virus has some extra tricks compared to RNA virus but the core concept is the same for both.
- bilal4hmed 6y agoWould such a technique help an immune compromised or suppressed person ?
- rolph 6y agoan immune compromised person may require larger repeated doses, or a different/concurrent strategy such as antibody infusion
- wittyreference 6y agoThe vaccine in this instance is all about delivering a target to the immune system's sentries. If those sentries are defective, or if the hitmen the sentries need to alert are defective, there's nothing this vaccine can do to change that. "Immune compromise" is generally used as a blanket term, but in many people there are specific immune deficiencies, which may or may not factor into the pathway being targeted here. For instance, natalizumab screws with immune cells' translocation across membranes, and shouldn't play a role in responding to a vaccine (I mean, if it wasn't off the market anyway). If it's a general immune dysfunction (cancer, diabetes), they will see some benefit, but it will be much reduced - specifically because both responding to the vaccine, and responding to the virus post-vaccination, require the activity of the immune system. What this means precisely will vary with the degree and nature of the immune dysfunction: some folks might see some antibody response, and benefit from repeat dosing. Others might fail to seroconvert altogether, in which case it is what it is.
- jbaudanza 6y agoI see, thanks for the reply! I was thinking that maybe because Covid is an RNA virus, there would be a shortcut to getting the mRNA sequence for creating the spike protein. The scientists could peek at the RNA in the actual virus, recognize the spike protein, and put that in the vaccine. Whereas with a DNA virus, it would require extra work. But from your answer, it sounds like that's not what they do? Or, maybe they could do that but it's not any easier than working backwards from the amino acid sequence. This stuff is all very interesting!
- rolph 6y agothe short cut is that DNA virus has a further layer of code utilization , the DNA must be read out and transcribed to mRNA, then translated to protien. there is an extra step in there, but you can still use a synthetic mRNA to create a protien specific to putative antigens decorating the surface of the DNA virus, or of the infected cell, or both if your rich and want to make sure. a DNA virus must be understood somewhat to find the reading frame for the protien you need, this is the case for RNA virus as well however RNA virus are limited in size due to the instability of RNA, this means less kruft to wade through until you find the FOO
- raphaelj 6y agoIs there a reason they don't create the protein in Vito and them inject it as a vaccine? I would imagine they could use in Vito cells to generate a lot of spike proteins. Are they using mRNA because it's easier to manufacture? Or is the protein too instable?
- rolph 6y agothe protien, and the mRNA would be instantly degraded outside the cell. the liposomal capsule holding the mRNA has been engineered to deliver the mRNA to the cell and fuse with it delivering the mRNA confoundingly the mRNA is fragile thus the ultracold dryice freezer required for holding. the protien is stable on its own, but will be destroyed by exocytic proteases unless shielded by insertion into a membrane
- nicwilson 6y agoNo. Yes. This approach is like sneaking in blueprints to a factory (cell) that makes (proteins using mRNA) whatever it has blueprints for, and gets inspectors that come around occasionally (immune surveillance), or very frequently under active infection, looking for contraband. When the body start producing this foreign proteins in the presence of something to trigger the immune system (called an adjuvant which all vaccines use to make the body recognise as bad and not harmless/irrelevant) the immune system starts producing a response against that.
- rolph 6y agoadjuvent is not neccesary for immune response, it is nessecary for spreading out the antigen producing character among more doses, rather than using a concentration of mRNA that in itself produces enough protien to induce immune response
- nicwilson 6y agoWhat? > adjuvent [sic] is not neccesary[sic] for immune response, Completely false. Unless the immune system has been exposed to something similar before (e.g. SARS/MERS n.b. made up example I have no idea if the spikes of SARS or MERS are molecularly similar enough), no adjuvant means situation normal for the immune system. If there is nothing to signal to the immune system that this new antigen is bad then it will treat it as neutral suppressing any vaccine response, which is worse that if the vaccine had not been delivered at all. >is nessecary[sic] for spreading out the antigen producing character among more doses the point of booster shots is to ensure that antibodies are maintained at sufficient levels to fight off a real infection. If a response has been established, i guess adjuvants are not as necessary? (did biomed, but not a vaccine researcher) I have no idea if they are included or not for boosters. > rather than using a concentration of mRNA that in itself produces enough protien[sic] to induce immune response A high concentration won't do shit if the immune system doesn't have anything to activate it, it will just see a high concentration of irrelevant new, i.e. foreign protein.
- rolph 6y ago
- lrossi 6y agoOne thing that I don’t understand is what happens to the cells in which the mRNA enters. Do they die? Do they go haywire? How are the spike proteins getting out of them? And if the cells die, how many of them are going to be affected by one shot?
- rolph 6y agoits a game of numbers and timing. first off there is a patrol inside that cell that cleans up mRNA that doesnt have a "hall pass" cells that are very damaged or confused will go into a procedural death mode called apoptosis, different from simple cell death as others are imformed of events and can react accordingly. as soon as the cell expresses S protien the immune system may then tag it and take a sample then produce a great many antibodies for the price of a small number of cells death relative to the large number of antibodies
- rolph 6y agoaddendum >>there is a halflife/turnover rate, in tech terms the hardware is updated very frequently, by degradation, and replacement. this is loosely what creates a constituatively expressed proteome. the S protien is not part of the program so is degraded and not replaced. if the protien insertion is too extensive or the activity of the protien is egregious for the cell then, apoptosis
- throw9678 6y agoIf you (or others) would humor a newbie question - assuming that host cells start expressing the spike protein, and the immune system learns to react to it, what are the chances that it will also learn to react to other proteins expressed by those cells, which are not related to the virus, and basically learn to attack its own cells? In other words, is there a worry of MRNA causing auto-immune reaction/disease due to those proteins getting expressed by host's own healthy cells?
- rolph 6y agothere is a self recognition system, the body indexes its components and will end process when the protien is recognized as self. foriegn molecules are not indexed and if large enough [as in protiens, not water or salt] they will trigger immune response a wanted poster and a bunch of antibodies are produced that tag the invader. the mRNA of concern will not modify your DNA sequence, the expression of the S protien occurs untill the mRNA is destroyed by the cell, or the cell itself is destroyed taken apart and compared to self antigens, the foriegn antigen is expressed by MHC cells and PresenteD in a context of this is a hostile thing [a wanted poster] this all occurs in a system of interdependent cell types and thier interactions. your question addresses the crux of immunology, and needs a lot more attention than would be constructive here. put on your reading cap and check this out: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immunology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immunology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autoimmune_disease https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autoimmune_disease
- ffwd 6y agoI know nothing about this so excuse any potential ignorance: They say: >COVID-19 mRNA vaccines give instructions for our cells to make a harmless piece of what is called the “spike protein.” The spike protein is found on the surface of the virus that causes COVID-19. So from what I understand the vaccine itself does not contain the spike protein but is simply RNA that is injected into the cell and then the cell goes through its usual process to translates* the RNA to amino acids which then gets churned into protein (the spike protein)? My first question is how did they make the RNA? Is it the exact same RNA as in the coronavirus or is it artificially generated by them? Does it do the exact same thing that the RNA in coronavirus does and is the spike protein the exact same spike protein found on the surface of the coronavirus or is it different (even if subtly so?) Can anything go wrong at any point in this process (can the body misuse the RNA, or the spike protein, or anything else) and if so what? *edited
- Pfhreak 6y agoI believe that they manufactured the rna without access to the virus, just the genome. I am not qualified to answer whether the spike protein is identical to the one in the virus, but from what I understand it is very close. The protein just doesn't have the virus attached. It's like having a factory manufacturing car door handles but no cars. Things could go wrong, mostly because some folks may have allergic reactions, autoimmune flare ups, or the increased immune response can cause side effects like Bell's palsy. That said, mRNA breaks down quickly on its own, and the spike proteins will be cleaned up quickly. The odds of a serious complication are very, very, very, very low from the studies performed so far. (Expect some flu like symptoms, however, as your body fights the cells with the modified RNA.) I'm a total layperson here, just synthesizing what I've read.
- wittyreference 6y agoI'll add a point, because otherwise your answer was excellent: This mechanism was once explored as a means of performing gene therapy in human beings (a couple of decades past). It was abandoned because of its utter failure to produce lasting genetic effects. That's a big plus here: we have a well-explored platform for having the cells transiently produce a protein we want the immune system exposed to, but which we already know is useless at producing lasting effects. The only lasting effect here will be in the memory of the immune system, not in the cells affected by the shot.
- scott00 6y agoDoes anyone understand why the FDA and other experts seem very unconcerned about long term side effects? The safety profile in the 0-2 month timeframe is very easy to understand: they tested it, so they have actual data. But it seems for longer than 2 or 3 months you would need to make an argument based on animal trials or just biological reasoning. But I can't find anyone talking about it at all.
- TheAdamAndChe 6y agoThey are concerned, but it's a balancing act. COVID itself is a new virus with unknown long term side effects, and it's killing millions while causing massive economic harm triggering political destabilization in some areas. The vaccine is new and may cause issues, but current data doesn't indicate it will cause issues and it prevents death and sickness by COVID very effectively.
- throw9678 6y agoAs mentioned in the Nature article and in another poster's comment[1], MRNA vaccines have been known for a while now (decade+ ?), and studied on animals, with some limited phase I / phase II human studies. But nobody's gone through a full phase III before covid hit, so that kind of a wide fan-out is new and exceptional because of the emergency nature of the disease. But I don't think they're unconcerned. I think it's a combination of lack of decades-long longitudinal studies, and also that previous phase I / II studies haven't throw up significant red flags. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25403560 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25403560
- reader_1000 6y ago> But nobody's gone through a full phase III before covid hit, Do you know why nobody did not conduct phase III before? Is it because of safety concerns or lack of necessity since concerned disease disappeared?
- detaro 6y agoAFAIK some of the breakthroughs in the delivery mechanisms are relatively new. Some of the companies now making a covid vaccine were talking about running a trial for a flu vaccine in the next few years, but obviously that was far less urgent and all the steps (getting permission, getting participants, actually running the study without "unlimited" money, ...) would take longer. (mRNA would be a good candidate for a flu vaccines because they are fast to produce, which in theory reduces the amount of guessing needed to make the "right" flu vaccine for the year, but of course a) flu vaccines already are a thing even if sometimes wrong and b) a flu vaccine isn't given as high priority overall)
- tedunangst 6y agoThis paper from two years ago answers a lot more questions about how mRNA vaccines work, how long the mRNA stays active, how to prevent runaway infection, etc. https://www.nature.com/articles/nrd.2017.243 https://www.nature.com/articles/nrd.2017.243
- kleton 6y agoHave they released the rna sequences of the pfizer and moderna vaccines? I could not find them in the patents or supplementary information in the journal papers. It would go a long way towards public trust if they released this information.
- ceejayoz 6y ago> It would go a long way towards public trust if they released this information. No, it wouldn't. The goal posts would immediately move.
- kleton 6y agoNormal drugs are required to have the chemical structure in the packaging. I wonder why they are allowed to release this one without similar chemical information.
- ceejayoz 6y agoThe Pfizer vaccine: https://go.drugbank.com/drugs/DB15696 https://go.drugbank.com/drugs/DB15696 > BNT162b2 is a nucleoside modified mRNA (modRNA) vaccine encoding an optimized full-length version of the SARS-CoV-2 spike (S) protein... which appears to be entirely public (along with the rest of the SARS-CoV-2 genome): https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/gene/43740568 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/gene/43740568
- cblconfederate 6y agothe BNT162b2 sequence itself is not available though
- ceejayoz 6y agoThe sequence is that of the protein. That's how it works. The vaccine contains the mRNA sequence for the protein, so cells produce it, triggering an immune response. The "nucleotide modified" bit just means they replace some nucleotides with nucleotide isomers like pseudouridine (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pseudouridine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pseudouridine) to keep the vaccine itself from being attacked. The sequence remains the same.
- wenc 6y agoReposting this: these two videos answers a bunch of questions that are in the comments. Here's a 5 minute video explaining mRNA vaccines in laymen's terms (Cliff-Notes style) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=the81FQoAUI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=the81FQoAUI Here's a longer, more technical, 43 minute video explaining them and the Moderna/Pfizer/BioNTech/Astrazeneca clinical trial processes in more detail. The biochem part starts at 12:30. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=35Idb_lCU4o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=35Idb_lCU4o
- vmception 6y agoThe real question is whether any of that protein folding helped at all over the last two decades
- thrower 6y agoThe CDC site provides information in other languages as well if you’d like to share with family/friends in your community!
- mrfusion 6y agoAnyone know the answer? If we can encase an rna sequence in a lipid envelope and get it into cells, why haven’t viruses ever evolved something like this? It seems like an easy run around the defenses of the cell?
- rolph 6y agothis is how natural virii function, not all but a whole family of them. some virii use a protien capsule others are actually a naked RNA strand. and yes it is the first run around of defenses, but there are a number of other hurdles.
- crazydoggers 6y agoAn important thing to keep in mind is that viruses do this type of thing in your body all the time. Your cells are constantly being programmed by viruses to generate proteins that are used to build viruses, many using messenger RNA (like coronavirus). Obviously this will be the first wide spread use of a vaccine using a mechanism viruses have used for millions of years. So although care, caution, and respect are clearly justified, I’d just like to see a little more public education on how viruses work in the first place. It’s easy for the public to hear “the government is programming your cells” and not even understand the basics of how cells or viruses work in the first place.